ICC-appointed tribunal biased, says Salman’s lawyer

Salman Butt’s lawyer Khalid Ranjha wants Beloff’s removal, hints withdrawal.


Fawad Hussain November 15, 2010
ICC-appointed tribunal biased, says Salman’s lawyer

KARACHI: Following the withdrawal of Aftab Gul, Salman Butt’s other lawyer Khalid Ranjha has called for a change in the International Cricket Council’s (ICC) appointed three-man tribunal that would hear the spot-fixing case against the three suspended Pakistan players. Salman, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif, who were suspended following spot-fixing allegations, are due to appear before the tribunal for the actual charges, led by the ICC code of conduct commissioner Michael Beloff, in January.

However, Ranjha said Beloff, who also headed the ICC hearing against the players’ provisional suspension last month, should recuse himself because of an “obvious bias”. Salman’s legal team had already suffered a blow when Gul withdrew from the case saying that he doubted that players will get justice.

“At this point, I agree with Gul because you can’t expect fairness from a man who is biased against you,” Ranjha told The Express Tribune. “We are not satisfied with Beloff’s verdict in Dubai [against the suspension]. Beloff should recuse himself because we doubt his justice.”

Ranjha, a former federal law minister, said he would like to present the case in front of another individual.

“It is my desire that someone other than Beloff be appointed,” said Ranjha before hinting his possible withdrawal from the case as well.

“It would also be difficult for me to fight the case in presence of the same judge. The decision is against the interests of my client,” said Ranjha. “It would be like fighting a case against your own appeal.”

Meanwhile, following Gul’s withdrawal, Salman is totally relying on Ranjha for the ICC hearing and was hopeful of getting his name cleared from spot-fixing allegations.

The hearing of all the three players will be heard from January 6 to 11 in Qatar.

The ICC CEO Haroon Lorgat had earlier advised the suspended trio and their lawyers not to mix the hearings of the three-man tribunal with the one held last month. While maintaining that the two hearings are separate, Lorgat also defended Beloff’s appointment saying that under the ICC code of conduct commission rules, its chairman had to sit in tribunal hearings.

Published in The Express Tribune, November 15th, 2010.

COMMENTS (6)

Usman | 13 years ago | Reply Before declaring these players as criminals, one should remember they have only been accused by NOTW which is a tabloid. Even SY has to level any charges in official capacity. It is extremely sad when people come and outrightly declare them as crooks.. I have no problem banning these players for life BUT IF FOUND GUILTY!!! I have a problem when ICC does NOT act on the official complaint launched by the SL Cricket Board with BCCI about Raina’s contacts with the known bookie. ICC did not suspend him and he is still a very much part of Indian team… Isn’t it ‘cuz both CEO and President of ICC is Indian??? Why does no one talk about these double standards??? If ICC has to act only on the evidence provided by gutter press then what is the use of its Anti-Corruption Unit??? SHAME on ICC and its boss Lorgat! He is clearly biased towards Pakistani players. This has become “Lorgat vs Three of our star players” and PCB should sought an explanation from this MORON!
Mamoon | 14 years ago | Reply Icc step by step is proving its biased character towards the paki players nd i completely agree wid the first comment , '' It is a conspiracy against Pakistan players ''.
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