The person in the above narrative is me. I am a woman and if for some reason I happen to be treated like a respected human, I am expected to react in surprised gratitude. Because, really, if I walk into a coffee shop after midnight with a man who is a friend, I don’t fit the cookie cutter template of being someone’s wife or sister. But then, we are progressive now, so even if the man accompanying me is my boyfriend, I will not be questioned.
However, since he was neither and I was the only woman in the room, I was beyond being labelled. Hence, I was up for grabs — in this situation, quite literally so.
I am used to both men and women turning when I walk into a space. It’s flattering mostly, and in all honesty, if no one turned, I would be offended. They turn and stare, but then they stop. This time, however, one man turned around and refused to go back to what he was doing. He kept staring and I gave him time, until it started to bother me.
I did, however, finish my coffee and dessert — a much-needed intervention after a long work day. As I started to walk out, the same man brushed against me.
I reacted in a very unladylike fashion, verbally at first. I asked him if he was missing his mother. I said this because I wanted him to realise that I, too, am a woman. As sacred as his mother’s would have been, my honour is equal.
He was taken aback and lashed out with a choice insult involving my anatomy. That’s when I physically attacked him. And I didn’t back down, even after the initial shock of those around me faded and they tried to stop me.
It was not fair — that’s what my premise was.
Eventually, I had to be dragged out. One of his friends followed and asked me to calm down since I was like “his sister”. At this point, my temper soared again and I told him that I refuse to be associated as anyone’s sister, mother or wife because I am none of those — I carry my own dignity.
When I narrate this incident, most people find it either an exaggeration or they start to lecture me against doing something of this sort again. I probably will do it again, however, because there is a strong sense of injustice here punctuated by the fact that my honour is defined by that of the man accompanying me; both of these realities are things I will never agree with.
That evening, I walked out with some bruises but my pride was intact. He probably went home confused though, with whatever scars I had inflicted.
Published in The Express Tribune, July 30th, 2013.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (18)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Wow. You are justifying your violence and taking law in your own hands. Your place is in a jail not here writing columns
you're nuts, try getting some psychiatric help instead of debating gender inequalities
Well done Ammna.
Even after reading this many men would be thinking what were his precise comments about your anatomy.
Yes, gender classification is too deep-rooted
I totally understand your behaviour and very courageous reaction to such incidents. However, it can be extremely dangerous in a country like Pakistan where the majority of men are sexually frustrated, to say the least. So, I would advise you to refrain from physically attacking these men who are capable of committing some horrible acts. You could verbally attack them but refrain from physical attacks.
@AD: What an arrogant statement. "Women in general are totally confused just like you." Now really. If anybody is confused it is YOU. Disagreeing with a woman is one thing but condemning all women is nothing but shameful. And I am a man. How many men steal, kill or lie? A lot more than women. How many men beat up women? But I will not claim that all men are evil. In a society like Pakistan, where women have very little to be happy about, we should encourage those few souls who do have the courage to tell us their version of the story of life. I do not expect you to say sorry because I know many many men who have very negative opinion about women. And I do not see a wind of change increasing its speed sometime soon.
@Mirza: So true - I totally commend her on what she did but then again, I totally understand what you are saying - so true ...sometimes I think it is just not worth it ...thinking of the possibilities of putting yourself and your family in danger ..... and it is better to walk away. You never know what these guys are thinking assuming that the reason why he brushed against her was to create a scene, in the first place...testing his grounds.
I respect the way you stood up. It is courageous and commendable, however if you are living in city like Karachi. I think it was more towards being stupid instead of being brave. Simply because you do not know the person you are messing with. He could easily be someone who might be capable to do unthinkable things to you afterwards. He could easily indulge in activities such a rape, kidnapping or murder etc. Amazingly this is something that not only women but men have to worry about as well living in Pakistan. Beacause hey, Pakistan is the land where anything unjust is possible. Meanwhile no justice is provided to anyone expect the rich and powerful assuming they are on the side of justice.
I also don't believe in this theory of calling any random women as sister, mother or daughter or any other relationship, I consider them women and I respect them as a woman and a human being. But they get angry for not considering them baji or beti or ammi. Looks like you meet wrong guys and I meet wrong women.
You are to be congratulated for your reaction. However I believe how many women in Pakistan or for that matter in all Muslim countries can react this way and get away with it. In Muslim countries Women have been murdered for going out at night. So long as women continue to wear hijab or burqa they will be treated as chattels by men. Women of the western world rose up against the domination of the men and gained the status they have today. Still violence against women in the world continues. I am a community ambassador against domestic violence against women campaign by men started in Canada nearly 30 years ago. Well meaning men of the Muslim world should stand up against the mullahs and imams who say to women to cover up and not go out at night. In Aceh, Indonesia the authorities do not want young women to ride scooters and not wear trousers or jeans. What a stupid world we live in. Once again well done and encourage other women of your acquaintance to stand up to men.
Kudos to your Amna. We need more women like you in Pakistan. Well done and do it again.
seriously
Apne mun se sher ban gayein ap. :P
That's sad to hear. A woman should be able to live with an independent sense of respect and dignity. Although, rationally speaking, what you did was risky. I know why you did it and I don't find anything wrong with your reaction except the possibility of a hostile reaction from the man. (Which is why people would have advised you not to react). Let's hope someday we can grow out of our repressed sexual frustrations and start treating women, regardless of their habits and clothing, as decent and respectable human beings.
why again? Why the change in the title?
hahaha........ I agree with the writer with most of the facts but the dilemma of womanhood is not because of men only.
Women in general are totally confused just like you. You refuse to be "associated as anyone’s sister, mother or wife", yet you are the first one to associate yourself with his mother. "I asked him if he was missing his mother. I said this because I wanted him to realise that I, too, am a woman. As sacred as his mother’s would have been, my honour is equal." If you are a separate individual unassociated to the above mentioned relationships then learn to gain respect as an individual. I have never seen a man asking for respect because he like anyones father is a man hence deserves respect. We make our own mark and stand on our own feet and earn our respect.