Doctors alone face music after botched surgeries

Qaiser Zulfiqar April 14, 2010

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan lacks the kind of medical defence unions who work for the legal, financial and social protection of doctors in Europe. This instills a sense of insecurity among medical practitioners.

“The principal job of a doctor is to help save human life, but he sometimes fails in the mission and no-one comes forward to lend him support if the situation turns awkward,” says Dr Ahraf Khan, a GP, while talking to The Express Tribune.

“The Pakistan Medical Association (PMA) is an organization which notionally works for the welfare and protection of doctors, but in practice does nothing for their safeguard,” asserts the doctor. He says medical defence unions have active presence in Europe but not in Pakistan.

The only body that comes closest to such a model is PMA but its work is at best symbolic, he adds. “It’s not necessary that a doctor would always conduct successful surgeries. In some cases a patient also expires due to his negligence but this negligence would never be intentional but the aggrieved family sues the doctor,” Ashraf says.

Medical practitioners get no legal support from their associations

In Europe organisations such as medical defence union provide free legal help to medical practitioners but in Pakistan doctors’ bodies leave their members to fend for themselves. Moreover, hospitals lack modern facilities and go without safety procedures in place. This means that when treating serious patients they are liable to contract the ailment but no support comes their way, he says.

Another Islamabad doctor says that in Europe doctors are fully covered through a medical malpractice system which means that in case of human loss the insurance company pays the penalty. No such system exists in Pakistan.

He said the PMA is only a doctors’ representative organisation but “has been hijacked by senior doctors who never work for their junior colleagues.” Although its standard operating procedures (SOPs) stipulate working for the welfare of doctors, this in reality is not the case, the doctor asserts.


Dr. Altaf ul Hassan | 12 years ago | Reply Thanks are due to Mr. Qaiser Zulfiqar to point out to an important issue the medical professionals are facing in our beloved country but this is just the tip of ice berg exposed so far as their problems are concerned.Doctors here are working tirelessly to handle the patients round the clock in over-crowded emergency wards but in return are treated thanklessly on a meager amount of salary insuffucient to make their both ends meet.It is surprising that when judiciary,police,excise and taxation departent and many other departments are being treated on special pay packages,doctors are ignored altogether and they are working on a salary which may not be compared even with gunmen or peons working in the banks.There is a need to treat the doctors on humanitarian grounds if they are also considered human being who have to cater their families and alos have genuine needs of bread and butter.It is reasonable that they may also be offered special pay packages in the best of public interest.
Mustafa Maharvi | 12 years ago | Reply i'm sure PMA is seriously thinking to protect Doctors from such principal threat. Outstanding contribution from Qaiser Zulfiqar.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ


Most Read