Editorial

Railway tragedy

In 2007 it was decided to repair the 159 ‘most fragile’ bridges, a project that apparently has yet to come to fruition

Editorial July 03, 2015

Rescue workers and troops inspect the wreckage of a train carrying soldiers and military hardware after it fell into a canal following the partial collapse of a bridge in Wazirabad. PHOTO: AFP

A railway bridge collapsed, derailing the train that was passing near Gujranwala on July 2. The number of casualties recorded so far is at least 19, with the possibility of more bodies being found downstream of the accident. The train was carrying army personnel and the majority of the dead were members of the armed forces and their relatives. The cause of the bridge collapse is so far unknown. Another train had passed over the same bridge about 90 minutes earlier with nothing untoward noted. The bridge dates from the pre-Partition era — as does much of the railway infrastructure in Pakistan — and was alleged by some sources to be in a dilapidated condition. The possibility of sabotage cannot be ruled out either and there is to be a report within 72 hours as to the cause of this tragedy.

The Director General Public Relations of the Pakistan Railways, Abdul Rauf Tahir, said that all railway bridges were examined in January 2015. If true, that is a major undertaking. There are 13,841 bridges as part of the railway system, 55 per cent of which have reportedly reached the end of their useful life. There are 1,352 bridges that are 100-120 years old, the bridge that fell being one of them, and 1,245 that are 80-100 years old. Another 640 are 60-80 years old and there has been negligible building of new bridges since Partition.

It is worth noting that in 2007 it was decided to repair the 159 ‘most fragile’ bridges, a project that apparently has yet to come to fruition. Although sabotage cannot be ruled out, neither can the possibility of the bridge simply failing, and the fact that another train traversed it successfully, earlier in the day, could be entirely immaterial. Over half of all bridges in the railway system are beyond their designed lifespan. The quality of workmanship and materials used in the repair and maintenance of railway infrastructure has been criticised in the past. We regret the death of so many military personnel, and hope that a speedy and transparent inquiry will reveal the causes of the tragedy; anything less would do them a grave injustice.

Published in The Express Tribune, July 4^th, 2015.

Like Life & Style on Facebook, follow @ETLifeandStyle on Twitter for the latest in fashion, gossip and entertainment.

COMMENTS (1)

M Saleem Chaudhry | 9 years ago | Reply A cursory review of the data of bridges provided in your brief," Railway tragedy " will be enough to make it top priority for anyone with average common sense to repair and rebuild these bridges for a vital transport system. However our current rulers despite being in the corridors of power, repeatedly have never bothered to realise and work on it. With 55% of bridges out of total of 13841 having outlived their designed life span , how can any sensible person think of ignoring to rebuild and repair them just for allocating hundreds of Billions for building Metros and Motor Ways? Isn't it unforgivable negligence that work to repair 159 most fragile bridges planned in 2007 has not been completed even in 2015 after a lapse of 8 years? Shouldn't 195 million people take such irresponsible rulers to task and knock them out of the arena of power,once for all?

Replying to X