The question of how the case is to be handled raises more issues. Anticipating further protests, the police have been deployed across New Delhi. There is also talk from members of government about making the names of the convicted rapists and sex offenders public, in the hope that they will be denied employment and socially ostracised. Indian rights activists, meanwhile, point out that more often it is the victims who suffer stigma rather than the perpetrators — with this factor leading to a situation where many rapes are never reported at all.
This, unfortunately, is a situation familiar to us in Pakistan as well. Gang rape is a crime we know much about. The question for us, as for India, is how to make our cities and indeed our villages and towns safe for women. The answers lie in inevitably punishing those behind such crimes. However, this does not happen often enough. The answer also lies in empowering women, raising their status and creating more public disapproval for such atrocities. The street clashes and protests in Delhi depict anger but they are still restricted to far too small a group. In India, and everywhere else, the protests need to be bigger, wider and sustained through peaceful means so that longer-term change can finally be achieved before other women fall victim to similar horrors. This must not be permitted.
Published in The Express Tribune, December 30th, 2012.
COMMENTS (8)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Cynical
Spot on. But it might take hundreds of years for any change in this misogynistic behaviour in much of the under developed world.
This incident is horrible. There is a culture of "chalta hai" towards everything bad speciallly crimes against women. The system is morally bankrupt from head to toe. No protests are effective enough for a lasting and meaningful change. This would not happen in western societies. But in India this is endemic and acceptable! No woman - rich or poor is safe. In the end, the victims are blamed for doung it to themselves! Shame on India that is "shining" and raping with impunity. Quit investing in this kleptocracy that masquerades as a democracy!
Horrendous by any standards. Kudos to the civil society for hitting the streets in an effort to bring much needed social change in attitudes and actions.
The recent gang rape in Delhi is indeed a subject of concern wherein the wide protests across the nation have pushed forward the desired action against the offenders. Although the work is still far from complete as the trial shall take its own time to be followed by appeals and thus the entire issue shall get cooled down during the long period.This is not a question of such an incident having taken place in the national capital of India but, a problem that remains existent in the Indian society and such incidents happen from time to time in various parts of this nation. One can say that a rape a day is normal in this nation. Indeed a hundred percent full proof strategy is next to impossible as there are various constraints that exist. Moving on to a wider connotation from rape to the issue of crimes committed against women in India wherein rape is just a single kind of crime. There are cases of molestation in public places and at work places as well as within the house, harassment for dowry, eve teasing, human trafficking etc. The most unfortunate side of the story is that rapes that are generally brought to public notice are those that take place in a secluded spot say an old dilapidated building, a bus or vehicle, or in a hotel however there are cases that go unreported wherein a girl or lady is subjected to a forced sexual intercourse by the other male members of her family be it her family or that of her spouse. In addition sexual exploitation of women at the work place goes on unabated and in many instances women allow a leeway in order to get a good increment or promotion in their job or are financially too weak to resist to such advances. The problem is rather serious but has perhaps never got the desired attention from the government. There is therefore a need to enact stringent laws to check crimes against women.As regards rape and human trafficking the most stringent of all punishments would be life imprisonment accompanied with a chemical castration which is essential to inculcate a fear in the minds of the offender as well as those who have similar intentions. Also the culprit having completed his sentence in prison should continue to live with that guilt which may lead to suicide too and a rise in the cases of suicides but this aspect needs to be overlooked if this is able to bring down the cases of rape and human trafficking in the country. Similar laws are needed to check the other kinds of crime against women. However an essential deterrent needed is to ensure that the laws are not misused at any point of time to harass men or to be used as a tool for blackmail. Police Reforms that has been lying in the files but not been implemented too is essential and this department needs to be given a free hand to tackle the offenders involved in any kind of crime committed against women. The police as an institution needs to be made more effective hence a greater autonomy needs to be given to the policeman to tackle crime especially that which is committed against women.Besides India the subject of women concerns the entire globe but in most international summits the issue remains dormant or is given the lowest priority. I request your kind self to ensure that this issue of crime against women; which is happening not just in India but in many other nations of South Asia and the world; is discussed during these international summits. The Non-Aligned Group of nations (NAM), the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC), Association of East Asian Nations (ASEAN) and the Commonwealth of Nations (CWN) are the forums where problems regarding women and crimes committed against them should be discussed and the other nations too must work on similar lines to check crimes against the women in their country. There is a dire need to change the perception about women in this country and the other nations. Talking of India where even today women are treated like a piece of property or a physical object and does not enjoy the status given to them under the Constitution of India. The honour killings in certain states of India is yet another kind of crime committed that needs to be checked. The status of the Indian woman unfortunately remains that of a doormat which needs to be changed if the nation has to move forward and become one of the leading nations of the world.
This is all because of the culture, that we are so proud of.Girls are inferior, girls are a burden boy will help run the family etc etc. We need to get rid of this culture that is so gender biased.The solution to all the problems is education and more education.Protest against the government is not gonna change anything,protest should be against the illiteracy,poverty and so called culture.Hopefully one day we will have educated india that respect all human beings,especially Women
I agree with every word that you have written. As an Indian leader said, the whole Indian nation needs to hang its heads in shame at the humiliation that this girl has had to suffer. The point is attitudes towards women in India are still largely governed by a male chauvinist view that women are property of their men, whether husband, father, brother, or son. That used to be the main story of Indian society in the past. Unfortunately, in the 65 years since independence not much has changed in India. We still continue to hold a feudal attitude in most matters, especially where women are concerned, but also in most other matters. This attitude of contempt towards women is seen in the behaviour of men AND WOMEN towards the less fortunate of the society, the service community (Class IV, you know) and domestic workers, etc. Everybody in the so-called upper classes of society thinks that the 'lower orders' are but chattel and slaves who may be treated in whatever manner their employers like. Even in ordinary manner of speaking to them this attitude of the employers is always in evidence. I am sorry to read that things are much the same in Pakistan. Both countries need to take early steps for the amelioration of the condition of women. V. C. Bhutani, Delhi, India, 30 Dec 2012, 0605 IST