Musharraf’s trial

Whatever became of his famous rallying cry: Pakistan first?


Editorial January 25, 2014
Whatever became of his famous rallying cry: Pakistan first? PHOTO: REUTERS

The treason trial of former army chief General (retd) Pervez Musharraf appears to have entered a crucial phase with the presentation of his medical report on January 24. The much-awaited report by a three-member panel of doctors associated with the Armed Forces Institute of Cardiology (AFIC) describes his illness as ‘serious and unpredictable’. Cynics must have permitted themselves a smile at this conclusion, as this appeared to be opening the exit door for the general, who since the past many days seemed to be itching to leave the country on the pretext of medical treatment. What provoked howls of derision from the public prosecutor was a clear indication that General (retd) Musharraf was unwilling to get his treatment done at home. His unwillingness stems not so much from his lack of faith in the capability of local doctors as from his doubts about the right equipment available locally.

Doctors say that a coronary angiogram is required urgently to ascertain the need for more medical procedures. However, the report adds that General (retd) Musharraf wants to go abroad as ‘he has reserved his right’ to avail a ‘medical facility of his choice’. Predictably, the public prosecutor bristled at the findings of the report and demanded formation of an independent medical board comprising the country’s top five cardiologists, which should then file a separate report. Jeering at the demand of the principal accused in the case, prosecutor Akram Sheikh said if General (retd) Musharraf is allowed to leave the country to be treated at a hospital of his choice, all prisoners suffering from similar diseases must be given the equal right to leave the country as well. Without taking a partisan position on this issue, we cannot but see a point in Mr Sheikh’s line of reasoning. Given General (retd) Musharraf’s own past declaration that he would fight all charges against him in the court of law, it is in the interest of his own prestige that he must not be seen to be running off from court proceedings. Pakistan’s leading hospitals, including AFIC, are reputed for their best treatment facilities for heart patients. There is hardly a reason for General (retd) Musharraf not to trust their doctors or their facilities. After all, whatever became of his famous rallying cry: Pakistan first?

Published in The Express Tribune, January 26th, 2014.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.

COMMENTS (20)

Assad | 10 years ago | Reply @Nida Alvi: It matters not how he left the court the first time around, he has gone to the courts multiple times already and some times on charges that any fair government or judicial bench would disregard. So your silly argument that he is afraid to show up in the court is nonsense.
I am surprised to see so many pseudo-intellectuals still lamenting for Musharraf
So am I to take it that you are the one and only "full fledged intellectual" around here which would make the comments of us lesser beings not worthy of being shared? Grow up! That coward sitting in the PM's office ran away from the country at the first chance he had before the case against him for conspiring the send off a plane carrying the Army Chief to India was even initiated. Where was his courage then? The other chap who just sat in the Presidency in the PPP government sent over a 100 medical notices to the courts just to make sure that he did not have to appear in the court. Or for that matter, where is the courage with the conjurer of tsunamis when it comes to condemning the brutality of the Taliban? So what silly courage are you talking about in this land of hypocrisy and opportunism? The type which would lead Musharraf to show up in front of the one sided judicial tribunal so they can pass a vindictive judgement on him at the behest of their political masters? So who shows courage in this land of ours? You certainly aren't given the fact that you see that this trial is anything but justice yet can't get yourself to speak the truth given your own biases against Musharraf. ET, please publish my comments too as I see you giving preferential treatment to certain folks with certain views. Not fair sirs!
Rex Minor | 10 years ago | Reply A very well written editorial on the dilemma which the country is facing on account of the trial of a General, the first in its history. Let me try to bring some clarity on the Generals complaints. The medical report sees the need for a diagnostic of the problem which Parvez Musharaf condition indicate, it does not propose any treatment for the patient. In any case, it would seem that both the accused and the Government were not prepared for the trial. The events of the past several weeks appear to indicate that the new elected Government of Nawaz Sharif has once again blew up the chance of reinforcing the democracy though a dialogue with the people of the country and not follow the military ideology of using force. The complete military rule is knoking on the door. Rex Minor
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