Dr Arsalan Iftikhar, among other things, has been tasked with bringing investors to Reko Diq – a high-profile but controversial gold-mining project that his father, Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry, had taken up in a suo moto case when he was chief justice.
Recently appointed Vice-Chairman of the Balochistan Investment Board (BIB) – which Chief Minister Dr Abdul Malik Baloch defended in front of the media on Saturday – Dr Arsalan will be assigned to bring in foreign and local investment in the mineral sector including Reko Diq gold & copper mines project, a highly placed official from Quetta told The Express Tribune.
The provincial government is contemplating re-entering into an exploration and mining agreement with Tethyan Copper Company (TCC), according to the official.
Interestingly, a three-judge bench of the Supreme Court, headed by then chief justice Iftikhar, in its ruling on January 7, 2013, had declared void and in conflict with Pakistan’s laws a previous agreement reached between the government of Balochistan and TCC for gold & copper mining at Reko Diq in Chagi district on July 23, 1993.
Jan Buledi, an official spokesperson of the Balochistan government, said, “The BIB is assigned to facilitate investment for economic development,” adding that “the BIB is looking for investment for every sector, including minerals, and Reko Diq is part of the mineral sector.”
The spokesperson also tactically admitted that his government had been asked by the federal government and legal experts to reach an out-of-court settlement with the TCC.
“Both [the] federal and provincial governments would not be able to bear the financial losses in case a financial penalty is inflicted by the International Court of Arbitration,” he said, adding that “keeping in view the advice, we are making efforts to resolve the issue through talks with TCC.”
Buledi did not specifically name any multinational company that might have better chances of gaining the mining licence, but he said the TCC will also be entitled to apply for the licence when the provincial government calls for international tenders.
“I think it will be unfair to prevent TCC from participating in the bidding for a licence,” the spokesperson said. “The provincial government would like to settle all its legal issues with the TCC as its claim for financial compensation is pending in the International Court of Arbitration.”
‘Unrealistic project’
As a first step to award a mining licence to a suitable multinational company, the provincial government has already closed its own exploration and mining project of Reko Diq after finding that the project is unrealistic.
Funds that were sanctioned for the project under the Public Sector Development Programme (PSDP) in the last financial year of 2013-14 were blocked after closing down the project. “It was an unrealistic project. We have blocked funds that were allocated by the previous provincial government as it would have been a waste of public money” Buledi said.
The project, named H-4, was initiated by the previous provincial government of then chief minister Nawab Aslam Raisani in 2013 after he was convinced by scientist Dr Samar Mubarakmand that the Balochistan government was qualified enough to undertake mining at Reko Diq with its own financial resources and technical proficiency.
Raisani entrusted the task of exploration and mining to a newly created provincial organisation, Balochistan Copper Gold Project (BCGP), and appointed Mubarakmand as chairman of BCGP’s board of directors.
The provincial government had obtained an approval by the Planning Commission on the basis of a study conducted by experts that declared the project viable. The project was to be executed within four years, after the release of funds in 2012, with the total estimated cost of Rs8,812 million.
The present provincial government, after coming into power in 2013, not only dumped the project but also removed Mubarakmand and his team.
Buledi, while justifying the abandoning of project H-4, said, “The provincial government is not convinced that it had the required capacity to carry out exploration and mining on its own. H-4 was an ill-conceived proposition of Mubarakmand and his team.”
Published in The Express Tribune, June 29th, 2014.
COMMENTS (57)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Brilliant answer!!! @Umer:
@Fawad: Simple answer is NO!
Some one must understand that exploration work for any minerals are not so easy, its take time, money and hard work, when completing a project. Tethyan Copper company TCC completed hard exploration work in 16 years which started 1993 to 2009. Its right of TCC to start mining work in the area.
Rewards for services provided by daddy..
@M.Akram: "@Naeem every Pakistani is proud of scientist team produced by the beloved great khan".
You mean stealing of enrichment technology from the Dutch from Urenco, buying bomb technology from the Chinese and then organizing the great "scientific" team to assemble and paint green the nuclear bomb makes Khan a great scientist?
Tasked with luring investors e.g. Saif ur Rehman or some Shaikhs in our "brother" countries.....
The Question is. Why Arsalan Iftikhar?
Didnt his father use to take Suo Moto on appointment of clerks
Corruption is the biggest reason for the decline of this nation and hats off to PML-N by hiring this thug to make the pace more rapid :(
Now this is a shame! This government should be kicked they are less than PPP.
