Really? Or, is it the corruption in the local civic bodies because of which the drainage system is blocked resulting in this waist-deep flooding in the heart of South Delhi? Or, is it the corrupt politician accepting bribes from the corrupt contractor who has ensured that substandard material is used for substandard construction? Or, is it because of the civic authorities, bribed out of their minds, who care little about naked electrical wires and the complete misuse of amenities by unscrupulous shopkeepers and others? Or, in short, is it the nexus of the corrupt politician, bureaucrat, thekedar and the minions who have looted the peoples to provide infrastructure that dissolves in the rain, and cannot take the pressure of normal monsoons?
The chief ministers of Delhi and Maharashtra are silent, as are the ministers concerned in both the state and central governments. There is not a word of remorse, not a word of apology, just the usual ostrich-like approach of burying the political head in the water in the hope that the crisis will pass on its own.
The international airport at Delhi was flooded out last year. At that time, the big time contractors insisted it had nothing to do with the construction but with the fact that the local civic authorities had not bothered about proper drainage outside. Engineering experts at the time were quoted in sections of the media as saying that the flooding was because of design and construction flaws but then the big contractors made sure that the big politicians in charge did not listen to the dissenting voices, and the issue passed with the monsoons. This year, the airport has been flooded twice already within a month. Passengers arriving at Delhi find themselves wading through ankle deep water, with the conveyor belts and lifts out of operation and chaos overtaking the international airport.
Politicians have allowed Delhi and Mumbai to rot to a point where they probably no longer know where to begin. Roads in posh New Delhi have caved in; roads in Mumbai have gigantic potholes; the drainage system is completely choked, and no one is willing to take the responsibility. All in power are apportioning blame to the other, with not a thought for the 33-year-old film-maker who had stopped to draw money out of a bank and was helping his grandmother into the car when he was electrocuted. And why? Because the municipal lords had, in all likelihood, been compensated sufficiently to allow a jewellery shop owner to place an AC unit on an iron railing outside his shop, in complete violation of the municipal by-laws. The two shop owners were arrested and released on bail but what about the civic authorities who have allowed all kinds of violations to take place across Delhi? Who is going to act against them? No one, as all are in cahoots. Delhi is a city run on black money with real estate contributing largely to the parallel economy. Money flows in black and creates a system where individuals who have the money bribe their way across the board; and the institutions of the state emerge compromised and corrupt. The honest individual is not just a rarity, he or she is considered a fool by those earning the fast bucks, acquiring real estate, shopping in five-star malls, and taking glitzy holidays. For them, the price of tomatoes and onions is meaningless, “Rs20 or Rs100, what is the difference?”
This time around, the usual platitudes “we will ensure this does not happen again” are also not emerging from the political class. The consensus seems to be to hunker down, wait for the rains to pass and hope that the short memory of the public and the unprofessionalism of the media that rarely follows up stories will work in favour of the corrupt and cold nexus controlling Mumbai and the capital of India.
Published in The Express Tribune, July 27th, 2013.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (23)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@np:
And there are Pakistani columnists published here & in India that whine about Pakistan! The Author, like Aakar Patel & some others, is a syndicated columnist just as there are Pakistani syndicated ones. Their columns appear simultaneously in India/Pakistan dailies/Blogs. They essentially address their compatriots that make their primary audience & critique their respective countries instead of saying syrupy sweet things. For my money she is doing a great job. However, if others feel differently they must realise it's an opportunity for Indians to say nice things to counter her. Here somebody could have mentioned rain-water harvesting pioneered by Chennai or initiatives taken by cities to segregate plastic waste by paying for it or gone lyrical with monsoon on Western Ghats & so on. But that would prevent the pleasure of whine against the whine, wouldn't it? P.S.a correction: the lyricist of the song mentioned was not Majrooh but Noor Lucknawi.
@Rakib: Ah but have not ever seen this lady share any joy or say a single nice thing about India. She simply comes here and whines.
@Prabhjyot Singh Madan:
(what is the point in discussing Delhi and bombay in this newspaper except to score points)
Share some joy, some frustration, share life!
Kuch Apni kaho kuch Meri suno kya dil ka lagana bhool gaye, kya bhool gaye?
rone ki aadat aisi pari hansne ka tarana bhool gaye, haan bhool gaye?
(Majrooh/Lata/Talat)
I agree with the lady in this matter but what is the point in discussing Delhi and bombay in this newspaper except to score points. By the way, my Calcutta city suffers from the same problems too. Rab rakha
But the problem is that the same people responsible for these problems will happily return to power in Delhi and Maharashtra just because they are "secular".
