India's Muslims make emotional return to riot-hit homes in Muzaffarnagar to vote

Villages went to the polls in the key northern state of Uttar Pradesh, where communal riots killed more than 50 people


Afp April 10, 2014
An Indian resident holds her election card as she queues with other to cast their votes at a polling centre in the village of Jaula in Muzaffarnagar District on Thursday, April 10. PHOTO: FILE

MUZAFFANAGAR: Seven months after fleeing deadly religious riots, mother-of-five Shaina Khatoon and hundreds of other impoverished Muslims made an emotional return to their home villages in Muzaffarnagar on Thursday to vote in India's election.

After driving for an hour in the back of a truck from a refugee camp, Khatoon, 28, arrived at her village under police escort and went straight to the house she was forced to flee when violence erupted.

"This is where I used to live with my family," Khatoon said as she stepped inside her home, now bare except for a few bricks and clothes.

"How can I return? I have little children, what if we are attacked again?"

The marathon election, with Thursday the biggest day of voting so far, is expected to sweep Hindu nationalist hardliner Narendra Modi and his Bharatiya Janata Party to power over the ruling Congress.

Among the 92 constituencies voting Thursday were a group of villages in the key northern state of Uttar Pradesh, where communal riots erupted in September and killed more than 50 people, mostly Muslims.

Since then, thousands of Muslims have been living in camps just kilometres away, too scared to return to their homes where they once lived peacefully alongside majority Hindus in a sugarcane belt.

The clashes erupted when Hindus allegedly killed a Muslim man supposedly for sexually harassing a woman, triggering  deadly retaliation that quickly spiralled into three days of riots.

With few toilets, little running water and just enough electricity in each tent to power one or two lightbulbs, conditions at the camps are poor. Some, like Khatoon, say they have not received compensation.

Instead of resolving the situation, politicians have been accused of trying to exploit the tensions in Muzaffarnagar district to win votes along religious lines, in a battleground state that sends 80 lawmakers to parliament.

Modi's right-hand man faces allegations of incitement after he reportedly told Hindu leaders in the area last week to seek "revenge" at the ballot box against a government that "protects and gives compensation to those who killed Hindus".

His party says the remarks were taken out of context.

Congress and the Samajwadi Party, which runs the government in Uttar Pradesh, are trying to win over Muslims, who at 13 percent of the population are the largest religious minority.

"My family will not vote for Modi. He was the one behind the riots," Khatoon said, expressing fears held by some religious minorities.

Many Muslims point to deadly religious riots in Gujarat in 2002, which Modi is accused of failing to prevent as the western state's chief minister. He denies any wrongdoing.

"We have not received any money. But I will vote for them (Samajwadi Party) in the hope that like the other victims, we will also get the money some day," said Khatoon, squatting outside her tent.

Inside, there was a string bed and a discoloured mattress on the floor along with a few boxes of belongings. With limited space, some of the family of seven sleep outside at night.

Khatoon and the others spent three hours waiting anxiously Thursday at the camp for the truck to take them back to Lisarh village to vote.

When they finally arrived, they were led by police through narrow lanes to the polling stations. Former neighbours from the majority Hindu Jat community stared at the returnees with a sense of familiarity.

But neither side spoke to the other.

COMMENTS (13)

Observer | 10 years ago | Reply

@Bakhtiyar Ghazi Khan:

"Shame on these Hindu extremists who forced Indian Muslims out of their homes. Thank God for Pakistan that we don’t face these problems. All prayers to Indian Muslims, may they get justice."

First, any riots, violence and suffering of human beings is to be condemned strongly irrespective of religious affiliations.

But, if you are really sincere about your comment, instead of shedding crocodile tears for the "suffering" Indian Muslims, why don't you demand that they be allowed to immigrate to Pakistan to escape the Hindu "extremists"? Wasn't Pakistan created for all Indian Muslims?

As for "we don't face these problems", did you ask the Shia, Ahmedis, Christians, Baloch, HIndus and Sikhs and other minorities?

G. Din | 10 years ago | Reply

@confused: "@3rdRockFromTheSun: When are u holding that referendum in Kashmir under UN supervision that Pandit Nehru promised?" As soon as you ( Pakistan) fulfill all conditions in UN resolution prior to holding the plebiscite. Good luck!

VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