There is also a third element in this affair; the militants reportedly were a little confused over nominating Imran as their representative as he did not satisfactorily fulfil their criteria of being religious. Now that Imran has shown his inability, the militants have also voiced their disappointment over his decision to opt out of their nominated committee. Indeed, the militants were rightly confused over Imran’s suitabilityof acting as their representative. But then, the counter-argument, as reportedly debated by the militants, was that they were nominating him as their representative in order to achieve the objective of achieving peace and not to enforce (their own brand of) Sharia. Here, they seem to have struck the right note.
The Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf, (PTI) under the chairmanship of Imran, stands for restoring peace in the country through a negotiated settlement between the state and insurgents. It considers dialogue as one of the solutions, a preferable one. When the PTI chairman says that the militants are our own people, he is simply narrating a fact as both the leadership and the rank and file of militant groups are Pakistanis, who have taken up arms against the state. They are a mix of all ethnic and linguistic groups of Pakistan. Narration of facts should not enrage Imran bashers, who mainly belong to a segment which calls itself the educated liberal class. Sometimes, the Nato supply blockade is also clubbed with their propaganda. Nato supplies have been blocked because successive Pakistani governments have claimed that the US undertakes drone strikes without their consent which amounts to violating our sovereignty. Militant groups draw their inspiration from anti-US hatred, which also serves as a major source of motivation for their leadership and foot soldiers. The PTI has refused to let repeated US violations of our sovereignty go un-responded, especially when a US drone strike sabotaged the much-needed dialogue process giving a clear signal that the US would dictate what we can or cannot do to resolve our internal matters. The insurgency that we face has become stronger and more violent with increased US dictations. Therefore, checking or limiting US dictates on our sovereign state is a pre-requisite to dealing with the insurgency, if not for other reasons. Then there are many resolutions of our legislatures coupled with an order of judicature requiring stoppage of drone strikes.
Whatever has emerged during the formation of committees to initiate the peace process has proved the fact again that Imran is neither ‘Taliban Khan’ nor any other Khan. He is what he is: he is Imran Khan who has his own vision of making Pakistan a modern, democratic, independent, corruption-free and a welfare-oriented state.
Published in The Express Tribune, February 8th, 2014.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (35)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Uzair: Am completely with you on this.........I too am being shut out and the interesting forum this once was, has changed. All I can think of is that ET must be having genuine concerns but they must also realise that the reader depends on and expects them to hold tough and deliver.
Shameful for the Tribune to publish such fanmail garbage. It should only be allowed to appear as paid advertisement.
Give IK a chance to mature, he deserves that, period.
ik is not confused nor his supporters. his supporters know he is heading in right direction. their are two kind of groups, one who are pro war; they want war at any cost and want to eliminate their enemies by power and thos who are realist; they know war means only flowing of blood. it was pak army's analysis if they go after taliban in n.waziristn, there are 60/40 chances of win. so talking with them is the only solution, they are fighting a gorrila war we have to negotiate with them and every one who are acting on same lines. but once the negotiations are failed going after them is the only solution but with tactics and with national policatal concences. read history of irish republicans etc they may help us realise the actual solution.
I wonder how many of these commenters are the same people using different names
I wonder how many of these commenters are the same people using different names
Who is Imran Khan? A man who thinks 180 million people are fools and can be fooled on daily basis.
Why are we arguing over "Imran Khan"
Because he tried to prove the people Pakistan by giving them an alternate option and making Nawaz Govt turn a little harder by acting as a real opposition?
While the democratic history of this proud nation see's 2 political parties turn by turn becoming richer and richer day by day and we the people of this land suffering.
The fact remains that more than Imran there were hopes with the present government but no one dares speak of the vows they made before election and the PM himselfs speaks and says to ignore the irrelastic commitments which they made in election campaign as a result of "Josh-e-Khadabaat".
The energy crisis was to be resolved in 9 months no blog post speaks for that and the bullet train which was to run Peshwar to Karachi. We all know Mr. 10% very well but cannot trial him. Why?
Conclusion: We as a nation we have to deny the status qou empower our true representatives.
