Right in the middle of meeting upon meeting of the ‘Core Committee’ of the PTI modelled on God only knows what: the Core Committee of the PPP? (and look where that Core Committee landed the party!), arrived friend Charles Timothy ‘Chuck’ Hagel, defence secretary of the United States of America, who served for 12 years in the US Senate and was selected by President Obama to be in his cabinet.
Hagel has served in the US Army in Vietnam where he was twice wounded and was twice awarded the Purple Heart, and later as a professor at the Edmund A Walsh School of Foreign Service at Georgetown University, chairman of the Atlantic Council, and co-chairman of the President’s Intelligence Advisory Board. (Thank you, Wikipedia).
A man you would agree, who has considerable knowledge of the axis of the planet and how the earth turns upon it, and knows exactly which way the poles lie. A man, you would agree, not to be trifled with, most particularly because he heads the mightiest military in the whole wide world. A military that belongs to a country that is headed by a highly intelligent man under whose careful guidance that country is reaching out to even those nations the mere mention of which was considered taboo just a few months ago, and for decades before that.
During which time other countries made full use of the geopolitical situation and milked the Americans for all they were worth. Need I say more, except to bring to your attention the excellent article “An incoherent foreign policy” by Kaiser Bengali in Dawn of December 10, 2013, in which the good man has extrapolated that given the opening of relations between the US and Iran, the future of the region could well change to the utter detriment of our country if we don’t wake up and “smell the ralli-milli chai”.
Indeed, a spate of articles has appeared in the immediate aftermath of Hagel’s three-hour visit to Pakistan during which, uncharacteristically for the Americans, he publicly wielded a big stick made up of billions of US $s warning us in no uncertain terms of the costs our country might have to bear due to a cut-off in US aid of various kinds, most critically for our defence forces that depend almost entirely for sophisticated weapons systems and their spare parts that we hold in our inventories. To name just one: the F-16 fighter-bomber, the pride of our air force.
What he did not say was that the US also exerts great influence on what the IMF and the World Bank and the Asian Development Bank lay out in development loans and on which, let us face it, our country depends. The JI/PTI slogan is that this country can well do without monetary help so long as we do a, b, c, and x, y, and z, so to hell with the US/Nato. Good and well, as my friend and colleague Brigadier Ashraf Khan Afridi used to say 40 years ago when we served at the Infantry School, but could they wait until the US/Nato exit Afghanistan before they start doing a, b, c, and x, y, and z?
For, and I wonder what news they and their leaders read and watch, whatever I have read or seen tells me the United States and Nato are in the process of LEAVING, not entering Afghanistan! Why, then, are the JI/PTI stopping these foreign armies from leaving please? Why, indeed, can’t they have one-way traffic out of Afghanistan so we are rid of Nato the soonest? In any case, it ill-behoves the ghairatmand JI/PTI government to go on using up to US $500 million aid on various projects while it stops their goods. It should immediately stop these projects in their tracks and return the balance left over to the Americans (until they stop the drone attacks, of course!).
We are a contrary people, we know, but the contrariness being shown by the JI/PTI leadership, which is so quick to put any criticism of their acts and ‘strategies’ down to ‘hate’ for their parties, borders on utter stupidity. Childish and puerile, I’d put it down as. Would that they realise that even the lightest of sanctions applied by the Americans and their friends can pull our country back decades. And that the most powerful countries are not about to let their soldiers starve in Afghanistan no matter what action they might have to take.
Elsewhere now and to senior schoolmate Masood Hasan’s article last Sunday, December 8, in The News. Yes, our school is also located in the Wah Valley that I wrote about last week. Every weekend, (and on week-days, quietly!) we used to go for walks along the beautiful Dhamrah catching fish as we went along, and swimming whenever it took our fancy. And shooting doves for the pot with airguns and pellets that would be issued to some of us on Sundays and other holidays by the principal himself.
And what great men they were: Mr H. Catchpole; Squadron Leader N.A. Beg, and Lt Col A.W.E. Winlaw. For the interest of old boys, I was introduced to Col. Winlaw’s nephew in Gloucestershire by my chum Henry Shepherd-Cross who was going out with his daughter some years ago. I forget his name but he called all of the Winlaw family telling them how he was lunching with one of ‘Uncle Winnie’s’ pupils! I had also told him I had got six of the best from ‘Uncle Winnie’ for not learning math which news was also passed along to the mirth of all.
