Is music in gyms a distraction?

Music has become an essential part of a gym - but some trainers feel this trend is a bad idea.


Ians December 05, 2010

NEW DEHLI: Music has become an essential part of a gym and with growing demand, most gyms these days have live DJ sessions to make the workout a fun session.

Nicholas Kraal, the business development manager of Mumbai-based True Fitness India, thinks music is a great motivator, “We have a dedicated DJ booth and professional DJs spin music from 6 am to midnight. Our DJs also take music requests and play fun, fast-paced, pumping music to motivate and excite our members during workout sessions. We believe that music complements our state-of-the-art premium facilities.”

Gyms have to make sure different music is used for different activities so that it matches the pace of that particular workout.

“Certain classes require specialised music based on beats. Aerobics instructors use music to keep the 32-count (32-beats per minute) or 120 beats per minute. A high impact class can even have anything between 130-140 beats per minute,” said Althea Shah, general manager and fitness expert of Gold Gym, Mumbai.

“Classes sometimes cater not by age but by musical taste with beach, jazz, hip-hop, Latin, classic rock, country, Broadway, classical, club, and disco aerobic music,” he added.

Shah also points out that the reception area, spa and changing rooms have soft music playing while the workout areas have fast paced music.

Some people prefer listening to their own collection while working out and Amit Nigam is one of them. He prefers to bring in his own iPod for a workout.

“There are times when you get bored of the same beats or music and if you love a particular music genre, listening to another one can be torturous,” he said.

And there are a few who like to watch TV while working out and Kraal says it is a matter of personal choice.

“Watching TV or listening to personal music while working out is a personal choice and we respect that. Some members may find it more motivating to listen to a personal play list while others prefer TV as it helps them to take their mind off the physical exertion,” he said.

But there are some who don’t like any distractions while Delhi-based personal trainer Aashu, who has been in the profession for over 14 years, prefers to train without music or television and doesn’t agree with the “music motivational” theory.

“Listening to music or watching TV is just a way of getting distracted and not giving 100 per cent to your workout and this affects results,” he said.

“What happens when you are listening to your favourite music? Half your mind is enjoying it, and the other half is trying to get the posture right. So the focus that one requires in a workout is not there.”

“People believe music motivates them, but does it actually? Why does one need music to motivate one for a workout? This is a clear indication that they are not enjoying their workouts and doing it just for the sake of it,” he added.

Another fitness expert, Tasneem Zaki, also agrees with Aashu.

“I believe when you are doing cardio, it’s good to listen to music because it helps to distract attention from the speedometer. But if you are doing weight-training, free-hand exercises or floor exercises, it’s always better to switch off the music,” he said.

Published in The Express Tribune, December 6th, 2010.

COMMENTS

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ

E-Publications

Most Read