Watch what you eat: Report confirms teenager died after eating a burger ‘not fit for consumption’

Published: February 25, 2015
Kanza, a student of class eight, died a few days ago and her mother and two younger siblings fell ill, the family claimed, after consuming burgers at the Dilpasand Sweets’ North Nazimabad branch. STOCK IMAGE

Kanza, a student of class eight, died a few days ago and her mother and two younger siblings fell ill, the family claimed, after consuming burgers at the Dilpasand Sweets’ North Nazimabad branch. STOCK IMAGE

KARACHI: Kanza’s half-eaten burger, according to a test conducted by the Pakistan Council of Scientific and Industrial Research, was not fit for human consumption.

A copy of the report, which is available with The Express Tribune, proves that the burger was toxic and the main cause of her death. Class-eight student Kanza Ahmed died on January 29 while her mother and two younger brothers fell sick after having four chicken burgers from Dilpasand Sweets’ North Nazimabad branch.

The report reads that the burger had traces of coliform as well as Bacillus Cereus — two forms of bacteria. The report was issued by the laboratory to the office of the police superintendent in district Central on February 13 but was not made public. The father of the deceased, Dr Muhammad Ahmed Bari, got his hands on the report on Monday. He had paid Rs8,000 to get the test done at the centre more than a week ago.

“No action has been taken against the eatery in question. More than a week has gone by since the report was out,” said Dr Bari. “Commissioner Shoaib Ahmed Siddiqui assured me that proper action would be taken against the restaurant once the report came out.”

Initial treatment

According to Dr Jabbar who initially treated Kanza at Hi-Life Hospital, the teenager had been vomiting and was suffering from a bad case of gastroenteritis. “In medical terms this means that she had food poisoning,” he told The Express Tribune. “This happens when a bacteria releases toxic and enters into the bloodstream and can be deadly.”

Dr Jabbar explained that such bacteria do not die soon. “It can take four to five days to lose its affect — in some cases it may take a week or more,” he said. “It all depends on the intensity of the toxicity.” He added that he was not certain which bacteria had claimed Kanza’s life and said they would need to conduct an autopsy to find out.

As Kanza had difficulty breathing in her last few moments, the doctor suspects that it might have been a bacteria known as neurotoxin. “The bacteria can affect the nerves, which are directly linked to our respiratory system,” said Jabbar. “Kanza was discharged after treatment and went back home around 3:30pm. She was brought back to the hospital around 4pm and was complaining about having difficulty in breathing.” He added that there was a drop in oxygen flow to her blood and her lungs were not functioning properly.

He explained that, by this time, Kanza had to be put on a ventilator. Her mother, who is also a doctor, took her to Ziauddin Hospital, which is less than five minutes away, in her own car.

Medical records

According to the treatment certificate from Hi-Life Hospital, a copy of which is available with The Express Tribune, Kanza was suffering from moderate dehydration associated with sunken eye. Her breathing was normal and after an abdominal examination, the doctor found that there was tenderness over the epigastrium — this means that her abdomen was probably hurting. Her respiratory rate was 44 per minute, which was unusual as it is between12 to 16 per minute.

Kanza was given Ringer lactate 1,000 cc drip to treat the dehydration and electrolyte imbalance. A Ciprofloxacin injection was given to her to treat the infection along with a meta colon injection to stop the vomiting. The report said that the hospital had advised the family to get the girl admitted.

According to Dr Yousuf Sattar of Ziauddin Hospital, Kanza was dead by the time they brought her to the hospital. “The family just wanted to know if she was alive,” he told The Express Tribune. “We gave her cardio pulmonary resuscitation (CPR) three times but there was no sign of life.” By 6:30am, the doctor pronounced her dead.

Her brothers, who also fell sick after eating the burger, were treated at Ziauddin Hospital and are doing better now.

Published in The Express Tribune, February 25th, 2015.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (5)

  • Sharjeel
    Feb 25, 2015 - 1:36AM

    Can you upload the report and provide a link?Recommend

  • Syed Sibte Hassan Rizvi
    Feb 25, 2015 - 5:25PM

    Good job by reporters of tribune. now Dilpasand should be banned.Recommend

  • Ali S
    Feb 26, 2015 - 2:05PM

    I rarely buy from Dilpasand, but considering that our authorities aren’t well trained in how to preserve crime scene evidence – could it have been possible that the bacteria developed in the half-eaten burger after the girl was ill? A thorough investigation of the eatery’s kitchen hygiene should also be mandatoryRecommend

  • Shoaib Pasha
    Feb 26, 2015 - 7:21PM

    My heartfelt condolences to the bereaved family. Another young life has been snatched away due to the callous attitude of all of us as a society. Now we are demanding that Dilpasand be banned. Why can’t we a responsible citizens ourselves completely boycott all such eateries and make sure they go out of business d as no one buys anything from them. Even Allah SWT helps those who help themselves!Recommend

  • anon
    Feb 27, 2015 - 6:38PM

    Very sad – may she always R.I.P. I always say that a hotel or restaurant can be 5 star but the staff handling food needs to know hygieneRecommend

More in Sindh