Published in The Express Tribune, December 13th, 2013.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (35)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
The US is not leaving Afghanistan. They are retreating from a military capacity and extending their presence to a support role, likely for over another decade.
@numbersnumbers: Dear numbers, You can look up statistics as well as I can. However, you and a couple of others appear to be happily working in synergy in order to dream up false statistics, which allow people to feel comfortable within the "STATUS QUO", or you come up with nonsense statements, which nit-pick other peoples comments, but without coming up with a serious alternative. I do not know who is feeding you, but I can guess. However, I suppose I should be grateful that you have not used low grade English phrases such as "WOW" !
@Sexton Blake: So let's see if we understand your comment, You say that of the near 50,000 Pakistanis slain by the TTP, some 28,000 of that number were insurgents!!! Just where did you ever find that fantasy? As for your "we are really not sure who killed the (Pakistani) civilians", I would bet that most Pakistanis know just WHO has been killing "Them" in terrorists attacks the past decade or so!
@Gram Massla: Dear Gram, I will not attempt to compare fighter jets, but I did read an article the other day which pointed out that the US cannot get the F35 to work properly, the F22 has severe environmental problems for the pilot, but the F16 is reasonably reliable. The only drawback with the F16 is that it requires 30 hours maintenance for every 1 hour of flying time, and is becoming somewhat ancient. Perhaps the Major can get one of his English chums to shed light on the matter?
@salman: "they are not leaving" . They can't, even if they tried. Their departure is being hindered, by no one else but IK and his pack.
@Sexton Blake: It so easy to tell, from the tone of various submissions, who lives in the drone areas and who does not. Obviously you do not
But then, neither do you so please have some sympathy for those living under the tyranny of your jihadi brethren
@Dr.M.M.Khan: Dear Dr. Khan, It so easy to tell, from the tone of various submissions, who lives in the drone areas and who does not. Obviously you do not so you can afford to show maturity, and do put-downs on those who do.live in the bombing area, and those who have sympathy for them.
I agree with the writer that USA is leaving but would like to point out it is leaving without losing-Pakistan was very helpful in letting it in and was handsomely rewarded .Now that USA wants to leave PTI is blocking it by imposing conditions. What a cheek.USA is not going to stop attacks on it's enemies where ever they may be.Drone attacks have helped Pakistan too. Pakistan cannot have two types of foreign policy---one practiced by myopic PTI and the other by the central govt .International relations are never static but dynamic..Pakistan cannot antagonise USA but can engage with it in withdrawl. Pakistan's foreign policy cannot be decided at the border by young activist but by the democratically elected Govt. of which Imran is a member. Let us show some maturity.
!
When China scrambled its jets to counter the American and Japanese challenge to its ADIZ around the contested island the jets chosen were the Russian Sukhoi-30s, not the J-17 Thunderjets. The Chinese were smart enough to realize that technologically the J-17s were no match for the advanced American jet fighters. My point? That money and technology rules the roost in today' world. Pakistan has neither. You need Western money and you need the F-16s. Period.
@Sexton Blake:
*and we are not really sure who killed the civilians.*
You mean the 'would be Martyrs' are actually liars and their claims can not be taken at face value?
Additionally, if one looks at satellite images of Iraq, Libya, Afghanistan and large portions of north-East Pakistan all one can see is bombed out rubble.
Afghanistan and Iraq I will address in a moment, let me address the other two first.
A. Do tell me who attacked Libya and when? Or you believe that the Libyans should not have followed the Arab Spring?
B. And NORTH EAST Pakistan is also known as Azad Kashmir and GB , who bombed these areas and when.? May be you meant North-West which is under occupation of armed militia from Afghanistan a.k.a. the Haqqani horde.
C. In Afghanistan, as you know the freedom fighters and the Martyrs started Martyring each other once the Godless Russians departed in 1989. And this Martyrdom game continued right up to 2001. By then the only things left standing in Afghanistan were the Bamyan Budhas. Do you want to hear that story too?
