Cross-border firing

It is not a bad idea that military officials on both sides keep a hotline & talk down any problem that may arise.

Editorial July 23, 2014
Cross-border firing

The boom of artillery fire on India-Pakistan border leaves residents on both sides feeling nervy. It is not uncommon for the trade of bullets to escalate into a border skirmish that sometimes stretches for days on end. Innocent civilians become food for gunpowder in such duels, further straining the two countries’ fraught relationship. Last year, for instance, Pakistani and Indian forces sporadically exchanged fire along the working boundary in the Sialkot region for almost two weeks.

The skirmishes prompted villagers living close to the border to leave the area. Aside from the more prominent, headline-grabbing incidents, the minor ones keep taking place at regular intervals, which keep the border guards on their toes. After last year’s truce was violated on July 20, Punjab Rangers released data that puts the total of working boundary violations to 75 since the year 2011. Three people have lost their lives during the violence while at least 48 people have been injured in the last three years. The incident took place on July 20 when Indian troops resorted to unprovoked firing in the Charwa and Harpal sectors along the border in Sialkot. The Punjab Rangers DG visited the affected locations in the Harpal and Sajeet Ghar sectors of Sialkot the next day where he was updated on the recent Border Security Force firing on the posts and border villages.

It is no small mercy that despite such a large number of border violations, no major conflict erupted in their wake. But these small episodes still serve to keep bilateral ties hostage to belligerence and hinders efforts at thawing the icy relationship. Already, efforts by Islamabad to resume what had come to be known as composite dialogue have been thwarted by India’s insistence on quick conclusion of the Mumbai trial. It would be prudent for both the neighbours to at least keep the guns on their border silent, so that progress can be made towards resolution of all outstanding issues, including Kashmir. To that end, it is not a bad idea that senior military officials on both sides keep a hotline and talk down any minor border problem that may rear its head.

Published in The Express Tribune, July 24th, 2014.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.


Strategic Asset | 9 years ago | Reply

US & Pakistan were supposedly fighting for the same side and in constant contact on Pakistan's western border, but that didn't stop Pakistan from giving covering fire against ISAF forces to enable the good Taliban to infiltrate the border. If the US didn't succeed, how can India?

Feroz | 9 years ago | Reply

The situation on the borders will remain grim because the government of Pakistan has no control over its military, which remains answerable to none. To neutralize this asymmetric advantage of the Pakistani military the new Indian Government has given Commanders on the border freedom to decide and act on provocation, as they see fit. Not a very rosy picture for those citizens trying to build a peace constituency.

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