Aspirations of the Pakistani youth

Published: November 8, 2015
Email
PHOTO: AFP

PHOTO: AFP

PHOTO: AFP The writer is a former caretaker finance minister and served as vice-president at the World Bank

Pakistan is one of the two countries in the western part of the Muslim world where positive change is taking place and it is coming reasonably fast. The other is Turkey. The two countries are moving towards creating inclusive political and economic orders. They are being pushed towards these goals by the young in their populations. Of the two, Pakistan in terms of the size of its population, is larger and is also considerably younger. The median age of the population is only 23 years. This means that some 100 million people out of a total of 200 million in the country are below that age. Where do the young people live; what are their aspirations; what will be their likely response if these aspirations are not satisfied; how can they be satisfied and who in the country is capable of addressing them are some of the important questions that need to be asked and answered.

Pakistan among worst countries to live in for people under 25

Pakistan has not held a population census for 17 years. Almost all countries around the world hold them every 10 years, mostly on the first year of the start of a new decade. Had the country followed that practice — which India, for instance, did — it should have conducted seven counts by now. Instead only four were carried out — in 1951, 1972, 1981 and 1998. Consequently, there is not enough data available to make reliable estimates of the size and age-distribution of the population, its male-female composition and its geographical dispersal. Guesswork will have to do and that is what I will attempt in order to underscore the main theme of this article.

The proportion of the urban population in the total is much higher than the estimates made in 1998 when the last official count was made. Official estimates continue to place the proportion much lower than is most probably the case. This is being done basically for political reasons. The lower share of the urban population makes it possible for the landed class to maintain its grip on the political system. This is also the reason why no government in the past decade and a half had the political will to count the number of people resident in the country and how they were distributed across the land.

It is my guess that one-half of the population resides in urban areas. Of this 100 million people, 70 million are in large cities — those with more than two million people. Karachi and Lahore, the country’s two megacities, have a combined population of 33 million, almost half of the total living in urban areas. Medium-sized cities have another 20 million people while the remaining 10 million are scattered in thousands of towns across the country.

Youth empowerment: Rs2 billion released for self-employment loans, says Shafiq

The proportion of the youth is highly skewed in favour of urban areas in general and large cities in particular. Rural-urban migration is the reason for the increase in the share of the urban population in the total. There are more job opportunities in large cities. There are also better education, health and entertainment facilities available in urban areas. About 70 per cent of the population of large cities is made up of the young, those below the age of 23. Their share in the population of the megacities is even larger — perhaps about 75 per cent. A youth-oriented economic and social development programme, therefore, must focus on large cities, in particular on Karachi and Lahore.

What do the young people want from the economy and the social system? There are several ways of answering this question. One of them is to look at some inter-country comparisons. A group of researchers have developed what they call the “Youthonomics Global Index”, which ranks on a scale of zero to 100, economic prospects for young people in 64 countries. The index is based on 59 indicators that measure how the young feel about their current situation. This is done by looking at some of the obvious measures. These include employment opportunities and incomes at the entry level; access to educational and health facilities; availability of entertainment facilities; and perceptions about the future. The index ranks both the feelings about the present and also those about the future.

In so far as the present is concerned, it is not surprising that Norway, Switzerland, Sweden, Denmark and the Netherlands rank at the top as the world’s youth-friendlier countries. However, the researchers were surprised by one finding: China ranks higher than all emerging nations. It has become particularly attractive to young people, outranking several European nations such as Spain, Croatia and Italy.

PM’s Youth Business Loan Scheme fails to entice

Pakistan, not surprisingly, is among the countries in the bottom of the group. It ranks 58th, lower than Bangladesh and India. It belongs to the group that includes Mali, Egypt and Kenya. Why is the Pakistani youth unhappy with its present situation and how is it likely to act? For an answer to the second question, we should look at the work done by the economist Albert O Hirschman who, in his book, Exit, Voice and Loyalty, discussed the options available for distressed people. He discussed in particular the options of raising voice to indicate unhappiness or exit from the system in which they live. In Pakistan’s case, these two options are already being tested and both will result in retarding social, political and economic progress.

Published in The Express Tribune, November 9th, 2015.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (6)

  • Ali S
    Nov 9, 2015 - 5:35PM

    A young, poorly educated population with little employment opportunities and a radicalized, sectarian society – Pakistan’s future for its youth reads like a nightmare. Even if drastic reforms are undertaken right now, I suppose it will take at least two generations to see any palpable results.Recommend

  • choptocut
    Nov 9, 2015 - 6:55PM

    Sorry Burki but you yourself exploit youth at your institute: giving them below average salaries while charging yourself per day more than double the rate of their monthly salaries when in fact all the hard work is done by these youths.
    At least you should have to heart to practise what you preach. Recommend

  • Dr.M.M.Khan
    Nov 9, 2015 - 10:02PM

    Pakistan is suffering from a youth bulge. Nearly 80% of the population is under the age of 25. What sort of education are they getting. Most of it is substandard and not suited to the demands of the economy. Many of the youth graduating from the universities(if they are lucky) strawl around having nothing to do and going home to their parents and living off them as” parasites”. Many of them are attracted to religious fanatics who espouse nothing but poison against the west. If these youngsters are lucky and have so called “Connections” they do land up a job but others are just there!. Every gateway to the west seems to be closing every day. I meet highly qualified pakistani graduates including my professsion serving as waitors in Monaco, driving taxis in Canada and delivering newspapers in Sweden My heart cries for them! The nation which went Nuclear cannot employ it’s highly talented youth. History will not forgive us. Our future is going down the drain.Recommend

  • Skywalker
    Nov 10, 2015 - 12:31AM

    @Dr.M.M.Khan:
    If you look at it differently, there is lot of opportunity for some visionary leader to guide these young men/women towards a better future. We don’t want the young ones getting disenfranchised and be non-state actors.Recommend

  • Dr.M.M.Khan
    Nov 10, 2015 - 4:07PM

    @Skywalker: i agree with you but it is such a shame that since 1947 we have been unable to produce one visionary leader. We have produced a lot of politicians but a visionary leader is a pipedream.Recommend

  • Husnain Ali
    Nov 10, 2015 - 7:01PM

    Basically our main problems are lack of Job oppertunties, lack of education and lack of health system. Pakistan youth is attracted towards abroad to go there and earn livehood. Our Govt is working for better infrastrucher but thery are not giving fundermental rights to Pakistani people so our people are deppressedRecommend

More in Opinion