Imran Khan only mistake is that he is not willing to sell himself to the Americans or the people who actually rule us.
He has the dare to look them straight in the eye and say no, admit his mistakes as a leader, and think for the actual well fare of the country instead of his MNA's and multiplying his assets.
Imran Khan string is pulled by some one from behind...Shereen Mazari is well known linked to hidden hand in Pakistan
Good written but IK is alleged as u turn specialist and he must focus to build his image as positive politician.
Surprise, surprise, PTI fanboys have learned to write coherent articles. Keep on justifying your 'dear leader', he's already chosen his fate for the next elections.
P.S. I voted for PTI during the May elections, a decision I now regret
In case you come across issues in understanding the meaning of "self-styled liberals", go through comments section.
Imran Khan is a fraud and now using his PR minions for damage control. He was chosen by the Taliban as their representative only because he is their staunch supporter along with the other three nominated by them. Can anyone imagine the Taliban choosing a moderate person with a balanced approach and honest thinking? So, we all know 'who is Imran Khan'. No kidding.
IK used to be a ray of hope in all past years but no one never thought that IK would prove a lunatic, a person with ludicrous vision and a leader with disgusted leadership skills. In last few months he made his staunch supports to repent to regret and to kick themselves. Actually everyone over-rated IK abilities, capabilities and expended dynamics and why they would not, IK portrayed himself in a way that a naive too get coxed.
Probably the only leader after M A Jinnah and Bhutto who thinks, talks and makes his policies in the interests of Pakistan. He is neither scared to put out the truth in front of the nation nor a part of the capitalist-feudal nexus that his ruled this country since its creation. Yes, he is stubborn about his beliefs and policies but that is a merit in a true leader. Mountbatten also took Jinnah to be a "stubborn communal leader" and Martin Luther King. Jr was also taken to be too "naive" and "anti status-quo" leader by Hoover and company. However, I do hope his plans to introduce a uniform education system in the K-P succeeds as well as his other policy initiatives of health and justice.
@ET Editors: Why have you not been publishing my comments recently? You know that what I state is the truth, harsh as it may be, yet somehow you seem to have adopted a more right-wing and censoring-the-truth approach. Disappointing and makes me lose faith in Pakistan even more.
Yes, we fully support the decision taken by the core committee of PTI, because of Imran Khan is neither a representative of any taliban group nor any other militant group. He only wants the peace through dialogue process and advocates dialogue to bring peace and development in the country.
A propaganda is running underway in media now a days against Imran Khan to prove him a pro-taliban leader. He is not a pro-taliban but he is a pro-dialogue leader.
CM Balochistan Mr. Malik is also requesting the baloch separists (who are in contact with indian raw and other agencies and they support the separists in destroying law and order in the province) to beging a peace talk. It simply means that now Mr. MALIK is representing RAW or any other foriegn agency, as a result of being an advocate of peace talk.!!!!!
Yesterday, Mr. Bilawal Zardari in an interview to an indian channel, reiterated to begin talk with india to bring sustainable peace in the entire region. It means that he is a representative of india or he must lead and represent india if these peace talks begin with Pakisan.
With Imran Khan what the media is creating confusion is really a shameful act.
The Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf, (PTI) under the chairmanship of Imran, stands for restoring peace in the country through a negotiated settlement between the state and insurgents.
i.e PTI wants Pakistan to officially surrender FATA to the Taliban and seeks no justice for the murder of it's fellow citizens and soldiers at the hands of the Taliban. How much more are you willing to negotiate away?
IK is the real leader of Pakistan. but our poor people are fooled by clever politicnaes.
He has said this over and over; wanting peace does not mean you're supporting militants. This is not rocket science people! Either you "bashers" choose not to rationally listen to what he says...or maybe you're just too dumb Either way if we actually do listen to your logic that everyone who demands a peaceful way out of the war on terror is a militant, then I think the US administration should be declared a militant organization itself for wanting a peaceful exit out of Afghanistan. Nobody bashes Obama for wanting negotiations :D.. Anyways, aside from his WoT stance, people fail to overlook the fact that until now he has lived up to ALL his promises in KP. I guess you guys want to choose what to listen and what not to listen, eh?
