Barking up the wrong tree

The government does not have any plan, except to carry around the begging bowl to the western capitals.

Yousuf Nazar October 24, 2010

Pakistan needs to revive its stagnating economy now and control galloping inflation. The chronic issues of fiscal profligacy and narrow tax base have assumed crisis levels. The government does not have any plan, except to carry around the begging bowl to the western capitals. Our never-ending pleas for more aid are testing the patience of the donors who are openly taunting the elite of Pakistan to ‘do more’ for their country.

Our president is fighting for his survival while the prime minister is bogged down by multiple crises. As for the finance minister he can find the time to travel to Boston and address Harvard students — which clearly reflects on his sense of priorities. Meanwhile, the most powerful person in the country, the army chief, remains India-centric and tactically focused on the Pentagon and the Taliban.

Externally, the western powers are engaged in ‘currency wars’ and have made China and its strong currency the scapegoat for their problems. The drought in Russia, flooding in Canada and parched fields in Kazakhstan and Europe have ruined crops, fueling food price inflation worldwide. Russia and Ukraine, two of the world’s largest producers of wheat, have stopped exporting wheat. Faced with the threat of a supply crunch, India recently increased support prices for wheat and pulses to encourage farmers to grow more.

Many government and even private economists seem to be oblivious of the international context we are operating in. Dr Ashfaq Hassan Khan recently wrote in the The News advocating a freeze in the price of wheat — which is likely to do more harm than good.

The Americans are both begging and threatening the Chinese to devalue their currency to make US exports more competitive. Poverty and inequality in the US are at an all-time high with around half of those currently unemployed out of a job for more than six months. Clearly, we are barking up the wrong tree for a strategic alliance and aid.

The initiative taken by some political parties and groups for the cancellation of Pakistan’s $55 billion of foreign debt is important but unlikely to succeed. But that is just one issue. The two more important ones are taxes on the rich and drastic cuts in military and civilian establishment expenses. We can save about 1.5 per cent of the GDP by making deep cuts in military and civilian expenditures, and by reforming tendering and land auction systems.

It is possible to generate 1.5 per cent of the GDP from taxes on the rich, regardless whether they are urban, rural, landlords or businessmen. Thus we can generate $8-10 billion per annum from debt cancellation, expense savings, and additional taxes or $5billion every year, (excluding debt cancellation).

However, my experience with government officials has convinced me that nobody wants to do anything. The only way to force them is through a mass movement.

Published in The Express Tribune, October 25th, 2010.


Shazia | 12 years ago | Reply Narmeen, I agree with you. Ultimately people of calibre and vision can and do make a big difference. Look at India’s top economic planners and compare them with our lot. India too had and does have huge problems. The problem is our governments and politicians can only stomach yes sirs and not independent thinkers. I agree with Mr. Nazar that while the world is looking towards East, we cannot change our US centric mindset.
Meekal Ahmed | 12 years ago | Reply @narmeen, Our problem is not that "highly qualified" people have gone abroad. Sure, some of our best minds did go off to pastures greener (World Bank, IMF, Asian Bank etc) but even today despite that brain-drain Pakistan still has good policy-makers and good economists. Moreover, our problems are so glaring and so obvious that you really don't need a hoard of PhD's pouring over some esoteric, unfathomable econometric model trying to find solutions. There is no magic to raising taxes efficiently and equitable nor in cutting wasteful spending, solving the circular debt issue, restructuring the loss-making public enterprises starting with a 40% cut in their work-force at all levels, reducing inflation, reducing banking spreads, coming down hard on monopolistic, anti-competitive and collusive behavior in the marketplace, cleaning up non-performing loans, giving the State Bank more autonomy, and so on and so forth. You just need a minimum amount of intelligence and a hell of a lot of commitment.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ

Most Read