Of the seven projects funded by FIFA in Pakistan, only one has actually been completed. PHOTO COURTESY: PFF
KARACHI/ DHARAN: There are no recognisable football fields, no players, just a rusting goalpost at the Hawksbay training centre, built with a $500,000 FIFA grant on a windswept plot by the Arabian Sea near Karachi, and officially “completed” two years ago.
In Nepal, goats graze on a rutted playing field near decrepit facilities at the Dharan football academy built with FIFA cash in the Himalayan foothills. The sole member of staff, a watchman, says he hasn't been paid for a year.
A Reuters review of football development projects in these two South Asian countries shows they are littered with half-built and under-used facilities, despite receiving more than $2 million from the sport's world governing body this year alone. In recent weeks, Reuters reporters visited seven projects in Pakistan and Nepal that received FIFA money under its 'Goal' program - which funds footbal fields for youth academies, known as technical centres, and playing surfaces in stadiums. But all they found was that just one had an active full-time training programme, while three had no proper playing fields.
During embattled outgoing President Sepp Blatter's 17-year reign, FIFA has poured money into such projects in some of the poorest corners of the world. Blatter has said the programmes aim to make the world's most popular sport accessible to all, but critics contend such grants have helped ensure he retained power with support from the heads of football associations in countries known more for their corruption than footballing prowess.
Blatter was re-elected president for a fifth time in late May, just days after seven FIFA officials were arrested on bribery-related charges as a result of a wide-ranging US investigation into corruption in FIFA. In early June he announced that he would step down once a successor had been elected in February 2016.
FIFA says it spends $200 million a year on development programmes, partly through its 'Goal' programme. It declined to comment about the specific cases of Nepal and Pakistan for this article, but said the majority of its 'Goal' projects around the world were “successful”.
"Over the past few years, FIFA has put in place stringent financial controls and audit checks to ensure, as far as we can, that the money we provide is spent on the projects we intend and is managed carefully," a FIFA spokesperson said.
"Only in a small minority of cases do we discover problems that give cause for concern."
Making a difference
It isn't certain how many of the more than 700 completed 'Goal' projects around the world meet FIFA's objectives. But there are clearly examples where FIFA money has made a difference in developing football in poorer countries.
In Mogadishu, Somalia, for example, a dusty national stadium now boasts a smooth, bright green playing surface. In Costa Rica, the football association has used successive grants to build up a national sports centre.
"Look at the difference in so many cases of football associations not having headquarters or fields or technical centers before FIFA started investing in 1999." said Jerome Champagne, a former FIFA deputy general secretary.
"Governments don't suppress the (British) NHS (National Health Service) or the French social security because some people may cheat the system."
Even so, there are places besides Nepal and Pakistan - parts of the Caribbean, for example - where 'Goal' resources don't seem to have reached those they were aimed at or have not been properly managed.
A Swiss investigation into FIFA, running in parallel to the US probe, is looking at whether FIFA funds for development grants to regional and local football bodies around the world were siphoned off for personal gain, among other things, according to a source with knowledge of the probe.
The presidents of the football associations in both Pakistan and Nepal face leadership challenges from opponents who accuse them of corruption - which they deny. Both noted that FIFA pays 'Goal' project funds directly to contractors without passing through the accounts of member associations - a mechanism designed to avoid corruption.
Ganesh Thapa temporarily stepped aside last year as president of the All Nepal Football Association (ANFA) during a FIFA investigation into misconduct. ANFA officials alleged he ran the association in a self-serving way, and drew attention to a PwC audit and other evidence that Thapa and his family took large payments from a former Asian Football Association chief. Thapa denies any wrongdoing.
FIFA's Ethics Committee has not yet made a judgement in the case, and Thapa resumed his post in July after his replacement died from an electric shock.
Meanwhile, Pakistan Football Federation (PFF) President Faisal Saleh Hayat is the focus of an investigation started in June by the country's Federal Investigation Authority following allegations by a PFF faction that he embezzled funds and squandered $1.4 million on foreign travel. Hayat denies the accusations.
Pakistan: Beach football
The architect's drawings for the Hawksbay Technical Centre show a lush green football field.
Approval for the centre "for the training of national and youth teams" came in 2006, and FIFA's website shows that its contribution of $505,958 was spent.
Hayat told Reuters the project was completed a year ago. The centre, near a beach resort, consists of a sprawling building with a giant concrete football on the roof, surrounded by an uneven boulder-strewn field. There is no grass. A guard declined to let Reuters reporters inside.
Rahim Baloch, treasurer of the Sindh Football Association, which covers Karachi, said that the national team – for whom the the facility was built for – has never trained there, though local clubs train at the site.
On subsequent visits, Reuters reporters found the gate locked and the desolate premises abandoned.
"It's not playable. It's a shame there's such a big place for football that's not functional yet," said Yaqoob Baloch, a club-level football coach in Karachi.
