Gender bias: Transgender people face harassment in police lockup

Published: June 12, 2015
Police force the transgenders to undress to confirm whether they are transsexuals or not. PHOTO: EXPRESS

Police force the transgenders to undress to confirm whether they are transsexuals or not. PHOTO: EXPRESS

KARACHI: At the Saddar police station, officers pass mischievous looks. “Humaray station par madhuris aye hain [We have beautiful maidens at our station today],” smirked one of them, walking towards a shabby lockup.

Inside, Rimmel and Moni, two transgender people, huddle close to each other, looking petrified. “I pray that tonight we sleep at our homes instead of this police station. They are troubling us so much.”

Booked in a case involving a dispute and for injuring a man, the two say they are being subjected to immense harassment and humiliation by the police. “The first night we were brought to the police station, they forced us to undress. They said they wanted to see if we were really transsexuals,” says Rimmel, her head bowed in shame. “It was humiliating.”

The main accused, another transgender person is on bail, while Rimmel and Moni, who were arrested four days earlier from their house near Jinnah hospital, claim they were only trying to end the fight.

And since they have come into the police station, taunts and harassment have followed them. Moni, brushing her short hair, said that a police officer tried to grab her from behind the bars to remove her shirt. When she pulled back, he called her names. The two, when taken to the court, were also mocked by the lawyers and others there.

“The police are not taking us seriously. When we ask for something, they say things like you must have many male friends.” Both of them are associated with NGOs that work for transgender people.

Rimmel, who has completed her B Com part one, left home three years ago when her father told her to either change her ways or leave the house. “I could not suppress my feelings and felt like a woman. I could not live with my family.” On the streets, she worked as a dancer in musical gatherings and functions, leaving the work when she found a job at the Gender Interactive Alliance. “But I am in touch with my family. They sent me biryani here,” she said pointing to the empty plastic boxes in the lockup. Moni, who works for another organisation, says that she meets her family every two months.

Meanwhile, the police denied that the two accused were being ill-treated. “We are treating them just fine,” said SIO Javed Sheikh. The officer could not, however, refrain from expressing his biased views about the transgender community. “Society should know about their wrongdoings. They all try to get sympathy.”

Separate lockups

Transgender activist Bindiya Rana demanded that separate lockups be established for eunuchs. “Such cases highlight the need for separate lockups. How can they be kept be in male police stations?”

According to Rana, transgender people face harassment everywhere, from hospitals to workplaces. “We are recognised as transgender people on the NIC only.”

Sensitisation of the police

Rana Asif Habib, who works with street children and transgender people, called for sensitisation of the police when it came to dealing with transsexuals. “Their gender is being made the issue. As equal citizens, they have right to stand trial and to be treated fairly.”

He said that the police should be sensitised and given trainings on how to take up such cases and respond towards them when dealing with transsexuals.

Published in The Express Tribune, June 12th, 2015. 

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (7)

  • Saleem
    Jun 12, 2015 - 2:38PM

    Most of the so-called “Shemales”, here in Lahore, are actually boys who come from smaller cities and when they can’t find proper jobs, they start doing this. Some of them do it for fun. I have personally interviewed many of them, picking them from MM Alam Road, Gulberg, etc. So if these guys are naturally the third case, then they should be treated with respect, but if someone is trying to fool the society, they don’t deserve to get the rights of honorable eunuchs. Recommend

  • Stranger
    Jun 12, 2015 - 6:42PM

    Anything happens to me happens only bec of me . Why do they dress up like that and dance .why cant they behave respectfully and join respectful professions .why asset their sexuality ( whatever it is ) . Recommend

  • Samra
    Jun 12, 2015 - 11:22PM

    Why cant they behave respectfully and join respectful professions!!!!
    Lemme put it this way…lets suppose you own some multinational company, will you ever appoint any transgender to work with you or represent your company!!!
    Will you ever hire some transgender as your PA…i am sure NOT!!!
    If you cant then don’t expect the same from anybody else!!!
    I am sorry but i didn’t like the way you slammed them!!
    They are just helpless!!!Recommend

  • Hmm
    Jun 13, 2015 - 12:02AM

    Had no idea that “Madhuris” means beautiful. Recommend

  • sadam k
    Jun 13, 2015 - 8:32AM

    Actually,It is observed that they themselves involve in such vile acts,therefore,people don,t act with them properly. It is not the one sided fault- both are involved in this act..
    To overcome the problem which is faced by such transgenders, they need to adapt the strict behaviour, they must realize those beasts that they are not what they think of them-the step which they need to take is just to make themselves transparent….No one would as tease them as they are teased.Recommend

  • Rania
    Jun 13, 2015 - 10:25AM

    Society needs to understand, that people are not only eunuch by the genitals only. ONE CAN EUNUCH MENTALLY, Which is called Gender Identity Disorder.
    I don,t know about people dressing up as girls for the sake of fun or something else. But Yes, If someone has complete male or female genitals, He/She can be mentally Eunuch.
    Government should give them the right for sex change operations. We can take example from Iran, where there is no third gender. Its only male or female, and a male converting to female should be considered a female not Eunuch, and like wise. Recommend

  • zain
    Jun 13, 2015 - 10:36AM

    People who are judging them for being transgendered, please get a life. You and others have no right to take someone’s life and torture then simply because they are different. If they are really transgendered then respect them after all they were born this way and they are humans. You are in no position to judge. Since their families don’t accept them, naturally they would look to activities that go against islam teachings to survive. Imagine if one you were born and your families, and friend just push you away putting you through immense mental torture.Recommend

More in Sindh