Coming home to war: Afghan refugees return reluctantly from Pakistan

Published: September 4, 2015


KABUL: Rahim Khan’s return to Afghanistan 28 years after fleeing to Pakistan was not the homecoming he had dreamed of.

The 60-year-old is one of a growing number of Afghan refugees making the journey back with trepidation, as militant violence intensifies, yet feeling shunned by their adopted country as relations between the neighbours sour.

The rate of returnees has more than quadrupled this year, with 137,000 refugees going back to Afghanistan since January.

The number could spike further if the countries fail to agree by Dec. 31 to extend identity cards for two years and allow some 1.5 million registered refugees to stay in Pakistan.

The chill in relations, amid an offensive by Taliban insurgents which Kabul blames partly on Pakistan, has put the extension in doubt, along with the future of another million unregistered Afghans.

“First we had to leave here because of war. Now we are coming back to war and bombs,” said Khan, speaking at a refugee centre near Kabul where his Pakistan-born grandchildren were being taught the dangers of mines and roadside bombs.

Outside, the thump of exploding ordnance from a nearby army range echoed off arid hills, another reminder that Afghanistan appears no closer to peace than when Khan left during the Soviet occupation.

The dangers mean thousands of people have fled Afghanistan this year, many of them to Europe where governments are struggling to cope with an influx of migrants from the Middle East and beyond.

Yet Khan and others like him say they had little choice but to leave Pakistan.

His son Abdul Manan said their life as labourers and fruit vendors in Pakistan-administered Kashmir took a dramatic turn for the worse after Taliban gunmen massacred at least 141 students at an army school in northwest Pakistan in December.

Islamabad blamed the atrocity on militants based across the border, and anti-Afghan sentiment in Pakistan rose.

Manan said police started showing up at their home, asking to see their papers and threatening them with jail if they failed to pay 1,000-1,500 rupees ($10-15) every few days.

“We decided to leave, there was no other option. We couldn’t keep paying 1,500,” said Manan. “This is our home and we have no other place to go.”

Raja Shafqat Khan, senior official at the police headquarters in Muzaffarabad, administrative capital of Pakistan-administered Kashmir, said he was not aware of the family’s complaints.

“As a policy, we do not harass Afghan refugees,” he said.

Pakistan’s refugee minister, Abdul Qadir Baloch, promised to renew ID cards if he got cabinet approval, and said Pakistan would “not use any coercive measures” to send Afghans back.

Chill deepens

Afghan President Ashraf Ghani spent much of his first year in office trying to improve relations and spur peace talks with the Taliban, widely believed to have close links with Pakistan’s spy agency that helped create the movement in the 1990s.

But efforts stalled and the fledgling peace process collapsed after it was revealed in July that Taliban leader Mullah Omar had died two years earlier.

A spate of lethal attacks in Kabul that Ghani believes were planned by militants hiding on Pakistan’s side of the porous, rugged border soured relations further.

Pakistani Interior Minister Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan has said he wanted all refugees repatriated.

“The cards will not be extended,” he said. “They expire at the end of this year.”

There are four months left for the neighbours to patch things up, but for now the mood is hostile.

Since Ghani pointed the finger of blame across the border for the attacks, Pakistani flags and currency have been burnt by protesters. Pakistani diplomats in Kabul say they are restricting their movements.

Seeking to assert itself after Omar’s death, and exploiting a reduced foreign troop presence, the Taliban has stepped up its insurgency, leading to hefty clashes with Afghan forces and thousands of casualties.

Khan is moving in with his daughter-in-law’s family in the northeastern province of Kunduz, because fighting is too fierce around his farmland in neighbouring Baghlan.

As thousands arrive from Pakistan, others are seeking ways to leave.

Humanitarian organisations estimate that nearly one million Afghans have been internally displaced by fighting, and on the streets of Kabul, conversations quickly turn to departure.

Almost everyone knows someone attempting to get to Europe.

After Syrians and Eritreans, Afghans are the third biggest group of asylum seekers in Europe, making up about 11 percent of the 300,000 refugees and migrants who have made it across the Mediterranean this year, according to data from the UN refugee agency.

Ahmad Faheem, who runs the agency’s Kabul reception centre, said some of those leaving were among 3.5 million former refugees who returned from Pakistan soon after the United States toppled the Taliban in 2001, amid brief hope of a better future.

“Day by day the security situation is getting worse,” said Faheem, who himself returned from Pakistan in 2002. “They have come here to try to settle, but if there is no security and no work, they leave again.”

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (9)

  • Pakistani Dude
    Sep 4, 2015 - 10:31AM

    We can sympathize with the Afghan refugees but keeping in view the diatribe of the Afghan leadership and the promotion of anti-Pakistan sentiments among Afghans by Indian agencies, the return of Afghan refugees was bound to happen. They are refugees and they cannot stay forever in Pakistan. Recommend

  • Glowing Pakistan
    Sep 4, 2015 - 11:01AM

    We don’t hate Afghanis but we left with no other option than this. We are sorry we can’t afford your stay here. Even your govt is not serious about Pakistan. On daily basis they blame Pak for their own failure but they don’t know how much we are at security risk due Afghanis stay here.Recommend

  • Stranger
    Sep 4, 2015 - 11:45AM

    Every one cares about refugees /immigrants but there are logistics involved. Be it India/ Pak or Europe . Theres only so much the host countries can do .Recommend

  • Point
    Sep 4, 2015 - 12:07PM

    A neighbor Afghan went to Afghanistan two months ago. Came back again saying Pakistan is more home to him than anything. A very respectable Afghan family they were and they came back. Many are going to get some money from UN and they get back through illegal routes all over again. It’s a day to day activity we witness hereRecommend

  • Waseem
    Sep 4, 2015 - 12:40PM

    we fed them for over 3 decades and then they hit us at the back. No Sympathy, please return home. You are good at your home with Indian. Just stay there in your paradise. Recommend

  • Khan
    Sep 4, 2015 - 5:40PM

    Even though, I feel Afghan refugees are mostly peaceful and good Muslim. Unfortunately, they are facing such action because of their govt. Anti-Pakistan hysteria. Plus, the refugees that returned to Afghanistan, from Pakistan, turned out to be even worse Anti-Pakistani for their selfish reason (i.e. to fit in Anti-Pakistan Afghani establishment -created by West and trained by HINDUSTAN).

    For Pakistan it is better that all Afghan Refugees are returned to their homeland (AKA Land of Pakistan strategic depth) and if they don’t like it then they should head to HINDUSTAN or Western nations. Pakistan need to close it’s doors on Afghan Refugees, for good, and in worst case Pakistan should establish camps on Afghan soil for them and don’t let them inside Pakistan.Recommend

  • Malatesh
    Sep 4, 2015 - 7:48PM

    Its good move… They can go back to their country and get better education and prosperity. On what grounds Pakistan deny their role in Afghan unrest? Entire world including China blaming Pakistan. Ugher militants in China of which they directly blamed Pakistan, your minister said yesterday that ugher militants are almost eliminated, which means they had earlier and kept in denial mode, no one is asking the minister to explain his statement. Recommend

  • Osmund Saddler
    Sep 5, 2015 - 5:07AM

    Such warm and brotherly “Love” being shown by the Pakistanis for their war-torn neighbors, a mess that Pakistan and American both are responsible for. Pathetic.Recommend

  • Sumit
    Sep 5, 2015 - 10:05AM

    Why Afganis were forced to leave Afghanistan at first place? The answer is “Pakistan”, so you are not doing any ehsan on them it is your responsibility to feed them coz you have made their life miserable by interfering in thier internal affairs.Recommend

More in Pakistan