@The Author
Well done! Your loyalty to your leader stands proven without any reasonable doubt.
Now go looking seriously for all the wisdom and foresightedness your leader badly needs to become the LEADER this blighted land-of-the-pure, already on its death-bed, badly needs. And, look everywhere for whatever might help, both East and West; well beyond India and Turkey, and not anywhere nearby. Then convince your leader.
Best of Luck!
A worth read article.
"When the PTI chairman says that the militants are our own people, he is simply narrating a fact as both the leadership and the rank and file of militant groups are Pakistanis, who have taken up arms against the state. They are a mix of all ethnic and linguistic groups of Pakistan. Narration of facts should not enrage Imran bashers, "
Agreed... How does this help the relatives of the innocents killed by these 'our people'? How does this help in resolving this problem? Stating and acknowledging facts is the first step, second step is to actually resolve the issue at hand - something which your leader is not moving to. Let's assume your leader is right. Let's assume a scenario wherein the Talibans in a sudden surge of humanity, lay down their weapons, during the negotiations, but ask for amnesty for their black deeds in return.... What plan does your leader have for those surrendered? Surely they need to be brought to justice for their killings - Does he have the character and strength to say so? At the worst he's a closet Taliban, at the best he seems to be our Gandhi, who resorted to lofty idealism, ignored pragmatism and landed the subcontinent in a big mess, antagonizing everybody in return. The later are more dangerous, due to their emotional & muddled thinking.
" Who was Imran Khan" would have been a better headline. A well crafted obituary.
Desi Gora IK can do no wrong and never did. While his kids live in elite English palace he want our kids to live under TTP and Taliban rule. Not only did TTP endorse and supported PTI/IK in May elections they also chose him to best represent them.
Since when did this ultra conservative clean shaved Mulla become a liberal? Not everyone in the country suffers from old age dementia.
Imran Khan has become a problem in Pakistan polity, for his friends and foes and is no longer a solution for the country's woes. Bye Bye Imran, you should have stuck to sports.
Rex Minor
Once sleeping lion (army) will roar rats dancing on its top will hide in their holes-radio will be silent.You will see IK will be the first to jump on army wagon going all after apany hi log.He has no role in future politics of Pakistan-Mark my words.
This is an irony again for the people of pakistan. imran khan cameout with the new agenda being a politician to serve pakistani nation with the only aim to become the prime minister and he has been striving hard to achieve this goal. if we see his political history from last decade he first stood up with general parvez musharraf only to get a chance to become PM. then he was trying to stand up amongst be nazeer bhutto and nawaz shareef but they both used him and nawaz shareef and benazir did NRO and he saw no way then he left them then he joined jamat e islami only to fulfill his desire to become PM, even though he became hostiled in university of punjab and eveyone knows the jamat e islami has power in university of punjab. he always says there should be dialogue with taliban for the sake of peace in pakistan and that was the time for imran khan to show his spirit to serve his nation but he ran aways from this dialogu because he has no vision. he is confused person as he used to say about sheikh rasheed that i cant even think to appoint sheikh rasheed as my peon and now imran khan is standing with sheikh rasheed not to serve the nation just to rule the nation. imran khan is not the leader nor politician he is just like catalyst people use him and he let them use with the only hope to become PM of pakistan
For PTI, a cause bigger than peace seems to have emerged. It is the cause of proving Imran Khan right, for which anything can be rightly or wrongly justified. There are unfair critics of Imran khan but let's not make him an angel or saint. He does have his problems and there is no harm in pointing them out. Since he controls a significant proportion of narrative that will decide the future of Pakistan, such criticism is not only justified, it is alos necessary.
Funny how Imran is now being defended for his failures and blunders. Imran is now having a good taste of politics. It was always easy for him to sit outside the parliament and criticize. Not anymore i guess.
I'v barely seen a politician failed so miserably quick as IK has. So much for NayaPakistan or whatever false hopes he tried to feed the people.