Is being a doctor just a status symbol? And why would anyone put in all this money, work, time and resource if they weren't planning to see it through in the practical world?
It turns out that female medical students get very good rishtas as soon as they complete their residencies and then most choose to settle down. Lady doctors make great bahu candidates. But, part of the marriage requirement is that the girl will not work after she marries. So she must sound great on paper but ultimately stay home, produce children and be a homemaker.
Now, why would a mother in law look for a girl who is highly qualified and then not allow her to work? Why would a man marry a doctor and then ask her to stay at home? And most importantly, why would a woman sit at home after investing so much in a career?
Mothers-in-law like to be able to say that their daughter-in-law is highly educated and lady doctors certainly qualify on that ground. But, mothers-in-law also want their sons and, ultimately, grandchildren, to be taken care of by the bahu. Stay home, cook food, clean the house, oversee the staff, teach the children and have no opinions — these are still the traditional demands which daughters-in-law have to face.
Every man in this society wants a trophy. Obviously, she must be good- looking and from a good family, but education is crucial. An educated woman makes a good wife and a good mother. But dinner must still be ready when he comes home and his wife must be at his beck and call. Obviously, this is not possible if the wife is working long hours at a hospital or in a clinic. So the wife ‘chooses’ not to work. I looked up the definition of ‘trophy wife’. One dictionary said it was: “a young, attractive wife regarded as a status symbol for a man.” Interesting.
For me, the last question is the most important. Becoming a doctor is a difficult and stressful educational experience for any one, male or female. You have to get good grades and put in long hours of study. Why give all that up?
When a girl finally finishes medical school and her residency, she is normally about 25 or 26 years old. This is past the marriageable age for most families in Pakistan. But for a lady doctor it is the perfect time to marry. Many girls get very good proposals and they are conflicted about whether to work or to settle down. For some strange reason both don’t seem like a real possibility. They initially resist and then finally give in to marriage, quite often out of the fear of dying an old maid, in the process killing all their dreams and aspirations.
There is so much wasted talent in this country. Over 51 per cent of the population of this country is women and most of them are either forced or convinced to stay home and raise families.
In Western societies, careers and family happen simultaneously. In some households, if the wife’s income is more than the husbands, then the husband stays at home with the kids while the wife works. In Pakistan, many times a man will slog away at a job he hates and that barely covers the costs of running the home, while a qualified doctor or engineer sits at home twiddling her thumbs. What a tragedy!
Pakistan has a shortage of qualified people. We need more doctors, more engineers, more teachers, more scientists – more of everything. What we don’t need are more stay-at-home mothers. And, it’s high time we learnt this — especially us women.
Published in The Express Tribune, November 11th, 2013.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (57)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
mam because man is insecure and weak he won't let his wife to go away work long hours and earn without a dignity and in our society man take care of the household not women i may sound a conservative but this is pakistan we have some values.get real
This lady doctor bashing is getting way too old now. Coming from a class of graduates where 75% women are still working n serving Pakistan whereas 50% of the male doctors did migrate to canada uk and the USA you can't blame it only on the lady doctor who left medicine albeit only for a short while. Medical Graduates from Harvard are leaving medicine to raise families because only now people are realizing how important early years are for the children that u chose to have yourself. Apart from that if a woman who completes her masters in finance or business or education chooses to leave her field is equally at fault. Why not stop women from studying at all because they will waste boys seats in schools as well.
@Rex Minor I have nothing against cleaning women in the house.
However, the this article has deep undertones of the stereotypical western image of our country where women are forced to stay home.
I quote from this article: "Over 51 per cent of the population of this country is women and most of them are either forced or convinced to stay home and raise families."
The author has no statistics to back any of her claims. The 75% that she uses is no verified statistic...just an observation of some individuals. Do not confuse opinions for facts.
I used the cleaning lady example not degrade them, but to highlight that there are a lot of working women in our country. There is probably 1 working in every house(the cleaning lady).
That said, it is the author who is degrading educated women by calling them 'trophy wives'.
I repeat, this article has no verified stat and only uses stereotypical notions and biased opinions to compare us with 'western societies' which are depicted as the ideal.
@The Truth: Have you anything against the cleaning women in a house? The message in the article that I read is not to sacrifise the professional education and learning experience in favour of being married in a rich family!
Rex Minor
People will be sheep.
Everyone likes to jump on the bandwagon.
In Pakistan, the bandwagon is 'women are not encouraged to work by society' is pretty high on the list.
First of all, it is very derogatory to call these women 'Trophy wives'. In doing so, the writer is degrading these women with her own words.
Secondly, 'Trophy wives' exist even in the west. That is where the term was coined. Maybe someone should lecture them about the merits of working women.
