Punjab’s education success story

Some areas in Punjab have passed 90% enrolment mark, others in rural areas & south Punjab, girls’ schools, lag behind.


Madiha Afzal July 20, 2013
The writer is an Assistant Professor of Public Policy at the University of Maryland, and a Non-Resident Fellow at the Brookings Institution. She tweets @MadihaAfzal.

“One child, one teacher, one book and one pen can change the world. Education is the only solution. Education first.” So ended Malala Yousufzai’s rousing speech before the UN Youth Assembly on July 12. Malala voiced a call to action to fulfil the universal right to education for every child. With 40 million  out of 70 million Pakistani children aged five to 19 not attending school, Pakistan is performing poorly in this regard. Given this, it rightly seems that we have mountains to climb before we can educate all our children.

But this is not a column about how dismal things look, about how our government is inefficient, and how our citizenry is unmotivated. It is about the steps that are being taken in the right direction, especially in Punjab. Here is a look at some of the “good news” from Punjab’s education sector, as Sir Michael Barber, Department for International Development’s (DFID) special representative for education in Pakistan, describes it. Due to a number of interventions, which are part of a larger reform road map, teacher presence and student attendance numbers have shown impressive increases in Punjab. Both the percentages of teachers present and of already enrolled students attending class were greater than 92 per cent in December 2012, up from 72 per cent and 82 per cent in September 2011, respectively. The percentage of schools with functioning facilities has also increased from 69 per cent to 91 per cent in the same time frame. Enrolment has seen increases for the five-to-nine-year age range, but most of these come from kachi (or kindergarten classes) and do not yet extend all the way through primary school. While some areas in Punjab have laudably passed the 90 per cent enrolment mark, others, such as rural areas and southern Punjab, as well as girls’ schools, clearly lag behind. In addition, students are learning more. The latest Annual Status of Education Report, which assessed over 60,000 children from all Punjab districts, reveals significant gains in learning outcomes for both literacy and numeracy. Clearly, there is much more work to be done, but the above indicators show progress.

A number of policy innovations, fostered by the DFID and led by the Punjab government, have made these developments possible. Greater monitoring of schools has been instrumental in improving teacher presence. This has been made possible by the tireless work done by a revamped programme monitoring and implementation unit. Also key is the Punjab Education Foundation, which enables poor children to attend low-cost private schools for free. There is also the Punjab Educational Endowment Fund (PEEF), established in 2009 to provide merit-based scholarships and assistance in the 16 less-developed districts in Punjab. It has awarded over 41,000 scholarships, worth over Rs2 billion.

A number of government policies specifically target girls and young women. Under the Punjab Education Sector Reform Programme, annual cash stipends worth Rs1.5 billion are provided to 380,000 girls in grades six to 10 in government schools, in 16 out of the 36 Punjab districts. The objective is to improve enrolment and increase retention. The beneficiary girls are given Rs2,400 a year conditional on an 80 per cent attendance rate.

Some of Punjab’s policies and successes will be replicable and some will need to be adapted for the other provinces. The DFID is providing its second-largest funding to Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa with the expectation that some of these successes can be reproduced there. Balochistan is implementing a programme similar to the PEEF, in a good example of inter-provincial policy learning.

All of the above implies that Punjab is making strides in solving the access issue and in increasing the quantity of education supplied, at least at the primary level. But what about the quality of education? There are serious issues with our curricula and in our textbooks, as well as in how we expect our students to learn from these materials. While it appears that the 2006 curriculum reform recommendations have been incorporated in Punjab’s latest textbooks, there is no analysis yet of the quality of these textbooks. Over the next few weeks, I will be undertaking exactly that task.

Published in The Express Tribune, June 21st, 2013.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.

COMMENTS (19)

Parvez | 8 years ago | Reply

@Mudasir Roy: Your comment is a bit late as this piece has been taken of the main page ( sad )...........I wish you had posted this earlier as it would have substantiated my comments. Thanks anyway at least I feel a little vindicated and disappointed at the same time.

Mudasir Roy | 8 years ago | Reply

I totally denied the advancement of Education due to Barber's reforms. I am an educator in the Punjab Government Education Sector. Govt. has not yet fulfill the basic need of the Primary sector, yet they urge for the betterment. It is totally a theory of hypocrisy. We are in desperate need of 6 teachers at primary level but no one is giving it a look. How can you improvise your nation with 200 students and one teacher who has to teach 6 class from kindergarten to 5th grade having 6 subjects in each grade.

Just multiply the figures: 1 teacher X (200 students* (6 classes X 6 subjects)=

you have to answer the question if you do really think that we are progressing theoretically then i will be eagerly waiting for your reply.

Shahbaz Sharif's Merit is unquestionable but his policies are totally devastating the standard of education.

Some facts:

1; Each school has only one IT teacher: Elementary+Secondary(High School) which comprises of 5 classes multiplies by __ numbers of sections.

How can you accommodate him with 15 sections (If there are 3 sections each in one class) provided by the fact that there are only 8 periods per day. Moreover IT Teacher has to look after all the Lab as well. Moreover he has to do all the clerical task of the school etc.

2: Each pupil of class of elementary has to study 10 subjects and get him passed in each of them within 210 days of education span.

etc.

Answer me and i will let you know other facts later on:

He is just making a fascinating story and let the people convince by it.

It's just a fantasy of fallasy

Roy

VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ

E-Publications

Most Read