This an over hundred billion dollar project and can help reverse the down slide to Pakistan's economy. So make sure that Pakistan gets its salt's worth. Assure no kickbacks, please. Don't undersell.
@Raj - USA:
If Arsalan is put in charge of gold mines of Pakistan then even Qadri is welcome to bring a revolution as there is no other choice. Everyone else is already part of the game.
If Qadri can bring revolution, Arsalan can bring investment ........ as simple as that.
@Naeem: Please educate your self before commenting. Dr Samar has/had no connection with KRL and he is still more qualified than retired generals and bureaucrats heading several national technical institutions and universities.
Well obviously he's got the perfect resume for the job. From selling petrol chits to joining the police service after a stellar medical career, to becoming the youngest self-made billionaire. And now the greatest spin doctor has been asked to lure investors for the biggest natural resources project in Pakistan!
he said the TCC will also be entitled to apply for the licence when the provincial government calls for international tenders . TCC already owns the license that your trying to sell and chances are good that you will have to pay TCC several Billion dollars before your able to sell those rights to anyone.
OMG! What have you done Mr. PM & CM Balochistan by appointing this guy AI to this post, it is like giving Golden Spoon in his mouth. Just see the Sly Smile on this face in this photo. Very soon he will have a Golden RR in his fleet of cars. "Dad thank you".
The grin on the face of this criminal is that of the act that he and his dad pulled to fool 200 million people.
Malik Riaz has been vindicated.
All I can say is that this story makes me vomit!
pakistani youth will have to stand up and these people down one by one. One bullet a day for one corrupt head and country will be free in couple of years. No point sitting and crying.
CHINA AND THE US ARE AT NUCLEAR WAR IN AFGHANISTAN
By Greg Palast Jun 7 2013http://www.vice.com/en_uk/read/nucle...in-afghanistan Over all Pakistan is third world nation and known for its corruption and poverty in world. U will see the future result when India will be in Afghanistan to keep desalinating Pakistan .... we think USA wasted its 14 years in Afghanistan just for Osama , no they have larger interest.
Baluchistan had billions of dollar minerals and all the world has eye on that minerals , CIA , Australia , Canada gave billions of ruppes to Baluchistan govt for giving contract to its companies to exploit these minerals. ... Chairman Investment on minerals is is more Important than to CM position of Baluchistan , It involve billions of rupees.
KArazi is the richest person in south Asia as he has ten billion dollar in private bank account due to this mineral investment position. Afghanistan holds trillions of dollars of natural resources, including mineral wealth and hydrocarbons”, said Karzai
WASHINGTON — The United States has discovered nearly $1 trillion in untapped mineral deposits in Afghanistan, far beyond any previously known reserves and enough to fundamentally alter the Afghan economy and perhaps the Afghan war itself, according to senior American government officials.
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/14/wo...d=all&_r=0
The only qualification require for these kind of post is to be the family members of a high profile person - merit has nothing to with high profile jobs :D
This kind of decision encourage brain drain, and compel expats not to come back - as they are sure without contacts in the governments they will not be able to even find a job! Shame on you CJ and the Govt - you can't survive long with this kind of decisions.
After PPPs loot sale, now PML-N clearance sale is on... Pakistan ka Allah he hafiz ho.
Dr Malik Baloch should not have put his reputation on line for a proven crook son of an ultimate crook.
Perhaps Malik Riaz may be interested in the mines :)
@Naeem every Pakistani is proud of scientist team produced by the beloved great khan.If UR not avair dirty politics of thar coal and appointment of a medical doctor to take are of Reko Dig than plz do not say KRL scientist as copier .They produced the Deterrent Bomb and intercontinental delivery system under all restrictions .
This is a kind of bribe that comes under 'tactical' maneuvering, what a shameful innovation!!! To prove its independence Judiciary must take suo moto action against its own revered retired CJ with both father and son investigated alleging under bribe and demonising the whole Justice system of Pakistan and enforcing an immediate hold on this commercial bribe until cleared stainless. It is unbelieveable that an alleged criminally corrupt retired CJ took suo moto on so many previous government's officials but all those cases magically disappeared including this one where he and his son is benefitting now.
So dear countrymen Nation's gold would also be stolen by Sharif & Family and why cant they we are a nation of slaves (or worse lambs for slaughter) , While Arslan would as usual plunder in the name of father.T he looters would have to answer sooner or later I hope its sooner
Fat chance. Boils down to whether your win in arbitration ... and everything I have read said that nobody thinks your going to win that arbitration and there will be a multi billion dollar judgment against Pakistan. The real question is whether his father will eventually end up the focus of a criminal corruption review for a suo moto case with such an outlandish judgement that just happens to end up with his son brokering new deal.