Thirdly, these women earned their seats and paid for their education. They did not steal their education from anyone. Now if they are in a situation where they can live comfortably without working, who is to blame them? What right does anyone have to point fingers at others' decisions?
Lastly, I think a reality check is in order. This phenomenon is present only among the middle and upper class of our society. The vast majority of our society is uneducated. And a vast majority of our uneducated women are forced to work due to bad economic conditions. I can bet my house on the fact that the very writer of this article has 'women' employees at her home doing the cleaning.
We must not get entangled in these bandwagons. The main problem is lack of education in our society as a whole.
In the 2nd last para the writer mentions that in the west husbands stay at home to look after kids if their wives earn more than them.. so the husband staying home is ok but God forbid if a woman stays home...
While the stay at home mothers are more common in middle class households, this is hardly true for the majority lower classes in at least punjab and sindh where women work in farms, or as maids, servants etc.
We need to make a law about this, any student who wouldnt go for professional practise must return the amount of subsidy that was spent for his education.
It is a complete waste if professional seats are occupied by homemakers, that too highly subsidized seats.
@just_someone: The author has generalized but it is generally true, On the other side of the spectrum are middle class men who want educated wives who will work, share the expenses while also managing the house and kids. A woman's choice to stay at home or work is and should be entirely hers. I am not a doctor but I do not want to work after I get married. A husband who would 'want' me to work as soon as kids are of school going age would be as hypocritical as a husband who wants a doctor wife to sacrifice her ambitions and dreams to supervise servants and serve as arm candy for him. School going children also require a lot of work and so does running a house even with the assorted maids, cook, nannies, etc. If i choose to help my kids with their homework, co curricular activities, spend time with them, socialize, even yes, shop, i DO NOT consider that a crime. Nor is it a waste of my education as just bringing in money or admittedly, contributing to the economy, the only way to contribute.
@Truth detector: raising kids is not just a sole responsibility of a women as the medieval society has preached. Good, healthy and ethically strong kids are by product of efforts from both parents. Children get more wider perception to world when they interact with both parents vs following the rules set by one. There are many well bred kids in world where both parents are working.
Well...well..well..... Guys first we need to validate the figure of 75%...coz i am a doc, done my post grad as soon as i got out of med school....have a family and am practising succesfully.... I dont think this figure is correct coz about 60% of my female classmates are post grads as well working here and abroad especially US and australia.... And we r from KMC ...Peshawer...the supposedly conservative area of Pakistan.....
@Author: Now thats some dictation! If a woman wants to stay at home, it is her life and her choice. Let it be! There is no need to belittle the role of a homemaker.
However I do agree that doctors and engineers and other professionally edcuated women who have utilized government resources should think well before opting for such degrees! If they just want education for social status then there are other degrees that may serve the purpose of educating them. Please dont waste the seat of a deserving( male/ female) candidate!
@just_someone: Not so fast and rude too with your education calim. I am not sure what is your line but no one has yet been able to utilise more than an average 15 percent of human brain potential. The author has written an excellent piece describing the situation in her near and the concerns which she and many others have in her part of the world. I do not believe the author is generalising but addressing the women group who aim at studying medicine but due to their marriage in rich families prevent them from practicing their profession. This culture needs to be altered.
Rex Minor
some girls are have genes some girls have brains... life gives everyone an equal opportunity.
some girls have larger than average mammery glads and gluteal muscles other girls have to play catchup by investing in themselves via med-school and/or eng.school. Life is fair.
Also, with all due respect, if the author herself for as educated as the people she is commenting on, it would have a little more bite and not be so misguided!
As a highly educated man (think of the highest degree that exists), who is single, I can say this article is a ridiculous generalization. Somewhat of what you said is what I would like in my future wife (as would most reasonable men) but you seem to put everything in such a neat little bow and thats just messed up. For example, you keep saying us men would like hot food waiting for us all the time. I can say with some arrogance that I probably cook better than most women can and I dont want a maid, I want a wife. I can hire a maid to cook and clean for me without much trouble. Hence these things are not that important to me and probably to a lot of other men. Also, I want an educated wife but I also dont want her to waste her education and talent. I would highly encourage her to work outside of the house. I wouldnt be opposed to her being a stay at home mother for a few years (if she wants to do that) but I think she should work outside the house as soon as the kids are at a school going age. So yeah lady, first get to know what men want and then write an article because you made a fool of yourself in front of a lot of people with the baloney you wrote here.
i think that practice, after completing the medical studies of female, must be mandatory to certain period of time. e.g it might be mandatory for a lady dr to work for five years in a government hospital. This is how we can utilize the resource of Doctors. mover over we need to provide opportunities in the market for young graduates, here in newspapers we claim that we need more of everything but when this more come out of universities we become unable to provide them opportunities accordingly. So, we must consider it as well.
