Lawsuit hearing: Security threats bar dolphins from performing

Organisers sue Maritime Museum for Rs100 million in damages.


Our Correspondent July 25, 2014

KARACHI:


Along with the citizens of the country, it seems that the wildlife is also feeling the impact of Operation Zarb-e-Azb. The dolphins will no longer be able to perform at the museum, it was disclosed by the management of the Pakistan Maritime Museum (PMM) in the Sindh High Court (SHC) on Friday.


This was revealed during the hearing of a lawsuit against the withdrawal of the contract of the dolphins dancing shows in Karachi. The lawsuit, currently being heard, is valued at Rs100 million for alleged violation of the terms and conditions of the contract.

M/s Dolphin Show International (Pvt) Ltd had approached the court against the alleged dispossession of the dolphins and their trainers from the Maritime Museum, where the event is being organised.

It had claimed damages worth Rs100 million jointly or separately from the Pakistan Maritime Museum Director General, the Pakistan Navy Commander Karachi (COMKAR) and the Coordinator of Dolphin Show PMM.

History

The Dolphin Show International (Pvt) Ltd says it had been arranging a dolphin show in the city with the mammals, including one Beluga whale, one dolphin and one sea lion.

The company had signed an agreement with the PMM management and invested in a Dolphinarium to bring it up to international standards. The plaintiff said it had signed an agreement with the museum management in June 2013 to hold the shows for 406 days. The plaintiff had asked for an extension on June 18, but the PMM management had asked them to vacate the premises. The organiser was instructed to remove the dolphins and their trainers.

Earlier, the SHC had ordered the PMM and other defendants not to take any coercive action against the plaintiff. It had further ordered that the defendants to seek prior permission from the court before initiating any action against the plaintiff.

During the last hearing, the court had issued a contempt notice to the PMM director general Capt (retd) Muhammad Riaz to personally appear and explain why contempt proceedings may not be initiated against him for violation of a stay order.

Latest hearing

During Friday's hearing, Advocate Umer Hayat Sindhu, counsel for the PMM  director-general, informed the court that the dolphins shows could not be held on the premises of the museum due to security concerns.

Sindhu said that around 3,000 to 4,000 people visit the museum during the shows and the museum's management cannot risk putting their lives in danger.

Syed Azfar Abbas, the show organiser, refuted such arguments. He contended that the museum's reasons for disallowing the shows during Eidul Fitr were malafide. The entire museum premises are open to visitors, but only the dolphin show is being disallowed.

The single bench, headed by Justice Syed Hasan Azhar Rizvi, directed the PMM management to let the show continue till August 8.

Published in The Express Tribune, July 26th, 2014.

COMMENTS (9)

Sane Pakistani | 7 years ago | Reply

@pakistani.. It seems you have jumped the gun in your eagerness to malign the armed forces..commenting without reading the news item...pls read the article,,,the organisers wanted an extension to the agreement ..nobody violated the agreement.the Naval authorities have the right to disallow the same for ANY reason..the FACT is that the organisers are getting greedy..they had plans to take the show to Lahore and Islamabad..but as they didn't get a profitable venue decided to use the dolphins and trainers in Karachi And make more profits..

Somebody who knows the facts | 7 years ago | Reply

I saw somebody suggesting that the show has been disallowed due to kickback issue. Absolute nonsense! The fact is that there are some serious security threats and authorities have taken the right decision of cancelling further shows. Would you guys prefer to allow these shows, witness some grave terrorist attack and later scratch ur heads that when everybody questions logic of continuing with the show with all these authentic security threats?! Certainly, No! For a change, be logical and appreciate the correct decision taken by Maritime Museum authorities.

VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ

E-Publications

Most Read