The Lahore High Court (LHC) has instructed government-employed doctors to return to work at all hospital wards and end their strike completely from Sunday, while also suspending termination, suspension and show cause notices issued to the striking doctors by the Punjab government.
The court also directed the committee set up to review the doctors’ demands to start negotiations with the Young Doctors Association (YDA) and conclude them within two weeks, while regularly updating the LHC on the minutes of committee meetings.
On Friday, Justice Ijazul Ahsan of the LHC had directed the doctors to “show good will by calling off the strike immediately and commencing work at emergencies at 9am on Saturday”.
Members of the YDA have been boycotting their jobs at outpatient departments at public hospitals since June 18. They expanded the strike to include emergency wards earlier this month after the Punjab government adopted a more aggressive approach to try and end it.
While the YDA took Friday’s order to mean they could continue with their strike at wards other than emergency care, Justice Ahsan made clear in Saturday’s order that he expected the doctors to return to work at all wards from 8pm on Sunday.
Asked by reporters outside the courtroom if the YDA would now end its strike, YDA Punjab President Dr Hamid Butt and General Secretary Dr Sohail Nasir said that this would be decided at a meeting of the YDA’s general council.
Muhammad Azhar Siddiqui, counsel for the petitioners who had challenged the strike in the LHC, said that the YDA representatives’ statement was tantamount to contempt of court. He said that he would file a contempt plea on Monday against the doctors if they did not return to work.
Harassment and contempt
In Saturday’s proceedings, YDA counsel Advocate Raja Zulqarnain said that the government was continuing to harass the young doctors despite the court’s unambiguous instructions on Friday to desist. He said that doctors had been served show cause and termination notices after Friday’s proceedings, which showed the government’s contempt for the court orders.
Additional Advocate General Faisal Zaman rejected the charge, saying that the show cause notices and termination letters had been issued to the doctors on Friday morning, before the court gave its directions.
He argued that all the actions taken by the government were lawful under the Punjab Employees Efficiency, Discipline and Accountability Act. He said after the court’s orders, the health secretary had issued a notification mentioning the LHC order and forwarded it to the home secretary, the Lahore police chief and other departments concerned.
Justice Ahsan asked the YDA counsel to file a separate petition against the alleged harassment. He gave the YDA president time to detail the allegedly illegal actions taken by the government against the protesting doctors.
The judge assured the doctors that the court would not allow any illegal action. He said that the doctors’ demands for a revised service structure were not unreasonable.
Zaman argued that the service structure matter was before the Supreme Court and the LHC should await its verdict. He said a committee set up by the SC had already proposed a service structure.
About the murder case against several doctors at Mayo Hospital over the death of a child, Advocate Zulqernain said that the government had passed the Punjab Healthcare Commission Act in 2010 under which the police could not register murder cases against doctors until the matter was referred to the commission. He said a case could only be registered against doctors under Section 322 (manslaughter).
But Zaman argued that Section 322 applied only if a patient died while receiving medical treatment. In this case, he said, the infant died because he was denied medical treatment.
He said that the child had been buried without an autopsy but the police would exhume the body to determine cause of death. On the request of the father, the judge ordered the government to set up a medical board to supervise the exhumation process and the post-mortem. The court also directed the investigating officer to submit a challan by Monday against the doctors involved in the murder case.
Representatives of the Young Doctors Association were asked in court if they would end their strike completely if the arrested doctors were released. They were unable to give a definitive answer on this.
The judge directed the assistant advocate general to present arguments on why a murder case had been registered against the doctors when the hearing resumes on July 13. He asked the YDA counsel to file a separate petition for the cancellation of the murder FIR.
Published in The Express Tribune, July 8th, 2012.
COMMENTS (11)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Not every decision of apex courts are under the influence of PML-N, grow up people. learn to appreciate good decisions even if they are are not-so-good people of your dictionary. Whatever the demands of YDA is , risking the lives of poor, who have nothing to do with this rift, is not the solution
When the government cannot pay for electricity how can it pay the salaries of doctors?
It is unbelievable that the people who have the legal, professional, and religious duty to save life are letting people die for the sake of some financial benefit. I don't understand when the benefits of doctors working in Punjab are already better than the doctors of the other provinces, only they are on strike. I am sure there is some politics involved behind this move of YDA to make Shahbaz Sharif look bad during the election year. Suppose if he had accepted the demands of the YDA - there salaries were already raised last year - then there would be demands for hike from the senior doctors, then para-medical staff, then clerks, and then so on. This would have continuously put Shahbaz Sharif under pressure during the election year because it would be impossible for him to meet the all the demands. Although I am a critique of Nawaz Sharif & Family along with MPL(N), but here I appreciate Shahbaz Sharif for not bowing down to the blackmailing of YDA.
@Jibran: for goodness sake, come out of PML(N) phobia. it's about the people who are dying because of strike not because of PML-N. at least don't play politics on the bodies of dead.
Once again SC is suppoerting PMLN for running their government. While it creates barrier for federal courts....
These judges think they are beyond common-sense evaluation. Pity.
@ Jibran, LHC has done great favour to doctors to get their jobs back. In any other country these doctors would have been charged for homocide. Punjab government has already given them a reasonalbe pay scale. If they need more, they should struggle in peacefull manner. Playing with the lives of innocent patients is barbaric.
Where are cases against those who showed heavy handedness against doctors and caused all those deaths?
Once again LHC bails out the PML-N.