This is the truth. Corrupt politicians and civil authorities are hand in gloves for all problems of this nature. They eat away a sizeable chunk of the funds allocated towards civic bodies and common man has to suffer. This is somewhat similar to what Pakistani citizens are facing. Of course how different could the mentality of common man be given our shared history of thousand years :)
The article is spot on. Every year Indian authorities have been caught sleeping on the job. The monsoon arrives every year but you would think it was the first time the authorities have experienced something like that. Muppets like Delhi chief minister rather than fixing the problems ask the Joe public to pray for the rains to stop. How ignorant and illiterate is that? Here is an excellent article talking about the civic sense in India.
http://m.thehindu.com/opinion/open-page/why-are-we-such-litterbug/article4960638.ece/?secid=3044
The flooding and drought situation in India is indeed extremely severe, and of course, like all other matters of public well being, corruption and poor governance affect water management in the country. However, I feel that the author is missing the forest for the trees here. Cities like Mumbai and Delhi have natural drains that would carry excess rainwater away and prevent flooding. In times of drought, these would be important reservoirs of fresh water.
However, with the reckless, ecologically insensitive model of urban growth that we Indians have embraced, these natural drains, the Yamuna in Delhi and the Mithi and Poisar in Mumbai have been thoroughly choked. No amount of man made drains can do what these nature made drains can.
@nrmr44 We have the same problems as india. We could learn lessons from India. Pakistani cities may not slums to you but to me they are.
Good article Seema Mustafa......Indian infrastructure is a disaster
The drainage system in India is of such compelling interest in Pakistan ........... ?
Seema Mustafa, you must move to Pakistan. You are a Muslim and Pakistan is the country where you should live. They have no monsoon issues, caste issues, inequality, injustice. Its is paradise on early. Move on and enjoy your life in a Muslim Paradise.
Who cares about the monsoon in India? Why is Express Tribune publishing stories about India that have no relevance to Pakistan?
I did not know it was THAT bad. What you said about Mumbai and Delhi, could be said about Karachi (which gets very little rain) or for parts of Lahore or Multan. A very well reputed town planner explained Karachi's problem by showing that the drainage net-work most of it laid during the British days only needed to be kept cleen especially the exit area...............the rest is the same story as described by you and money has to be made.
@Prany: This person water bottle is a wonderfull nationalist indian I like his realistic understanding not some hyper national India is a supper power
@Water Bottle: Wonderfully most aptly put ................ there is no city in India by any standard it is a extended slum just a few clean at different gps locations within indian boundary doesn't mean these are cities
Seema, a Pakistani by faith and Indian citizenship by affiliation is writing about Indian cities in her countries newspapers. Who in Pakistan cares? But she cares for Pakistan and so provides some comfort to her countrymen.
Hay Waterbottle, Are you a glass water bottle or a plastic (PET) one?!!! :-)) I hope you are the glass one going by your intense frustration!!
First of all, Ms. Mostafa, who told you that India has cities?
India does not have one single city. In fact, the entire country is one extended slum.
We Indians are utterly irresponsible goons. We have no civic sense.
Why blame the government?
Plastic is choking this country. India will be smothered to death by this plastic menace in the decades to come if something is not done. Most of the floods we see in the so called cities are all artificial because fools like us choked out drains and sewers with solid and non biodegradable waste.
If want tea, we want it in a plastic cup. We want our Pani puris in foam bowls. We want vegetables in plastic bags. We want our groceries in plastic bags. We want plastic plates and spoons when we eat Samosa. We want our chips in aluminum laced packages. We want our gutka in sachets which wouldn't rot in a million years. We want our arrack in plastic bottles. We want our water in plastic bottles.
And what do we do with our consumed plastic? We stuff plastic bags with biodegradable waste, tie them up nicely and throw them on the street/sewers/drains. Where is it going to go? Into a bovine's rumen? Clog the drains/sewers?
We are destroying our country one street at a time.
While agreeing with everything written in the blog I do not see its relevance to Pakistani public as it is not news such as the murders in the name of religion that occur and reported daily in Pakistan.
The storm drainage system is very old and inadequately designed as the population grew. Modification of existing system was not properly done as cities grew. People threw plastic bags in storm drainage pipes choking the system. It's not just Mumbai and Delhi. Same thing in Lahore. I have not studied the system in Karachi but I have read some issues raised by Late Mr. Cowasjee in Dawn newspaper. While the Central, State and Local politicians have a lot to do with these problems, the corruption has also a lot to do with both the storm drainage and the sanitary sewage system. I can discuss the solutions but no poltician would want hear them. So sad.
@Author: I like your article and as you may know I have been your nemesis for long time. , As far as Mumbai is concerned, much of the flooding has to do with the flooding of the Mithi river. This river has been constricted due to encroachments and despite a SC order I would seiously doubt that much has been done. The Congress began by building vote-banks among the perpetrators of the encroachmemt and the Shiv Sena decided to play them at their own game by having their own set of encroachers rather than solve the problem head-on. Not only this river, but the sea-shore of Mumbai is filled with encroachers.