The allegations of widespread rigging by voters and candidates alike, not to mention the results of court-mandated audits of votes cast, have proven that nothing much has changed since 2008 when the PPP claimed victory in an election where per The Express Tribune “almost half, or around 45.67 per cent of the total 81.21 million voters in the 2007 electoral rolls were dubious, if not downright bogus”. It is unfortunate for Pakistan’s voters that this news item was printed three years after that farcical election took place. That they had to endure another two years of the illegitimate, corrupt and incompetent PPP government for a third time is an even greater tragedy in the evolution of this so-called democracy.
As for the current prime minister, one can’t help but remember the first time this gentleman had a ‘mandate’. In fact, it is difficult not to recall exactly how this mandate ‘strengthened’ democratic institutions. Numerous orchestrators of that particular farce have already been exposed in the Mehran Bank scandal. As is often the case in Pakistan, the hand that gives, also takes away, and in 1999, when General (retd) Pervez Musharraf unceremoniously removed Nawaz Sharif from office, there were some celebrations and no protests.
The sad irony of the ‘enlightened moderation’ of the Musharraf regime conducting an election that brought yet another engineered parliament into existence can almost be offset by the appropriate nickname it earned during its stint – the King’s Party. No surprises then that as this parliament’s term came to an end, the now deeply unpopular ‘King’ was pressured by Washington to cut a deal with the late Benazir Bhutto. This historic compromise led to the wholesale pardon of varying levels of criminals and their subsequent return to parliament in 2008.
It is in this historical context, that the 2013 elections took place, an election in which fake degree holders, tax evaders, bank defaulters and religious extremists made yet another triumphant return to parliament courtesy the rubber stamp Election Commission of Pakistan and the country’s perennially failing legal system. The difference this time was that a sizeable number of middle class urbanites voted, precisely the kind of people that make a democratic process stronger. Not only did many reject the results of the election in their constituencies almost instantaneously, within days they saw a plethora of evidence to support their suspicions. A year on, the plethora has evolved into a tsunami of evidence of electoral fraud, in every province of the country.
The public’s willingness to accept military rule every so often, when viewed through the prism of decades of engineered elections, can only lead to one conclusion: the system being promoted by Pakistan’s Ivory Tower intellectuals is a Masquerade Ball at best, one that pretends at representation of the masses whilst serving elite interests in Washington, Riyadh and at home (in that order).
Noam Chomsky once said: “The American Intellectual Tradition is one of servility to power.” One can’t help but wonder what he might think of Pakistan’s own brand of neo-liberal intellectuals, who ask us to continuously place faith in a system that turns petty criminals, brownnosers and failed businessmen into oligarchs cum imperial toadies. They ask us to place faith in a system that empowers the very people who have the most to lose from the development of a pluralistic, democratic society. They discourage us from street protest, asking us instead to place our hopes for change in an electoral reform process that would be conducted by those who are responsible for undermining it in the first place. They tell us that even though court-mandated audits of selected constituencies have highlighted massive rigging, the results of the 2013 elections were, by and large, fair. Not one has so much as suggested a full recount of votes cast, something that Afghanistan’s politicians have agreed to undertake, precisely to strengthen their fledgling democracy.
No, their message resonates loud and clear: accept the election results as they are or else open the doors to anti-democratic forces to take advantage of the political crisis. It is not as if the Sharifs and the Bhuttos are Bohemian ‘Children of the Revolution’; they are products of the very anti-democratic forces we are persistently warned about. Their struggles with the Pakistan Army are comparable with medieval children fighting with their medieval father over who holds the keys to the castle. The concerns of the masses do not figure into that equation. Besides, the military brass, according to at least one high placed source, isn’t too eager to answer directly to the masses anyway. Martial law is a remote possibility at best.
Prior to the 2013 elections, a comprehensive third-party election audit wouldn’t have entered the realm of realistic possibilities. So however the mainstream media may endlessly debate Imran Khan’s motivations, he has brought Pakistan one major step closer towards finding the truth about how democratic its elections really are. That itself is an achievement. As a religious man, our prime minister should appreciate the value of truth and its relevance to democratic principles. So, for all the angst the PML-N is expressing in the mainstream media about the Azadi March, there is one simple solution: order the audit and demonstrate that there is more than one leader fighting for the establishment of a truly democratic nation.
