On June 5, 2013, when Nawaz Sharif was sworn in as prime minister, the economy of Pakistan was in tatters. Long power outages had disrupted normal life and stifled economic growth and there were reports that private businesses were moving out. With huge repayments due from a previous IMF loan, the stark reality of a default was looming large.
The PML-N’s immediate priority was to focus on electricity and economy, including stability of dwindling foreign reserves. Within a few weeks of taking charge, we set out an action plan for improving the electricity crisis and announced the Power Policy 2013. Our prompt response was clearance of liabilities in the electricity system – known as ‘circular debt’. To avert default on our loan obligations and to gain international acceptance of our economic strategy, we approached the IMF. This time, we did not need large sums of money. Pakistan has to repay more than $5 billion during the 2013 to 2015 period, including $3 billion which have become due in the current fiscal year 2013 to 2014. We, therefore, had no choice other than re-engaging ourselves with the IMF for a new loan programme.
The next step was to start the economic rebuilding plan. We presented an austerity budget by cutting wasteful expenditure, reducing a number of ministries, and abolishing discretionary grants. Secondly, our priority is to increase tax revenues. Next, we abolished the system of general subsidy so our revised subsidy policy only targets low income segments of society. To increase investments in the country, the PM announced youth loan, fee reimbursement and laptop schemes. For businesses, he announced incentives to increase the business footprint in the country as well as a deregulation plan that includes a greater role of private equity in businesses that had been mismanaged by successive governments.
Our strategy for rebuilding the economy has received recognition but also been the focus of debate on local media. A furore was raised as the dollar was traded at just under Rs111. On balance, economists voiced their concerns on the difficulties summoned by agreeing to a programme that would again seal the reputation of Pakistan as a ‘single tranche country’. It was also hammered that there were hidden provisions that would result in major devaluation of the currency, increase inflation and force wholesale auction of public sector assets at throwaway prices.
While economic strategies take time for results to emerge, one can share some early fruits of the plans.
The economy has started to grow, with the quarterly national accounts pointing to a GDP growth rate of 5% in the first quarter of 2013-2014, compared to 2.9% in the first quarter of 2012-2013.
Inflationary pressures have started to ease, and as compared to inflation in November 2013, prices in December 2013 and January 2014 have witnessed reduced momentum.
Budget borrowings have reduced drastically. As against an IMF target of 3.5% for the first six months, budget deficit has been recorded at 2.2%, even better than 2.6% actual recorded in the same period last year.
Exports are also picking up, with the exports (fob) up by 3.2% in the first six months, compared to the same period last year. The most significant increase was recorded in textiles which increased by 8%.
Home remittances in the first six months have also recorded a growth of 9.5%, indicating a healthy growth over a high base and much above the target growth of 6%.
The rupee has stabilised; measures have brought about the exchange rate stability and it is trading steadily around Rs105 a dollar to 106 a dollar range without any significant speculative activity.
Reserves have moderately stabilised and are expected to grow in coming months.
Our stock exchange is thriving, and over the past seven months, the Karachi Stock Exchange has performed better when compared with a host of other stock exchanges around the world.
While there is good news on many fronts, our challenges include increasing investments both from domestic and foreign sources so that job creation can be enhanced, building up of reserves without incurring high debts, increasing tax collections and employing better ways in using them, managing our national assets in a more productive manner, and focusing on human development.
Going forward, some important initiatives include deregulation, increased investments to enhance energy security, undertaking of structural reforms to improve management of public finances especially improvement in tax collections, making Pakistan an attractive investment destination, and a new economic growth policy.
All major indicators of the economy are pointing to the fact that the economy has begun to show signs of revival and that it is moving on the right track. Challenges remain on the horizon and much work remains to be done, but the key to continued success would be to remain on course and avoid distractions that can sway energies in undesirable directions.
Published in The Express Tribune, February 25th, 2014.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (53)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Nida Alvi:
haha..you're fooling yourself and everyone here. everyone knows how the may 2013 election was conducted so any victory for the PML-N was null and void in my opinion. that said, ishaq dar is the same man who in 2008 after being appointed as FM came out and said that the previous governments (not a dictatorship) numbers were all wrong. imagine how that helped our image and our credibility? only an idiot of the highest order would make that statement, that too the finance minister of a country. read rauf klasras article published in the news a few days ago on what NS and co. have been up to in their recent 'vacation' in the outskirts of sindh. shameful.
@Exxo: FYI - as usual, PML-N politicians are simply copying other's ideas. PTI leadership has been posting regularly in the news. Imran Khan, Andaleeb Abbas and more recently Asad Umer to name a few.
@Nida Alvi: I am an Indian and not a supporter of any political party in Pakistan but you have quoted so many incorrect and/or misleading facts that I felt it necessary to rebut.
"4. Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) is pouring in with initiation of a large number of mega infrastructure projects particularly in the enery sector."
Factually incorrect. http://tribune.com.pk/story/660151/fy14-fdi-inflows-drop-sharply-by-27-in-first-half/ . Foreign direct investment has actually dropped.