Good investigative report.
@Naeem he is no scientist from KRL. He is son of Ex CJ Iftikhar Chaudhary. By the way as far as I know Doctor Samar voluntarily helped in Thar Coal project, which could not go ahead as there were no kick backs involved for PPP govt to benefit. Regards
Shame Shame Shame is he qualified and competed for this post .... Ex-CJP please answer
@U-turn:
Do you even realise what is going on? This is loot sale of our valuable resources not real investment.
Make millions rather billions. You got golden egg chicken. Be thankful to dad for his dedication and loyalty to people of Balchistan in particular, nation in general & sharif brothers in specific.
A wrong person for the job as his past is tarnished by a corruption scandal. How can he lure the international investors? He has no qualifications for that except for the fact that he comes from the same province but not from the two main ethnic groups of the province--Balochs and Pashtuns. His father no doubt is heavy weight and a clean person to lead the investment sector of the province.
Previously , you would hear these stories of blatant corruption from African countries. Thanks to CJ , I believe we would top the list of most corrupt nations in 2014-15. When the highest echelons of power are sunk in corruption then only God can have mercy on common people. The project of TCC that was termed as a violation earlier is normal now once commissions are paid.
Good Luck and all the best wishes for you to Steal and Rob more Money of my Country. As it is in yours and your father's genes, to tell lies, do fraud, steal and rob, it is best opportunity for you and your father to do it now, as too much time may not be available to you and your crook father.
President Musharraf vindicated PML- N has failed democracy..
This is called "Dudh ka rakhwala Billa". The entire game plan opens. Arsalan will be used by TCC to influence Courts and was being done during his father tenure when back door settlements were done by him.
Oh my god, our best resources would be given over for pennies, for a commission. No wonder he has been placed as the chairman as he won’t object to any corruption, for obvious reason.
When you say tactically, do you mean 'tacitly'? Because otherwise the sentence does not make any sense.
so the cat would guard the milk, pathetic. Look at this guy, from a FIA employee to CSS failure, yet inducted on CSS level, thanks to daddy jaan ebing CJ of Pakistan, this guy will be responsible for such lucrative deals, no matter we are in the drain, when people like him are taking care of our national assets what were we expecting.
Task means, use his previous experience of embezzlement and applies this new job. Then rest of Pakistan ask why there is a problem in Baluchistan .
Dad scared away the investors , the son now lures them , this is called all in the family , a new fiefdom on the horizon , be watchful Pakistanis .
How can a medical doctor have knowledge of mining? ?? Its ridiculous. ..
After taking a medical college seat from a Bloch and making billions the wolf is protecting chickens now. He has a real talent while using a govt address and making money for himself and the family. Why give any Bloch these lucrative positions? Let us confine all the ill-gotten wealth in a few hands. This is a payback from Sharif Brothers to the CJ who kept previous govt busy in the courts and gave a license to Sharifs.
I hope the Revenue from the wealth of Balochistan is spent in Balochistan not on other provinces. Secondly experience on Saindak project with chinese has gone miserably wronge. Saindak employes have inscure future, low pays, Water quality is unfit for health (a team of pakistan doctors found the water of swiming pools of chinese better than drinking water of local employees but the report never surface, thanks to bribes from our federal Govt), any employee serving there for 10 year or more has developed diabetes, hairlose, weakening bones etc. Despite all wronges, the project will still go to chinese for lesser revenues for province coz chinese are our stretigic partners.
How does his profile justify this appointment?
And they can't find a honest man in 180 million to do this job?
These so-called scientists from KRL amaze me..
This chap Dr. Samar Mubarakmand.. got himself a lucrative job promising to do wonders with Thar coal that no one had ever done, once kicked from there, he went to fool the Balochistan CM that he can manage mining... this is shameful but the truth is these guys from KRL are good at nothing except copying paid for technology.
Are for real ? Who is this Dr ? What expertise does he bring to the table ? Who gave him this job ? Lets have some transparency around his credentials ? I cannot believe this is going on at a time when the government is unsure of its future. What is the criteria is to turn down previous decision to undertake all exploration internally ? Who decides that ? Can the history and outcomes of such contracts (eg TCC) be made public ?
Mr PM Nawaz - remove the Dr from his post immediately and manage your affairs with a little more responsibility.
Is Malik Riaz in any way related to this non sense ?
Connect the dots you will see how poor in this county are exploited.
Do we have anything called procedures and merit in this country?
Best of luck Dr. Sahib.