While Bollywood films are regularly aired on television by cable operators merely days after their cinema releases, the practice of airing Pakistani films on cable is not as popular. So, it came as a shock when the country’s most-hyped film Main Hoon Shahid Afridi (MHSA) was leaked online by the seventh week of its release while it was still running in cinemas.
“Luckily, my film had completed its run so the loss was minimal,” says Humayun Saeed, producer and lead actor of MHSA. “But I think this has been a learning experience,” he adds. Saeed suspects that the DVD screener was linked to the editing studio run by Azam Khan, who had a copy of the movie. The latter had passed away leaving the doors open for someone to possibly leak the film for a small amount of money.
Saeed says that he filed a case with the FIA (which deals with cyber crimes) and Pemra but the response has been negligible. “I really don’t know what to do. I guess I can only ask the operators and people to think for the country on a whole,” says Saeed. “When I make my second film, I will check with the distributor and see how we can fill these gaps and be more careful,” he claims.
With the government ignoring an issue that threatens an industry on the brink of revival, film-makers have decided to become proactive. Ishq Khuda maker Shehzad Rafique has approached Saeed to coordinate a meeting with DG Pemra over future piracy issues.
Legal ambiguities
Owner of Mandviwalla Entertainment, Nadeem Mandviwalla says that piracy and censorship are intertwined. He feels the two reflect an overall hypocrisy towards cinema in the country in that while cinema censorship has been scrutinised, piracy remains unresolved. He highlights that cinema is not the only market for films, with other sources such as DVD, television, satellite and mobile phones also available. These are platforms where piracy and illegal content thrive, but seem to escape the law conveniently. “Imagine how disappointed someone like Saeed would be after he had spent a couple of years putting in so much work into his film? This trend will only discourage a market from developing,” asserts Mandviwalla. Clearly, the only place where regulation has become strict is in the censor board, which mainly controls cinema content.
Along with the government’s lack of interest in tackling piracy, which can have damaging effects on an industry that is still in its revival stage, film-makers also feel that the existing legal framework is very limited when it comes to piracy issues.
Imran Kazmi, whose film Siyaah was released on a smaller scale, says that there is little trust in the authorities to guarantee security of films. He adds that it should be ensured that at least in bigger cities like Karachi, Lahore, Rawalpindi and Islamabad, privacy laws are strictly enforced.
“We are basically told to just go to ‘authorities’. We are not sure who [it is that is] responsible to take action. Just like in Saeed’s case, they [the government] are not bothered,” says Kazmi. “There should be a place to address these concerns. Right now, you can’t trust anyone. If you complain, it really doesn’t result in action,” he adds.
Published in The Express Tribune, October 16th, 2013.
Like Life & Style on Facebook, follow @ETLifeandStyle on Twitter for the latest in fashion, gossip and entertainment.
COMMENTS (13)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@broken chooza is a prime example of what is wrong with our people as we are over populated by the lowest common denominator who are ready to strike down than support anything "made in Pakistan!"
@optimist: Do you expect thanks from india for creating market for indian films with pirated dvd's and cassettes.In feburary 1992 article in TIME magazine was published with heading "pakistan piracy capital of world" you can check it in archives.Under US pressure pakistani agencies cracked down on people producing hollywood pirated movies, and controlled piracy to some extent but India is different.Hurting india is favourite passtime in pakistan.No effort ever was made by pakistani agencies to stop it.Regarding royalties for Mr mehndi hassan,I must tell you, no matter how great a singer he was, his popularity among regular people in india was pretty low.You will have to hunt 20 different shops to get mehndi hassans or noor jahan's CD.Jagjit singh,hariharan or pankaj udhaas were far more popular. Piracy is hard to kill but the government should have some intent to curb it which is miserably missing in pakistan.
@Bilal: Its not about not liking a pakistani movie my friend, but basically the concept is pathetic. Afridi is a poor batsman on international stage and you really can't admire or make a man ones role model if all he gets is FAME....??? Averaging under 23 runs in almost 375 one day matches scoring just 6 centuries???? OR bowling with an expensive rate of runs per over (nearly 5 an over)??? Honestly, you cant praise him for one fastest century match and 2 or 3 performances in T20...he simply doesnt deserve it So the film wasn't bad but idea was.
@broken chooza: Exactly...the film is made in the name of a man who is such a flop show on international cricketing scene and doesn't worth it at all. I would have loved to watch a movie related to wasim, inzi, imran, waqar or any body who worth it. What a poor performer, just lucky enough to get fame and there you goooo.....mein hun shahid afridi.... good luck goofy audience and viewers
This leak definitely has India and Indians hand in it. They don't want Pak cinema to succeed and are jealous of its success.
@ Mohindar Sandhu It is not Pakistan against India. In fact, priacy has helped create a market for Indian films (while they were banned for 40 years). . Copyright situation is very bad in Pakistan. Since our artists don't get royalty, they often die penniless despite being big names (like Mehdi Hassan). . Situation in India is a little better but that is only for Bollywood films. Imagine the popularity of Medhi Hassan in India. Now how come he didn't get billions in royalty from there???
Even indian movies must not be aired soon after its release this proves that government is not acting against piracy,by promoting piracy pakistan is losing millions of service tax revenue and income tax.
Most of the Pakistani films (including Khuda Ke Liye, Bol etc) are available on youtube. It aslo affects dvd sales.
This is what is happening with indian movies in pakistan, from last many many years,No steps what-so-ever was taken to stop this piracy.Indian producer lose lots of money to this kind of illegal showing of movies.In fact india was blamed for hatching conspiracy to flood pakistani market with indian movies to distroy pakistani film industry.It cannot get any more ridiculous.Like they say What goes around comes around.
@broken chooza: No doubt movie is not great but still makers have spent lot of money on the movie. No one has a right to watch it for free. Its a theft, just like anyother theft. Most of us when watch pirated movies, don't realize that getting service without paying provider is a crime.
@broken chooza: Yeah you are used to watching B-Grade Indian movies so you won't be able to watch this kind of movie which doesn't have anything interesting for your kind of mentality
I won't even watch it if someone gives me money to watch this comedy.. :P