"6. Achievement of GSP Plus for textile exports boost by US$ 1 Billion every year and creation of millions of new jobs."
This initiative had been pursued dilligently for over 2 years by Zardari's government who had passed all necessary ordinances in ordeer to satisfy EU requirements.
"7. Endeavors to make peace with neighboring India & Afghanistan. Re-start of DGMO level meetings with India after a gap of 14 years. Economic prosperity always follows regional peace."
The DGMO level meeting was needed because the ceasefire signed in 203 was trashed when Mian saab initially resumed power. 5 Indian soldiers were ambushed and killed in August 2013. Pakistan talks about improving trade with India but refuses to honour Pakistan's commitment to give India MFN despite India having carried out all its agreements. While Mian saab talks a lot his actions and those of his brothers (funding JuD) are not conducive to improving relations with India. I am not saying that you should do that. Please do whatever you feel is in your national interest. But do not make claims which cannot be backed up by facts. As far as Afghanistan goes just a couple of days back te Afghan government accused Pakistan of giving safe haven to terrorists who attack Afghanistan and its soldiers.
The stock market index (I.e., barometer of the economy) has crossed 27,000 mark & is scaling new heights.Yes and the remarkable climb started in 2011 under Zardari and continued for 2 years under him due to the policy of not asking for cource of funds for any investments in the stock market. WIth the market being as thin and poorly regulated as it is, it was not considered a barometer for economic success during Zardari's rule nor should it be considered that now.
"2. Reduction in loadshedding with re-start of power plants shut due to circular debt, re-initiation of Nandipur, Chicho-ke-Mallian & Neelam-Jhelum projects and initiation of Solar Energy Park at Cholistan."
Neelum Jhelum has not achieved financial closure. IT ws already innauguarated twice before PML-N returned to power in 2013 and that is the same status now. IT sought help from ADB who basically said it has limited funds and will commit those to Jamshoro. It asked Pakistan to find its own funds for Neelum Jhelum which is a dead end. We also know what has happened to the IP pipeline.
This article is the need of the day. Give full credit to Ishaq Dar for trying to instill confidence in an otherwise hopeless situation.
Nice to see an article about economy with highest comments instead of terrorism related articles.
@Sarmad: Had they been given time to complete their term previously, then you could say that they failed. Let's give them proper time and see if they succeed or fail.
@ Nida Alvi, Dear sister dont be ignorant, I myself is a Chartered Accountant and firmly believe that its not the work of a CA to run the finance ministry of a country, its the job of an economist. I wonder if someone has conveyed Mr. Dar the comments passed by very senior Chartered Accountants in the post budget seminar of Institute of Chartered Accountants of Pakistan on his vision as reflected from the budget.
Regarding the number of votes PMLN obtained in the election, I would say yes it did, but also consider the above comments of which almost 80% are negative, you should also accept it, as it is democratic regime.
@Exxo: He's not defending anything. He's giving us the "official narrative". Like he and his ministers did in front of professional economists:
"In the second meeting, economic experts were expecting that they would be asked to give their input on specific issues, according to a participant of the meeting who requested anonymity. During both meetings, most of the time was consumed by government officials and members, he added."
http://tribune.com.pk/story/672296/advisory-committee-with-low-reserves-eac-advises-against-euro-bond/
You say reserves have stabilized. Yet on Feb 7 your reserves wee the lowest level in over 12 years. If the CSF had not come through the next week, you wold have been in deep trouble. Your expectation of reserves increasing is based on bogus stuff like Etisilat repaying 800 million which has not happened in 4 years, assumption hat the entire amount of spectrum auction will be forex, much higher loan sanctions from ADB and World Bank than appear to be on the cards currently. Your reserves are insufficient to pay even 3 weeks of moorts. Moreover, the current account deficit is much higher than budgeted. Under the circumstances, your currency is articifically propped up.
Mr Dar, please build Pakistan's economy right here in Pakistan, it'd be nice for a change and we Pakistanis would also benefit from this and certainly would appreciate if you could start doing what is right and for what we hired your lot at all.
Mr.Dar is running the financial affairs as if the country is part of Ittefaq Group.
http://tribune.com.pk/story/657574/for-the-record-imf-blows-holes-in-ishaq-dars-claims/
Also, the next governor of SBP will have only one criteria and that is he should be a 'Yes' man so that whenever Mr.Dar needs money, it will be printed with no questions asked.
Increase direct (progressive) taxation, and decrease indirect taxation. Stop providing tax shelter to so-called agri income, we all know that is an unethical concession to the feudals. In the 21st ecntury, their time is up, they had fun while it lasted - time to pay up now.
Sir what do you have to say about the resurgence of the circular debt.
A man who himself involved in money laundering and evading tax with false statement of Qarz-e Hassna of millions is asking us to pay tax and want to improve economy, what a shame for this nation (one more time)
Excuse me - you have done nothing to increase the TAX COLLECTION BASE. At least you are not pretending that you have either. That's the key issue - along with security.