D. And in Iraq we did see the oppressed majority coming out on the streets and rejoicing the fall of a dictator. Didn't we?
csmann: Observer: unbelievable: You apparently appear to take a delight in using faulty statistics when it suits you, and ignore the really big numbers, which have been established by eminent sources such as John Hopkins University, who use widely accepted, peer reviewed, scientific methodology. The 50,000 figure which csmann constantly brings up is correct, but he forgets to mention that 28,000 of those fatalities are insurgents and 6,000 military, and we are not really sure who killed the civilians. The total figure for Iraq/Afghanistan is 919,967 fatalities and 1,690,903 injured, and the injuries are not foot blisters. Additionally, if one looks at satellite images of Iraq, Libya, Afghanistan and large portions of north-East Pakistan all one can see is bombed out rubble. If ET prints the above the figures given may be of some interest to you, but I doubt it. You cannot handle the truth.
From what I understand America had some 35 thousand troops many years ago. Then they realised that what was needed was a ' surge ', so that added about another 35 thousand. Now they will draw down to a figure below the original 35 but still keep a very visible and effective presence in the region..........so no, they are not leaving. On Imran Khan stand, it looks like he is playing more for the local audience's benefit than anything else.
Kamran Sahib, you are doing good. Truth must be told regardless of what the idiots of PTI or anyone else believe and follow. Pakistan is not just their or their old-man (with learning disability), it belongs to us all and we must do all to prevent damages that might cause its destruction. This our Pakistan is just one and only country that we the masses have and not like most of these PTIans who have multiple visas if not foreign passports of countries they can run to, this holds for most of their leadership. Hammer this fact in the numb skulls of these trolls and do it as long as it takes to sink in.
The ball is in the federal governments court. It is time they took action (which is unlikely because apart from trying to fire Nadra chief have they really done anything?) and resolved this situation with the long term interests of the country in mind; and stopping the blockade and allowing drone strikes to continue is not in the best interests of the country.
And even if the US/Nato was leaving in 2014 in entirety, it doesnt mean you do not use what little leverage you have left to redeem your dignity.
The extreme right (Yes PTI is extreme right, lets face it) gets blinded in emotional euphuria and forget about our long term interests. Just a reality check for PTI people, being ghairatmand is directly propotional to being economically independent not the other way around. As far as we know huge part of KPK budget comes from USAID, so it doesnot suit them to point finger at the hand that feed them.
This is the analysis of a retired Major.
@Sohaib Irshad: So PTI/JI is blocking the return route because they don't want the American/NATO presence to be reduced?!! Funny rationale. Frankly, PTI/JI have no rationale for blocking the route (as is in most cases) but are only following a populist agenda. They should hope that people of KPK don't boot them out next elections as they did with MMA and ANP. Despite all the sick 'Pathan' jokes that go around the country, I have a lot of respect for KPK for booting out non-performers throughout the democratic history of Pakistan, unlike Sindh (humph!) and Punjab - which still vote in the same thrives and robbers every time, under different party names.
Stand up with dignity. People have gone used to with the everyday insult to the extent that now it is not even taken as insult.
Entering from karachi, and direction being towards Afghanistan, they are blocked. Strange way to leave. Even a lay man knows that for leaving you need to enter peshawar and your direction will be south.
Naya Pakistan by road masters!!....three wickets with a ball.Journey through dharnas..in Ninety Days...tsunami without water..end of corruption in no time..conversion of lota into matka with blink of eye. and much much more.To see all that join Lucky Insafi circus at GT road.
@Sexton Blake: How about a tear or two for those men,women and children who are no longer in this world due to Islamists bombing and beheading in the name of religion.
@Sexton Blake:
he is obviously unaware of all the innocent men,women and children who are no longer with us as a result of unnecessary US/NATO bombing attacks.
And you are obviously unaware that 40,000 innocent Pakistanis, men, women and Children are no longer with is because of 'strategic assets' in search of 'strategic depth'.
But then why lament 40,000 when you can do it louder for 869.
