Hafeez is likely to undergo a Test on his action in Brisbane on the eve of the tournament but if he fails to get clearance, Pakistan are to gamble by taking to the field with only four specialist bowlers.
In the recent series against New Zealand held in the UAE, the team management gambled with four regular bowlers and the Black Caps rattled off big scores in the last two games of the ODI series to run away with the spoils.
In the last match before that series — the final ODI against Australia — Pakistan played five bowlers, including bowling all-rounders Shahid Afridi, Sohail Tanvir and Anwar Ali.
Wicket-keeper Sarfraz Ahmed opened the innings with Ahmed Shehzad as Hafeez was ruled out due to a webbing injury. Subsequently Hafeez was suspended from bowling at the international level after the Tests against New Zealand.
Selector Shoaib Mohammad, who chose the final 15 for the premier tournament along with five other members of the committee, feels that Pakistan’s batting has the pedigree to post and chase big scores in Australia and New Zealand.
According to Shoaib, the modern rules in the ODI format where only four fielders are allowed outside the 30-yard circle make things tough for both regular and non-regular bowlers.
“Now a non-regular bowler should be expected to concede six runs per over but I believe our batting has the depth and the pedigree to chase down the runs and even post big totals,” he said. “The depth in the lower order with Sarfraz and Afridi is our strong point, hence even if we are a bowler short, the batsmen can win games for us.”
Playing four bowlers is a risky proposition: Mohsin
Former coach and chief selector Mohsin Khan feels that fielding a bowler short can be hazardous for the men in green.
“Playing with four bowlers only against strong opposition in an event like the World Cup can backfire badly,” he said. “A bowler like Sohail can be exposed under pressure, even Shahzad and Younus cannot be depended on. The trio can be relied on every now and then but not all the time, especially in pressure situations such as the knockout stages. It would be unfair too on all these batsmen who are expected to chip in as bowlers.”
Sarfraz should open the innings: Rashid
Former captain Rashid Latif also feels that five regular bowlers are needed if Pakistan are to do well in the World Cup. The wicketkeeping great wants Sarfraz to play as an opener if Hafeez is ruled out as a bowler.
“The fifth bowler is absolutely essential, we should be sacrificing a batsman, and Sarfraz should open if Hafeez cannot ball,” he said. “Considering the rules in place, we should beef up our bowling stocks and rely on five specialist batsmen, and Afridi and Sarfraz.”
Hafeez will clear test: Basit Ali
Meanwhile, head of the junior selection committee, former Test batsman Basit Ali, is confident that Hafeez will be cleared before the World Cup. However, he feels that specialist batsmen and bowlers are the ones who generally win matches and should feature prominently.
“In an event like the World Cup, specialists help and we should also opt for specialists and play five bowlers,” he said. “But I think Hafeez will clear his action, mark my words he will be the same bowler as before, basically his problem is his left foot and the landing and once that is sorted, he should be back to his best.”
Basit applauded the emergence of Sohail as a fifth bowler but feels that a team like India can take him apart.
“India is renowned for their batting skills against slower bowlers,” he added. “Sohail might struggle to make an impact against our arch-rivals, so let’s hope that we have Hafeez available as a bowler for the crucial opening tie.”
Like Sports on Facebook, follow @ETribuneSports on Twitter to stay informed and join in the conversation.
COMMENTS (11)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Pakistan elven vs india
1M HAFEEZ/sarfaaz 2A shahzad 3younus 4misbah 5haris sohail 6u akmal 7s afridi 8M irfan 9w riaz 10 junaid khan 11 yasir shah
thats what allrounders were made for. idiots didn't pick any in final 15
Mr. Shoib Muhammad I am surprised to note that as a selector you are banking on our batting in the world cup.. Whereas batting is our weakest link, particularly when it comes to chasing big totals.
How naïve!!! We need to play with 6 batsman, period! Sarfaraz is a wicketkeeper-batsman and can be counted as a batsman. We need to play with 5 fulltime bowlers and if one of them is having a bad day, then only the part time bowler(s) can roll over their arms to get thru a few overs.
Counting on batsmen to win you matches - not a good idea .
"In the recent series against New Zealand held in the UAE, the team management gambled with four regular bowlers and the Black Caps rattled off big scores in the last two games of the ODI series to run away with the spoils." But the 5th bowler was one of the best for us with good economy and a few wickets too.
The whole process of selection has been faulty. You needed a fast bowling allrounder to make the fifth bowler but we don't have one. Some of the players who made the final 15 were not even played against Australia and NZ. Selection of Sohail Khan, Ehsan Adil and even Yasir can not be justified. You needed to select Anwer Ali, Umar Gul and Raza Hassan as all of three are better suited as bowlers and are good for 30-40 runs in batting. Now if you go with 4 bowlers and then lose one of them with injury then where do you stand?
It would be a mistake to play a bowler short. Pakistan batting is not known for posting big scores, much less chasing them down. I don't know where Shoaib Mohammad is getting that idea from. Just look at the recent 3 series, how many times did Pakistan batting score big? Ludicrous! We need to play 5 full time bowlers which has been our strength, and try to restrict the opposition to a score that is manageable for our batting. Hope Hafeez action is cleared which will be huge for Pakistan. If not, then we need to play someone like Bhatti whose speed will be helpful in the conditions and he can bat as well. Let's be smart about this and not play to our weaknesses.
I agree with Rashid if Hafeez can't bowl he shouldn't be in the side, If we leave out hafeez we can add a specialist bowler and play with five bowlers. The top 5 batsmen need to get the job done, if they can't then you can't expect No. 6 or 7 to win you matches. I picked the best Xi and feel that this is the best combination.
1) Shehzad 2) Sarfraz 3) Younis 4) Akmal 5) Misbah 6) Harris (can chip in with some overs) 7) Afridi 8) Wahab 9) Junaid 10) Irfan 11) Yasir (he may go for runs, but could be a wicket-taking option)