@Leela: Indians are famous for speaking on any topic without even checking the basic facts. Please stay away from this site as we have no use for your unsolicited advice.
@sara j: On a serious note, what address I can send my resume to?
@Insaan: @csmann:
I fully agree with the author as well as with your comments! I was describing the situation in European countries, where not everyone has the foresight when they use their options for studies and later the choice of a profession with the use of hindsight. Some unertake part time jobs and others undertake research in clinical studies or seek employment in pharma industry. Not every one is able to cope up with working with sick and prefer to be engaged with illnesses rather than the sick. Therefore, those who are well off from home and decide to give up working as a practicing doctor and decide instead to raise children instead need not be criticised. What the Government, however, could do in Pakistan is to require a minimum numbers of years clinical service from those who receive free of charge medical studies but later migrate to another country or decide to raise her own family.
Rex Minor
Medical seats, which are a limited number, do go to waste when women who study medicine do not end up practicing it. But what about the men who end up doing CSS and joining the lucrative bureaucracy ? They are equally to blame for shortage of doctors in Pakistan. Lets face it, no foreign doctor would like to come to work in Pakistan as Pakistani doctors go to UK or US to work.
@furkan awan: "working woman for a wife"
You might want to rephrase your choice of words !
Thanks Juggun, for bringing up this topic. Nicely written article.
what about women looking for rich husbands???isnt it what rishta looking has become nowadays
Hi,
Thumbs up Juggan, one of the most interesting-reality based article I have ever read. Each word is true n ultemately yet another harsh reality of our society. I personally know some girl who are doing B.A., just for BeeAaa (marry).....
Now we as a nation really need to grow up......
FYI I am working in HR dept. of multinational firm and consider myself as a proud n happy girl..!!......."marriages made in heaven not in medical colleges".....
@Truth detector: every article cannot cover every aspect. this one is about women who go to medical schools and then do not practice the thing they were trained to do. which is unfair to people who want to actually be doctors and its unfair to the country that needs doctor. raising successful happy kids is important, but is not the sole domain of the mother, fathers need to play a role too. a woman can be a doctor and also raise children, many do. being a stay at home mother IS a valid life choice. but if you make this choice you should not be wasting time and resources that are allocated to creating doctors. if you know that you will never practice, don't go to medical school. get a liberal arts education that will help you be a fully rounded human being with knowledge you can pass on to children without taking away from someone else.
Always look forward to reading you. Little Malala got shot in the head for wanting an education..........and here we have those with an education, wasting it. How does one rationalise something like this ?
I think this is a very well written article. I agree with most of the comments saying this is just one side of the story but this is also part of the reality. Other than that, I guess everyone has their own opinions and views and I think we shouldn't be so judgemental about everything. Respect other's opinions and be tolerant.
I think this is a very well written article. I agree the writer has shown just one side of the story but this is also part of the reality. Other than that, everyone has their own opinions and I guess we should not be so judgemental claiming whether it is RIGHT or WRONG. Respect everybody's opinion and be tolerant.
I fully agree with the author only thing is ... It should be vice verse too ... Cud they (girls) be bagging a "Trophy Husbands" too ???
I am sure in the Government run medical colleges the course fees are highly subsidised - basically paid for by the poor tax payer.
Any student who donot start practicing as a doctor within a year of graduation, must return the full cost of the medical degree ( could be in the range of Rs20-40 lakhs) depending on the college and facilities used.
@Leela: Pakistan is also famous for many good things accomplished by genuine degree holders,but,it seems you are one of the misinformed ones obsessed by the Taliban factor.
Monday is not my day. I would be happy to learn which moderation rules I transgressed this time?
No body denies that 75 % female doctors not working is a matter of concern,specially considering how much the government pays to educate them.But this is a double edged sword on one hand our society is not working women friendly,from gender discrimination to maternity leaves problems we have it all,so you have to consider the husbands and the mother in law perspective that whether sacrificing your family life is even worth it. Secondly how many of these 75% doctors are actually interested in work because paying for education and working are different things,when the reality of managing both working and family life hits you many of these female do prefer their family life.
Good points raised - sadly the largely misogynistic society of Pakistan can't seem to understand these issues.
I think there should be a relaxed working schedule for skilled ladies i.e maximum 15 hours per week. This way they can manage both professional and house duties easily and play an important role in country's progress.
True that it is a fact that many girls who study as medical students end up as house wives....However there are multiple reasons for that.
