Interestingly, as an outcome of Imran Khan’s ‘Azadi’ march, people commenting on The Express Tribune’s website, Facebook and Twitter pages only have one thing to say: ‘Go Nawaz, Go’, whether or not the story or the image has anything to do with the prime minister or the PTI chief. It seems that this is the rhetoric of the nation these days (DJ Butt seems to also have picked up on it by incorporating it in the music for the rallies). Images of Malala, Ebola outbreaks, floods or the Northern Lights are all pounded with comments of ‘Go Nawaz, Go’.
Everything is linked to anti-government sentiment, so much so, that an individual commenting on the Northern Lights has said: “Wow! But GO Nawaz, GO.” Go Nawaz, Go has certainly become a trend.
Even on stories which shed light on serious issues such as depression, self-deprecating humour (the best kind of humour) is shared. On Malala’s win: “if Malala can win Nobel Prize then Sahir Lodhi can win the Oscar.” Other images have the slogan hitting out at Imran: “Ro Imran, Ro”.
Most of it can be rather humorous, but sometimes people leave extremely hate-filled comments which brings me to the next point — comment moderation does one more important thing: it gives one a good gauge of peoples’ mindsets.
Readers have simply left comments issuing threats as well as asking for the death of people. Positive things for the image of the country, such as Malala’s win, have led people to leave comments bashing her and moved on to people abusing each other’s mothers. You would think this is because of the divide between Malala lovers and haters, however, it’s alarming to see that people are pretty much hateful of almost anything. It doesn’t matter what the topic is, they love to hate.
For people moderating comments, aside from either being entertained or disgusted, ideas spew from the feedback we receive from our readers. We can learn to either avoid certain topics, or close comments on stories which will almost certainly bring about abusive content.
Published in The Express Tribune, November 4th, 2014.
COMMENTS (6)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
I think moderators of comments should not be the ones writing articles because there is too much incentive for the authors to moderate the critical comments out and slant the comments in favor of agreement. The best comments are often the ones who have understood the article and picked it apart revealing the authors biases and preconceptions.
I have had a comment congratulating a friend who got interviewed by Express Tribune removed (or not posted in the first place). The comment was not threatening or inappropriate or offensive to anyone, and it was in English (except for two words of Pashto). The comment ended with a prayer as well. So much for moderating comments via a consistent set of rules ET!
Hate was invented by Romans to create a new cannon fodder for their imperial design in IV century. The cannon fodder of converts were given alien words to containerize/direct HATE - Heathen, Unfaithful, Pagan etc. Pagan originally meant civilized. Romans directed hate of cannon fodder of fanatic new converts on Pagan natives of Europe and thus europe was brutalized or Romanized. Bedouins especially bania Kuresh perfected this Roman technique of Burkhafying barbarity under religious dogma which also is fossilized in a book. Thus barbarity in the garb of religion survives and fossilized manual of perpetual war and barbarity wipes out sanity, culture, humanity from native lands.
But moderators do not follow consistently the rules regarding publication of comments. Sometimes even relevant and non-abusive comments are trashed. At other times, some useless comments are published. ET must follow its rules meticulously.
Well said Raisa. We're indeed drenched with much hate and jealousy. We, as a nation, have a habbit of blaming all but ourselves, for everything wrong we face or do. Such attitudes depict imprisoned mindsets. Majority of us have double standards, bipolarity. Solution however, is education. Only education can change our approach to everything, letting us seek the truth, empowering us to respect others.