Vote-fraud probe: Poll supervisory body admits slip-up by POs

Says incompetence might be behind broken seals


Hasnaat Malik June 27, 2015
File photo. PHOTO: AFP

ISLAMABAD:


As the inquiry commission investigating allegations of rigging in the May 2013 elections is all set to start hearing arguments of the counsels representing different political parties from Monday (tomorrow), the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) has admitted that the absence of Form-15 from polling bags points towards negligence of the presiding officers (POs).


“It is clear that the gaps in the record of Form-15s is entirely random and reflects lack of care on the part of the POs as regards the copies of the Form-15s that ought to have been placed in the polling bags,” reads the reply submitted by ECP’s counsel Salman Akram Raja to the inquiry body.

“As regards gaps in the record of Form-15s that returning officers (ROs) have been able to retrieve, these gaps again reflect lack of care on the part of the POs or deficiencies in the record-keeping procedure and facilities.” The ECP states that the absence of Form-15s cannot be said to be proof – much less proof beyond reasonable doubt – of any wrongdoing. “The absence of Form-15s and broken seals could have been caused due to incompetence of the POs.”

Read: Returning officers’report: Form-15 missing from seats won by PML-N, PTI

It also states that the absence of Form-15s in any constituency cannot be considered as evidence of electoral malpractice by the returning candidates or anyone else. “There’s no evidence of who might have broken the seals on the polling bags.” Regarding the issue of extra ballot papers, the ECP said it was unclear as to who is being accused for alleged misuse of extra ballot papers. “Extra ballot papers were in the custody of the POs.” The ECP also defended the role of the ROs regarding their demand for printing extra ballot papers.

The inquiry panel said if the Form-15s were not placed in the polling bags or were removed later, there should be other corroborating evidence of tampering, adding that the PTI and other political parties have not challenged the actions of the POs and it has not been suggested that the POs at thousands of polling stations were part of some organised plan to rig the elections.

‘Blame-shifting’

Ishaq Khan Khakwani, chairman of the PTI’s task force engaged in gathering rigging evidences, told The Express Tribune that the ECP is the main culprit behind rigging and irregularities in the last general elections. He said the ECP is now shifting all the responsibility of irregularities from the ROs to the POs.

He also claimed that throughout the proceedings, the ECP has favoured the stance of the ruling party.

Read: Form 15 missing from thousands of vote bags

Meanwhile, in its 70-page reply, the PML-N has rejected all allegations of poll rigging. The party’s counsel told the inquiry body that the PTI had failed to prove its allegations during the proceedings.

Moreover, the MQM also submitted written arguments before the inquiry commission, denying all rigging allegations.

The three-judge panel, headed by CJP Nasirul Mulk, is likely to conclude the proceedings by Friday, following which counsels for different political parties will start recording their arguments from Monday.


Published in The Express Tribune, June 28th, 2015.

COMMENTS (14)

H Chaudhry | 5 years ago | Reply @Zain get your Facts correct! The Form 15 Slip up beneficiary list is topped by MQM and followed by PTI. PMLN is in 4th on the list. Sorry but doing research helps.
H Chaudhry | 5 years ago | Reply @Pakistan Actually you are missing key points here. First there is no 1 defense attorney here as this is not a civil case to being with. Its an inquiry commission where every party is represented by a Council. ECP is one of the parties and their Attornery summarized the position quite remarkably. Actually, the onus to prove any thing was on PTI and they misreably failed. ECP council is just summing up their position with Facts and figures. The FACTS are close to 70,000 PO supervised election and some of them made mistakes just like those mistakes have been happening since 1985. Second FACT is that Form 15 is a form of no consequence and even if it is the data shows (1) missing form 15s are from seats won by every party that is NO Pattern (2) MQM and PTI have the largest form 15s missing from their won seats again showing No Pattern to get PMLN elected. The arguments are very very strong and essentially this is where PTI's case wad pronounced dead!
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