Many marry doctors because of the 'doctor' label, and hence do not wish to have them practice, but then why does it stop the girls from not working. For that there are a number of reasons.--one the long course fo study up to Post Grad which is tough with family that is not willing to let that happen. Secondly, if the girl chooses to stay just a bachelor MBBS, the salary given in private hospitals is meager, and not worth the job. The ratio between girls and boys in the med schools in 5:1. It is so easy to see BA, MA and even Intermediate grads to get an easy match as a doctor. Many do not understand the dynamics and the support a doctor wife who also happens to be a Mom needs from home or husbands. Of course factors mentioned above are true too.Totally agree with everything. What really disgusts me is how men and their families consider themselves to have the right to discourage or limit anyone to pursue what they really want to. Like cmon mind your own business its a womans wish whether she wants to work or not, she has a brain like yours and she should be able to decide.
@Truth detector: I'm inclined to disagree. Saying the most important job for a woman is raising kids simply reduces a woman's worth to one thing: baby machine. Becoming a parent is no doubt among the most important thing for a man or a woman, as society needs great people to raise great offsprings (and that's most certainly a two person job in today's world), but to say that is the sole most important thing doesn't sit well with me. I'm a woman. I plan to work in finance. I want to be great in my professional love and remembered as something more than just mom. I Wang my own identity as a woman. My mother is an exceptional mother and she and my father together did an excellent job in raising a happy healthy family, but she has her own identity in her work as well and I would never do her a disservice and dismiss that achievement. It's important to her and that made it important to all of us. She will always be a mother AND a great artist, just as my father will always be a father and a great engineer. I would never take the rest of their identity away from them by claiming that their single most important reason for existing is to have babies or was to raise my sister and I. Pakistanis often expect too much of women and claiming their sole purpose is to have babies is akin to asking them to not have a separate identity. My mother may be a mother, but she's also a woman in her own right.
the article is just one side of the coin! the side the author wants to see..
The culture has a great impact on many things and the security conditions of the country the women of the west may so libreal but even after being one the developed nations of the world they are the most unprotected .they raped and much unhappier than other eastern women
this is very important in our culture that women get the protection but special jobs can be created for wormen in a protected environment so that they work easily home base jobs much be encouraged to get skill of women in to the field
technology so enabled to make women work at home some jobs must be fixed for women like call centersetc
ETBLOGS1987
This is interesting information. The fact that over 50% of the medical seats go to women and 75% of them never practice for a day means that 37.5% of the seats go totally waster. Apart from the human angle that the author addressed, I think there is a societal angle also in a country which - like India is short of Doctors. Are these subsidised seats funded by taxpayer money or private sector seats where at least there is no loss to the exchequer?
By the way in an overall well written article, I found the sweeping statement that 'all men want a trophy wife' a little excessive.
@Rex Minor: "One must not forget that the practicing medical doctors spend the rest of the working life with sick people which for some could become unbearable. Therefore these individuals have the opportunity after marriage to give up the profession in favour of the family life with children."
It is sad story that Pakistani women only realize that they will be working with sick people (which COULD become unbearable) and they will have a family life only after completing their MD and getting married.
@Rex Minor: Right.But 75% not practicing after educations is a sheer waste of meagre national resources. Many a deserving people's dreams of becoming doctors must have been shattered to give these seats to women who won't practice.
Juggan, you consistently advocate the women to work but you fail to shed light on the implications of it on the upbringing of the children. I am sure you feel that a mother coming back at six in the evening exhausted by the day's work is just the same as a house-wife, however; the children in the West and their lack of respect and insolence is alarming. The children cannot be left at the expense of "massis" that we hire at negligible wage.I don't see why a wife should put up with the problems of work if her husband is maintaining a reasonable level of lifestyle.
Pakistan is famous for people getting fake degrees. So, these women can get one to satisfy thier mother-in-law and husband. Anyway with more taliban sympathizers, these women will be staying home or in a burkha at all times.
the comma needs to be adjusted here.
A very well written thoughts of a would be medical doctor and the authors concerns. Let me add some points which are misse out:
1). medical studies are unertaken not for education but a predetermined profession.
2) One must not forget that the practicing medical doctors spend the rest of the working life with sick people which for some could become unbearable. Therefore these individuals have the opportunity after marriage to give up the profession in favour of the family life with children.
Rex Minor.
While I am all for women excelling in their professional lives but I do believe that out of all jobs, the single most important one is women raising successful, happy & healthy kids that will be more beneficial to society. This article did not cover that aspect.
@Khattak: check your privilege
Generalisations and stereotypes in overdrive!
"Every man in this society wants a trophy."
Wow, some generalization. How do you feel if someone says "Every woman in this society wants to sell herself to a guy with money"? Reality bites eh?
And if you really are so concerned that 75% of qualified female doctors never work, why don't you convince some of them to drop out of medical colleges and let someone serious (whether male or female) about their career use their seat instead, while they move off to a "finishing school" or home economics or something else that is aligned to their real interest in life i.e. bagging a rich husband and becoming a housewife.
I believe that these days in such an era only working woman can become a good wife !