Published in The Express Tribune, August 9th, 2014.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (12)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
I think I should enroll in M.A English Literature! Your English is too Awesome(this isn't a compliment) for me to understand!
What I did understand is that, you are trying to say that, current as well as the last elections were a sham! Agreed!
I have another solution which I think won't derail the democracy! Bring in resolutions/formulate policies that assure every person votes in the next election and vote via the bio-electronic system. And by next elections I didn't mean the next General Elections! I mean the Local Government Elections!
Correct me if I am wrong but the Provincial Autonomy gives the Provincial Governments the rights/Ability/Powers to do a lot more! Just assure the local govt. works!
PTI should set a best practices model when it comes to devolution of power, good governance and transparency. People voted PML(N) because they loved the development they saw in Punjab(I could be wrong here).
Oh and one more thing! This system will only change when people like you and me who call ourselves part of the "Civil Society" will join the political process in the proper manner!
Leaving the ground open for the feudal lords won't solve anything! Try contesting for a seat in Next elections, instead of just writing an article and condemning the people who contested!
@I saw your work after my first comment, your are with IK, so naturally you might not understand what I wrote before.
But I have never seen that the govt has not agreed for audit. YOU SHOULD PROVE CLEARLY THAT THEY HAVE NOT AGREED FOR AUDIT.
I SEE THAT 78% of the the consitutencies are being Audited so, your request for govt. to agree for audit false flat.
you can always protest in parliament for audit etc., this is first step of democratic movement, street fighting is last resort,
you people are too eager to through out a govt where your own strength is low?
How is it possible that a party in opposition for more than a decade can rigged the election , got victory , formed govt ? Totally bogus and appears to be imran khan is the replica of Aravind Kejriwal ? Psycho ?
so now a KASURI is leading the charge and the elections according to him that were free and fair were in 2002 under the TRUE DEMOCRACY of that GREAT MUSHARRAF and due to which the PATRIARCH KASURI became the foreign minister also the only time justice was served in pakistan was when another gallant KASURI got another corrupt PM ZA BHUTTO hanged
Excellent analysis...No leader can be religious until he speaks truth.So Nawaz is absolutely not.....
A well executed article highlighting the critical need of the people of the country be able to have their say through free and fair election. This is really the make or break point. Either the status quo will prevail or all shackles come off. The people must not accept anything less than an immediate, free and fair elections as a first step towards recovery. The rest shall follow.
"their struggles with the Pakistan Army are comparable with medieval children fighting with their medieval father over who holds the keys to the castle. The concerns of the masses do not figure into that equation." Sums it up. @vinsin: And pakistan has been in existence for 67 years now. Rome wasn't built in centuries either.
There is only that much one can take of all the chest beating about the last election. If these people have no faith in the election commission and won't accept the verdict of the highest judiciary in the land then the only conclusion left is they want to bring about an end to this govt. regardless of what it entails or, more likely, because of what it entails ---- chaos and mayhem. No well wisher of Pakistan should want any part of it.
@vinsin:
Good advice but patience has its limits and only Gid knows how we have spent the past 67 years under the misrule of the fascist "democratic" emperors.
As John Maynard Keynes said: "In the long term, we are all dead." We want freedom of speech, freedom of worship, freedom from want, and freedom from fear now! Plus some jobs, electricity, gas and security will be much appreciated.
Charge ahead Imran. Godspeed!
Well written- the supposed "democracy" that we have is not better than a looters charter for the elite. One set of crooks is normally replaced by another set. Its time to put an end to this rubbish and have real democracy.
Democracy is a process, it's a celebration/evolution, it's the only power of common man. In India itself electoral process was highly corrupt till 1991. It was changed by T N Sheshan. It took close to 50 yrs and close to 10 elections to make it perfect. Democracy is test a right man's patience and tolerance to it's extreme. Jan Sangh fought election continuously since 1952 and took 60 yrs to come to power. It is the duty of the opposition to question the ruling government and bring electoral reforms and wait for the next election. Rome was not built in a day.
Nawaz Sharif is neither religious nor does he have morals. Only thing he appreciates is absolute power through hook or by crook. The reason why the Sharif brotharans end is in sight is because they were never learned what democracy or honesty and fair play meant. For them rigging elections, killing protestors and stealing from the national kitty was all OK as they never had the morals to consider it wrong to begin with.