Noor Hussain, 75, faces 25 years to life in prison if convicted of murder after allegedly subjecting wife Nazar Hussain, 66, to years of abuse at their Brooklyn home.
Judge Matthew D'Emic, hearing the case at the Brooklyn Supreme Court, could make a decision as early as Thursday.
Hussain's defense attorney Julie Clark argues it was manslaughter, that he did not intend to kill her and thought it acceptable to discipline his wife of 21 years.
On Tuesday, prosecutors showed the court photographs of Nazar Hussain's swollen, bruised face, and of her body lying on a bed next to a blood-soaked wall on April 3, 2011.
Police detective William Simon told the court there was blood on the bedroom wall, floor and bed, in the kitchen, bathroom sink and on a mop in the bath tub.
Hussain initially told officers that his wife died after waking up in the middle of the night, vomiting blood and having breathing problems, before admitting to beating her.
Simon said Hussain had cuts and what appeared to be teeth marks on his hands. "Finally he says 'I killed her. Lock me up. Arrest me,'" Simon said.
But during a one-hour video interview later that day, shown to the court, Hussain admitted only to hitting his wife "once or twice" on the arm and "once" on the lip.
"I asked her to make some goat, some meat. She said she was not going to make that, she was going to make something else," he said speaking through an Urdu interpreter.
He beat her with a wooden stick used to stir laundry after she "disrespected me" and threw it out the window because he feared he would be tempted to do it again, he said.
He then calmly told officers she was completely fine, and that the couple prayed together before going to bed.
At 12:30 am, he alleged she vomited blood three times, refused his repeated offers to call an ambulance and fell unconscious, before he telephoned his adult son.
His son telephoned 911 after arriving at his father's home to find his stepmother unconscious.
Vincent Maneri, an emergency medic, said he found Nazar Hussain with bruises on her head, a large laceration on her face and upper lip, as well as swollen and bruised arms.
Paramedics spent 25-35 minutes trying to resuscitate her in the early hours of April 3, but she never exhibited any sign of life, he said.
Neighbor Safida Khan told the court she heard the Hussains argue at least once or twice a week for years, and that she twice intervened, trying to pacify the warring couple.
On April 2, she said Nazar Hussain attended a religious gathering at her apartment, with a red mark on her cheek.
"I was told by her that he hit me with a phone and that's the mark," a heavily veiled Khan told the court, speaking through the help of an Urdu translator.
She testified hearing Nazar Hussain "crying and yelling" and her husband "cursing and shouting."
Hussain was arrested on April 3, 2011 and held in custody ever since. He could be jailed five to 25 years if found guilty of the lesser charge of manslaughter.
According to a relative, he has lived in the United States more than 30 years and used to work at a gas station.
COMMENTS (17)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Khalid: I spelled meat but my IPad has a mind of its own.
@gp65: Madam i do agree with you that domestic violences( mostly against wives) do exist in India too and yes there are compromises from the weaker sex for various reasons like financial insecurity, lack of courage to go against, fear/doubt about continuous support from parents. The domestic violence or beating of wife however is not acceptable in the Indian society and is condemned and or opposed Moreover domestic violence even if committed by highly educated and well respected people in their field is because of individualistic minds and least related to religious backing while sorry to say in Muslim society particularly in the financially weaker one it is proudly proclaimed ( while in the financially affluent it is subtle) that wife is obliged to obey the orders/ wishes of husband and she deserves a beating ( gravity of which may vary ) by the husband to discipline her and it has acceptance in their society.it is very unfortunate thta wife too accepts it ( to some extent).
@saad: Sir, domestic violence definitely does exist everywhere but surely the muslim society be it in Pakistan or in India (particularly financially weaker people) tend to believe and also declare it openly that wife is obliged to obey the orders/ instructions of the husband and and if she defies or goes against the wishes of husband then she deserves a beating ( may be mild) just to discipline her . AND IT IS ACCEPTABLE IN THE SOCIETY. i.e. it is a societal value based on the religious teachings by the Mullah. i do not know if really there is such guideline/ interpretation but if it is acceptable in the society it will certainly give a signal which non muslim in the west will not appreciate (if not scared)
@Singh: Domestic violence ( mainly against the weaker sex) is the result of mind one develops during his upbringing as sees in the society he lives in his initial years of life. Islamic teachings as interpreted by their scholars definitely gives an impression in the minds that wife must obey the diktat of husband and deserves a beating to discipline. I remember about a book available in canada titled how to beat the ( Muslim) wife.
