The idea for this column stems from an unfortunate incident that I recently witnessed. The 25-year-old nephew of a friend of mine was exceedingly rude to his uncle’s wife in front of their whole family. His stance was that the age difference between the two was too little for him to treat her with any deference.
I understand and believe that respect is earned, but I also know that in South Asian cultures, relationships take precedence over age. When I grew up, everyone’s parents (including mine) were adamant about certain basic things. We had to say salaam to our elders and Khuda hafiz. If a mistake was made, an immediate apology was expected. If an elder did anything nice or gave a gift, a thank you note or a verbal acknowledgement was mandatory. If someone older than us walked into the room, we had to offer our seat.
I was discussing this issue with a friend and he related his own story to me. His daughter was having an argument with her mother. As soon as he heard his daughter raise her voice, he asked her to come to his room. He asked her whether she had raised her voice at her mother. His daughter tried to give him an explanation but he refused to listen. Once she admitted to raising her voice, he told her that if this was the education she was getting, then there was no need to attend school. She wasn’t allowed to go to school for three days until she begged to be forgiven. She was in ninth grade at the time. To date, she hasn’t raised her voice in front of her mother. She is now almost 24 years old.
Tough love is one of the hardest things to do because it means becoming the ‘bad guy’. But then, what else does one do? As a teenager, I hated my parent’s insistence on respecting my elders. Today, I am grateful to them for teaching me how to conduct myself.
We certainly can’t stop globalisation or stop our children from watching television. But does modern society really mean a valueless society?
I think part of the answer can be found in the saying, “it takes a village to raise a child”. As a child, I was brought up not only by my parents, but my grandparents, my parents’ siblings and even the servants in our house.
The children of today’s elite do not grow up surrounded in the same way. Instead, they live atomised lives, in which many of their most important relationships are not conducted face to face but via phones, televisions and computers. Quite often, they navigate these worlds without a guide by their side. And the end result is that some of them get lost.
Published in The Express Tribune, February 3rd, 2014.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (24)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
While respecting elders is a good thing, parents will be doing a disservice if they don't encourage the children to think logically instead of forcing them to believe and accept as the absolute truth on whatever the elders tell them. This is one reason why kids from eastern culture, especially Muslims, grow up not being competent in critical thinking, creativity and logical analysis.
I beg to differ. Obedience commanded out of children through manipulation, blackmail and fear shouldn't be mistaken for 'respect'. Which family values is everyone talking about? All I remember since I was born is either one of my parents ordering me to unthinkingly agree with whatever my grandparents had to say or ask me to do. Refusal was not a consideration because I knew I would be punished so it is easier to just go along. That doesn't mean children are respecting their 'elders', they just don't have a choice and this is not healthy behavior for society in general, anyway. It turns grandparents (and later parents) into unreasonable tyrants, holding finances and emotional blackmailing over their kids' heads to coerce them into doing whatever is required from them. This lack of individualism and respect for rights (yes, even children have a right to their dignity and privacy) is the reason why Pakistani society is so distorted today. It isn't because of technology, certainly not because of 'copying' the 'West', whatever that even means. Children in Western countries respect elders, same as everywhere. Don't believe or copy everything you see in Hollywood movies. That isn't the 'West'.
While I appreciate the topic, and agree with the author's concerns...isn't this the same Juggun Kazim that parades around as a model in attire that is characteristically at odds with traditionally Pakistani values? The factors contributing to the decline of Pakistani culture and values are myriad, and we can't blame a handful when it's clear they're all responsible collectively.
The article took me back to my childhood. Those were the days :)
If you truly believed in 'our family values', you would be sitting home rather than all around on TV and everywhere else but HOME! Stop being hypocritical and do what you say.
The author is nostalgic about a golden era when elders were respected...
The so-called golden era of joint families and respect for elders etc was built upon the silent oppression of the women of the family other than the mother or wife of the principal bread winner. It was not a golden era - it was a time when women had no say over finances or their own lives.
Today women are beginning to question this conspiracy of society to oppress them and in the process the elders are being told to fend for themselves - because while women are being empowered, the man continues to pretend nothing has changed.
These are good times - nothing to feel nostalgic about - it is time the man also does some heavy lifting around the house.
Many prayers for Juggan dear!Nice column for our great values!Stay blessed
With all due respect it is the children of the corrupt who enjoy benefits of technology and life in an affluent and liberal atmosphere. They are the ones seen misbehaving in public and I am sure privately as well. The atmosphere in less affluent homes is one of general servility, publicly as well as in their private lives. Go and see the poor and they will not be behaving like the examples you have cited above.
Family systems have collapsed everywhere, it has nothing to do with Pakistan. Today elders do not lead by example so are unable to command the respect they did earlier. When value systems break down, age becomes irrelevant to relationships. When the older generation can set an good example and practice what they preach, chances of success will be brighter.
One the greatest failures of our culture and why it remains stuck in past is because we value obedience above all. This be quiet, do not question, do not break with tradition ethos may seem like a wonderful value but its result is a society that cannot evolve socially, economically and politically.
If family values include close families which include growing up in obeying without questions what the elders are saying, then I prefer western values where children can ask awkward questions and disagree with elders. That makes them more mature and independent. In the west, if sons and daughters see their parents after they have left home, it is because they love them and not because society does not accept anything else from them.
So you think it's okay for children to listen to whatever garbage their parents are saying and just agree with it? I agree with you that yelling at your elders is not probably the best way to deal with something, but I think taking whatever you elders are saying lying down is probably what resulted in the state of our country as it is today. I think preventing your children from questioning you or even arguing with you is making them ridiculous robots of use to no one, especially not the society.
You do have the knack for choosing topics that forces one to ponder and reflect on oneself. One could blame this shift in behaviour on technology but that would be the easy and lazy way out. Instilling values into the young is a full fledged process that is part of parenting and the very important process of observing and monitoring behaviour right from birth. I, by nature am a cynic and I see this as part of a bigger issue, that of a crumbling state resulting in a breakdown of values, which directly effects and moulds the society we live in.
not just the children of the elite,most people i know pick and choose upon whose phone call to attend,whose text to reply.thus societal contexts have changed,replying to a sms is like replying to a greeting back in the days.These little things tell where does one lie in a persons life.everyone is shouting at their parents these days,but what if the child isnt willing to listen.what if the child champions himself for running the house.the audacity of reason,albeit stupid reason' provided to todays youth by what you call 'globalization' is immense.
The Eastern Culture has always been known to treat elders with respect. Their age, signifies experience. And wisdom. Therefore, respect and dignity are their due. However as the author noted, Globalization, and perhaps, "Aping" of certain Western Cultural traits is definitely eroding values.... In the West, older citizens are simply discarded,...in an undignified manner.