You can say whatever you want. The reality is that nawaz league will take ua to bsnkruptcy just like 1999.
Appreciation for Mr. Dar for trying to connect to the people and have the courage to defend his economic policy. Much applause for that. We may disagree with the economic policy but this approach of getting people on board through newspapers is encouraging.
@ some of the comments above Typical pakistani approach, if u hate the man, find one fault and ignore everything good he has done.. while of course there is a need to do more we should acknowledge his efforts and the signs of improvement, tax revenue has increased by 20 %, imf has revised upwards its prediction of economic growth, foreign investment is flowing in, gsp plus status is achieved, for the first time in many years gas is being provided to industries, power thefts are being caught, at least some positive signs are there, for the first time taxes have been applied on high income ppl.. while still tax base needs to be broadened, i think there have been some good steps taken and should be appreciated
Have you consulted the TTP ( the future rulers of Pakistan) ? Did they approve of the Islamic methods used to measure the GDP?
Waiting for the Ishaq Dar claim become reality 1$=Pak Rupee 90!
The PMLN Government is really pushing the wheel of economy forward... This fact is manifested in the stock exchange index (barometer of the economy) scaling new heights and Foreign Direct Investment coming into the country to generate income & employment opportunities. Pseudo-intellectual haters are gonna continue their hate but the economic indicators are showing visible improvement in Pakistan.
@ria: the finance minister himself writing….wow….
here they lift behind 5 times a day, after which they loose focus.So they write.
@Its (still) Economy Stupid: don't you know, our Finance Minister can only write, he cannot read or comprehend anything!
No, wrong Mr. Ishaq Dar. You either wrote this article to delude the public or you yourself are not aware of the dark pit your government has driven the common man in. Now, systematically dealing the points you raised:
The remittances have increased primarily because of their demand in the country. People are getting poorer day by day, hence the relatives abroad have started to cash-in their savings accounts and are sending more money here. Suicides have increased, prostitution has increased, the labour class has started to sell its organs and children just to EAT. Is it not true that the IMF loan scheme's assessment paper by IMF itself indicates that as a result of the loan: a) 1.2m people will loose their jobs? b) USD to PKR exchange rate will be around Rs. 127? c) Economic growth will be down to 2.6% from 3.5% This was ALSO indicated by Asad Umer in his speech in NA. There was no response against his statements from any member of the finance ministry!I will not be a party to this article where the minister himself is portraying that streams of honey have started flow when evidently at ground zero I find people praying for their death. I will not let my people be led astray at all. My people! Wake up and look how the fire burns around us! Due to such incompetent rulers our people are driven to slave labour, yet again you let yourselves be boggled by useless mathematical models and economic indicators? Were 9 months not enough for this government to make a change? If the previous government had done such huge damage to the country under Zardari's leadership why is the PML-N government not taking strict action against all those involved? There have been no convictions and no punishments, no recovery of the damages from the ones responsible. The truth is, they all are from the same lot. Different faces, same selfish agenda. Shame on the brutal rulers brought upon us through rigging and lies... 'Is khulay jhoot ko, zehn ki loot ko, main nahi manta main nahi janta...' - Habib Jalib
First Qarz utaro mulk sawaro and now Qarz badhlo mulk sawaro. Come on man, make up your mind before going forward.
Where is bullet train,Kashghar-Gawadar motorway rail projects also mother of all-anti terrorism policy.Also what is the guarantee that loan for youth will not be used for purposes other than declared in application.What is the use of laptop without printer, you tube etc.Also where is solid program for human resource development.Are some mega project left for last years of this government tenure to win next election.
Well done Pakistan’s Federal Minister of Finance Dr. Ishaq Dar. Under the able leadership of Pakistan’s Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif and your stringent efforts Pakistan’s Economic and Financial Conditions are bound to improve dramatically and out pace Foreign Exchange Reserves. I am looking forward to see the fruits of Pakistan’s Improving Economy by way of Increased Exports as well as Foreign Exchange Reserves, Employment along with a marked improvement in Education, Health and Welfare of the Pakistani People. . Congratulations indeed. . Cheers
Some fundamentals are missing. Law and order is a must for improving economy in terms of foreign investment and domestic stimulus. Doctors and rich people are kidnapped and get call for extortion. Under these circumstance area where government can stimulate economy without borrowing has been ignored. Minister should read how Mayor Rudy Giuliani of New York stimulated economy by bringing law and order at the street level.
Only if this was done out of your own accord and not under IMF's umbrella it would have been more beautiful
the finance minister himself writing....wow....
First of all I would like to thank you Mr. Dar for putting in an effort to write this article for the public to know whats going on. But again, you first bring the dollar so high, then drop it, and say economy is improving? Who are you trying to fool?
Imran would have ordered the GDP growth rate to become 1100%.
How about taxation? The affluent remain beyond the realm of the taxation. Use the data NADRA has collected, make people pay what is due. If not you are accomplices in theft.
At the risk of taking flak from N-leaguers can I please say Ishaq you have failed twice already. Why are you offering the same song and dance again?