Nice read. Had to be. I also studied with Mr. Catchpole in 1965 at Abbottabad Public School. Still remember measuring the height of the mountain facing our school with him. That said, PTI has presented some tactical obstructions to NATO supply that many in Pakistan reasonably fear will have terrible consequences. But the problem is, no political party in parliament has presented a political strategy for defeating the Pakistani Taliban. That includes the PPP, PMLN, and the ANP. PTI says drones are terrible, others say they agree. But the drones are merely a weapon. A strategy to tackle the TTP has to be about more than drones. The PTI claims halt to drone strikes will lead to a ceasefire with the TTP. Then what? What will the government of Pakistan and the TTP talk about? What if anything will the government put on the table. No government can realistically offer anything except that the TTP demobilize and send their fighters to their homes. All our parliamentary parties need to be frank about this. None of them are. They need to formulate a political strategy to defeat the TTP, and mobilize the public to achieve its objectives.
Chuck Hegel is someone we should be able to do business with. He's a brave guy who stood up to Israel's pressure to impose a policy veto on the US. If Pakistanis come-up with their own strategy to defeat the TTP, he's likely to back it.
I would have thought that the retired major would take his fishing gear and look for a quite place where he can fish and read Hegel's philosophy and let those worry about the present who have the will to resist the enemy and seek peace for their people and to lead them to success. The Nation which violates your country's sovereignty and drones your citizens and their families including children are not your friends nor different than the colonialists who deployed westland wapitis to control the tribal terrain in 1939. History reading is good but only if one can draw some useful lessons from it. .
Rex Minor
Are the Americans leaving!!The last I read, they were doing a deal with Karzai, Afghan Jirga to remain indefinitely...
We may have gained independence more than 60 years ago, but out thinking is still enslaved to Western dictat. As aptly shown above my Mr. Shafi. Good reminder of how our leaders think. Meanwhile, the same PTI is bringing some very western style change in KPK, 'war on corruption'. .
A news anchor posted this on twitter:
"We tried to bribe Patwaris in diff areas in KPK but they refused saying - minister nahi bach sakte, hum kya bachenge" .
Unfortunately, the only thing western our elite want to adopt is their handbags.
@Sexton Blake: ] I guess 50,000 Pakistani citizens and 5,000 soldiers killed are "necessary" attacks by "noble' Taliban and Al-Qaida.Volumes have been written about their murderous agenda against Pakistan and the world.Most Pakistanis have to shed tears of blood due to their daily mayhem.And they don't even spare Polio-workers,the persons who are trying to protect kids from a crippling disease.
ahhhhhhhhhhh Mr Kamran Shafi,,, You confuse us again
Reading Kamran Ahafi's article about how badly the noble Americans were being treated by Pakistan nearly brought a tear to my eye, but only for an instant. I could write volumes refuting what he said, but would merely point out that he is obviously unaware of all the innocent men,women and children who are no longer with us as a result of unnecessary US/NATO bombing attacks.
Good to see some old fashion,likeable reminiscence done by the author. Pleasing to read. [ Beside the doom and gloom mantra and dance of the seven veils by JI/PTI et al ]
they are not leaving
Dear Sir Thank you for your weekly opinion in ET.We, your regular readers would appreciate a few lines written by your hand on the Late former President Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela.Kindly enlighten us as to how "Forgiveness' can make Pakistan the paradise it was when you were a youngster. Kind regards and thank you Sir.
Major Sahb, before writing this piece, you could have searched and READ a little about WHATS happening in Afghanistan. Anyways just FYI
"US Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel has said he has received assurances during a visit to Kabul that a long-delayed deal allowing US troops to stay in Afghanistan after 2014 will be signed "in a timely manner".
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/afghanistan/10502799/Deal-for-US-troops-to-stay-in-Afghanistan-will-be-signed-soon.html
The total withdrawl is not YET decided. Perhaps you should re-publish this article which you wrote with so much zeal after US executes its "Zero Option"
With Warm Regards,
A PTI Troll :-) (as you would say)
>> For, and I wonder what news they and their leaders read and watch, whatever I have read or seen tells me the United States and Nato are in the process of LEAVING, not entering Afghanistan!
Yes, one has to wonder what you read and where. US is planning to stay in Afghanistan till 2024 as per the status of forces being currently negotiated between them and Karazi. Yes, their ground forces will be reduce but they will maintain heavy presence in their 8 or 9 huge bases all over Afghanistan. They will be in control of Afghanistan's air space fully and provide air support to Afghan forces. They will maintain drone capability for all that period and may be beyond. So your suggesting that they are leaving is really a very superficial reading of the situation.