Eyewitness reports and comments from officials show that of eight 'Goal' projects in Pakistan built with $2.6 million of FIFA funds, the only one was completed and is fully functional – a $481,650 office built in Lahore as the PFF's headquarters.
Hayat had previously told Reuters that four of the eight projects had been completed - the office in Lahore, and technical centers in Karachi (Hawksbay), Quetta and Abbottabad. He, however, did not respond to calls and messages querying the discrepancy between what he said and what Reuters reporters saw and heard from officials.
The center in Quetta has lodgings, a canteen and an office, but nowhere to play football.
"The construction of a football ground is part of the project and will be started soon," said Haji Saeed Taku, the General Secretary of the Balochistan Football Association.
The Abbottabad center fares far better than its Quetta and Karachi counterparts, boasting a playing field, offices and lodgings for visiting players. But what it makes in premises, it lacks in utilities including no electricity, gas or water connections.
While the inside looks smart, the contractors violated an agreement for using imported materials, including doors, instead replacing them with low-quality local materials, said Adil Khan Jadoon of the District Football Association Abbottabad, which represents local teams.
"We raised the issue of sub-standard materials and the poor quality of work, but nobody listened to us," he said. "We are really grateful to FIFA for providing funds to promote football, but it's very painful to admit that it didn't help promote the game here as the funds weren't properly utilised," he said.
Nepal: Goats as greenkeepers
It's a similar tale in Nepal.
The Dharan technical centre was built in 2002, but was mainly used by drug addicts and then Maoist rebels for the next six years, said Deepak Rai, the academy's director.
Local clubs occasionally trained there, but it was never professionally turfed, nearby residents say, and when the centre was due to be inaugurated in 2008, local people dug clods of grass from their fields to make the pitch presentable, said Rai.
A plaque at Dharan marks the centre's inauguration by FIFA's then South Asia director of development, Manilal Fernando, and Thapa, the ANFA president.
FIFA banned Fernando for life in 2013 after an investigation into bribery and corruption related to a 2009 election within the Asian Football Confederation.
Fernando, a Sri Lankan who had been a member of FIFA's executive committee, was in charge of distributing 'Goal' project funds in South Asia.
ANFA was subject to a FIFA Ethics Committee investigation in 2013 over "Tsunami funds and the 'Goal' projects managed by Fernando between 2005 and 2012 in the South Asia region," FIFA said in a statement last year.
A committee spokesperson cited FIFA rules prohibiting him from saying whether the probe had been concluded and declined to reveal more details.
Fernando told Reuters both investigations were launched against him because he supported one of Blatter's rivals. He said FIFA was "an iceberg of corruption."
Thapa, who has run Nepali football for two decades, is under a pending investigation by FIFA's Ethics Committee after a 2012 KPMG audit found "unappropriated cash movements".
In interviews with Reuters, Thapa acknowledged that the Dharan centre was not functioning. He blamed uncooperative local officials and the association's weak finances. "We are facing a very big financial problem. We do not have the money to run the centre at the minute," he said.
But, FIFA has given ANFA $6.9 million since 2000 for football development, including $1,050,000 this year.
In 2010, under 'Goal', FIFA donated $400,000 "for financing of three existing football academies," including Dharan. But that year, ANFA released just $13,000 for the centre's costs. In 2009-12, it granted between $13,000 and $21,370 each year for a full-time training programme for 25 youths - the only time the centre has been used for its intended purpose in 13 years, according to Thapa and ANFA audits.
Thapa said ANFA had stopped funding the Dharan centre because of a dispute with local officials over treatment of the boys.
"I went to visit them, they were crying and saying 'we're not being treated well, we're not learning anything'," he said.
But as with most of Thapa's stories, two graduates of the programme denied this.
Mohan Katwal, now 18 and a professional player with local club Morang, described his training at Dharan as good and said he enjoyed his time there. Sushant Chaudhary, now a commerce student, also said the training had been good.
Thapa said he had decided to spend the 'Goal' training money on the running costs of an academy in Kathmandu instead. He declined to elaborate, saying this was an "internal matter." His focus on Kathmandu has limits.
A second 'Goal' technical centre in the capital, the Chyasal academy, lies semi-abandoned. Rooms are locked, corridors are filled with trash and a large part of its grass field is worn down to dirt. It has never hosted a full-time training program because, Thapa says, it's too dangerous.
"It's not a suitable location. There are drug users around there," he said. Thapa said ANFA was still deciding how to spend this year's FIFA grant.
In Dharan, watchman Arjun Budathoki, 45, keeps an eye on the mostly derelict centre. He says he was last paid his ANFA salary in August 2014. For the two tournaments organised locally each year, the centre borrows a lawnmower. "For the rest of the year we let the goats do it," said Digmar Puri, who owns the animals and was an assistant manager when the centre was running.
COMMENTS
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