Its true that domestic violence exists everywhere. The problem as I see it is that, we in Pakistan, don't seem to do anything about it. Its now part of the culture. Society condones that behavior. The wife is not a partner in life but rather a servant that one gets to sleep with. The women are brought up (and I appreciate the fact that this is a generalization) thinking that her role is to be subservient to her husband. Add to that the fact that we do not teach our women to stand on their own feet - which results in the women being forced to put up with the abuse. Having to live with someone who abuses you without a way out is real torture --- something the woman has to put with forever (and that too with a smile lest she want another beating).
When I read about the CII dictate that DNA is not admissible or conclusive in rape cases and about "honor" killings -- I am at a loss. A country with such potential throwing it all away over misinterpretation and misapplication of the faith, lack of education and really just lack of thought.
Islamophobia exists because we feed it. Look at the number of honor killings and the opinions by the CII. They don't have to make stuff up cause we provide them enough to talk about. In Pakistan if the victim forgives ... the case goes away. I cannot even express myself the way I want cause that kind of language would not be published.
I am somewhat older than most, but like the great majority of men have never hit a women. Regardless of any marital friction, striking a women is inexcusable. If some of the articles describing Pakistan marital relationships are correct I would not recommend that my daughters marry a Pakistani man.
@ali: very true, domestic violence exists everywhere in the world. The PROBLEM is that in Pakistan we hush it up, don't protect the victim, the law doesn't care, it's considered a taboo to even discuss. Here it is EXPECTED that the woman will obey, will stay silent if beaten.
In the civilized countries there are laws against such violence, and these laws are ENFORCED. Of course, when people like this dumb ignorant go to USA or wherever, they often never want to learn human rights, and often hate the local culture and people. Mind-forged manacles are often too strong for ordinary human minds.
"Discipline her".....seriously? We are hearing this from a man who killed his own wife. Its sad how little value life has to us now. Its disgusting....killing his own wife for his dinner......... How can we belittle the tragic reality of how foolish we are as a people by saying its an international issue. This is just one of the incidents from a multitude of others in which innocent women, children and religious minorities are killed by us in the name of honor or prestigie or sanctity or chastity or prejudice. It just takes one look at the newspaper to realize that we as pakistanis hold very little value for life and love to resort to bloodshed to resolve the most insignificant of issues. Its all very sad Hearing of incidents like people killing their mothers or daughters or wives over trifles like dinner. This is just a manifestation of our ignorance As people.
@p r sharma: Mr Sharma I live in USA from last 30 yr. & it is not uncommon of domestic violence here. So don't plug it with religion, race etc. Singh
after 15 years of marriage i asked my wife to make me some kebab she beat me up and i will never forget it
@p r sharma: it has nothing to do with Islam. I can only pity your bigotry, prejudice and Islamophobia. Similar things happen everywhere in the world.
What an idiot and then claiming 'it is a cultural norm to beat ones wife'? What sort of inhumane act is that? Is this what Islam came to teach us? To hit women? Or to respect them?
Sorry to say the incident indicates the mindset as developed in the muslim society in Pakistan that wife must obey husband's diktat and the husband has the mandate per Islamic guidelines to beat her to discipline.. The husband after spending 30 years in USA remained isolated with the human values which he must have witnessed during this period.
I will take daal over stinky goat mean any day and I stopped beating my wife at the age of forty because wife and kids started ganging up on me and they beat me up a couple of times.
Many in america and Europe kill their wives from oj to pistorius the list involves some of the more famous names too, as far as beating women often get beaten by their drunk husbands in americas. Family related violence including is high in Both north and south america. It is not just à Pakistani in america but many americans who do similar crimes ... Domestic violence is an international issue, however, islamophobia is too