The promo of Coke Studio episode 2’s Phool Banro, sung by Abbas Ali Khan and Humaira Channa, features Fuzön’s Shallum as a guest musician, but we don’t get to see him or his name below the song title. According to Shallum, this is reflective of the producers’ unprofessional attitude, as any artiste who is not a part of the house band deserves to be acknowledged.
“If they are featuring all the guitarists of the industry, then they should give them due respect. This will reflect badly on their image, especially if they have an identity beyond Coke Studio,” Shallum tells The Express Tribune. “I am happier touring with my band than being featured in Coke Studio if it fails to give me due recognition.”
The guitarist says he is bothered by this inconsideration because words matter and any artiste would like to utilise a platform such as Coke Studio as a springboard for further hype. “Imagine what a Fuzön fan is going to think about the band’s key member not being recognised in Coke Studio when our new album comes out?”
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x244iue_fuzon-ankhian_music
Shallum is not the only one who did not get a special mention for his guest appearance. In Asrar’s Sab Aakho Ali Ali, musician Aamir Zaki’s name does not appear in the video, which is a awkward, considering most comments on social media platforms solely lauded his power-packed guitar solo.
Same is the case with Sajjad Ali’s Tum Naraz Ho, which features Pakistan’s well-known shredder Faraz Anwar as a guest musician. “Aamir Zaki and Faraz Anwar are also at fault for this,” says Shallum. “They should speak out because this is about standing for something one rightly deserves,” he adds. Zaki has been missing in action since the release of the first episode and could not be reached for a comment.
Faraz feels that people in Pakistan are accustomed to ignoring the instrument player in a song. “This is the extension of typical Pakistani mentality of treating the vocalist as an artiste and the instrument players as nobodies,” he comments. “I have been bothered by this mentality so often that I have stopped complaining. Ye Pakistan hai, yahaan sab chalta hai.”
However, Faraz also feels that Coke Studio producers Bilal Maqsood and Faisal Kapadia should have realised that such seemingly trivial things matter for artistes. “Faisal and Bilal are intelligent people and they have a band of their own [Strings]. At least, they should have realised how much these small things matter.”
Faraz is not concerned about his own image because he has been previously featured in Coke Studio and the platform’s audience recognises him, but feels this is unfair for first-timers on the show. “We should realise that guitarists have led band culture around the world, so sidelining them gives a wrong message,” he says. “In our country, half of the aspiring drummers end up becoming guitarists because jamming gets too disturbing when you live with your abu and ammi,” he adds.
Despite repeated attempts, Strings was not available for comment on the issue.
Shallum has lodged a complaint to the producers in the form of an email, condemning the “primitive and imbecilic strategy undertaken by the marketing team of Coke,” which is “clearly biased as far as guest guitarists [on the show] are concerned.”
COMMENTS (9)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
I guess Strings have always been like that. Shallum Xavier played on many Strings songs but was not always recognized in album credits. So following same on Coke studio as well. If Coke Studio can mention Ustad Raees among main artist why not guitarist like Shallum and Aamir Zaki
oh my what a big mistake from STRINGS! how could they
His guest musician house band difference is in the head. Ek episode mei ho ya dus, Naam ho to sabka ho warna kisi ka nahi. I think that's wise. is he saying he is superior or better than them and his name should be there? If that's case than that's very sad. I think it is smart to not name anyone and only give artist name. Producer ka Naam nai bi nai likha hai to tum kya asmaan se utray ho.
@Abdul Shabaz:
please have decency to recognize true talent. you sound like you are either a part of coke studio or affiliated with its people. this should be addressed this Pakistani mentality that faraz talks of should be changed
The guitarists are definitely correct with regards to how they feel. Faraz is very correct, and even being far removed from any musical background, I do notice the lack of care and the negligence when it comes to recognizing our legendary instrumentalists. People such as Faraz and Shallum are respected and looked up to by their tremendous fan following- how can you invite them to a show, as guests mind you, and not pay due respect? How is that treating them like "guests".
I agree with shallums complaints. When i was listening to these songs it did bother me that farazs or Amir Zakis name did not appear. After watching the promo for the second episode I didnt even know shallum was featured that is just simply unprofessional. Faraz is right too where he states that guitarists are not appreciated or thought of as real musicians in our country and that is very harsh. As a guitarist my self this is something I have faced.
In the behind the scenes before each song, every guest musician gets a fair share of screen time, so its not like they're being entirely neglected.
If Shallum was so concerned about his image, he should have just called the producer's because they have a friendly relationship, having collaborated on many tracks in the past such as 'Duur'. But obviously, considering how inactive Shallum's own band is, he needs to gain attention somehow, thus, this.
On the other hand, I respect how Faraz Anwar talked about this. He doesn't come across as attention seeking, plus he's super talented.
Shallum is an attention seeker, Faraz is a true musician. For Faraz I would say they add the guest guitarist names for next season.