For the current year, which is going to end in June, the average inflation target has been revised downward to 9% from the earlier 9.5%. DESIGN: ANAM HALEEM
Inflation in Pakistan slipped to a nine-year low in April despite an expansionary fiscal policy pursued by the finance ministry, underlining the need for a review of the calculation methodology that is showing a rapid slowdown in the pace of increase in prices of essential commodities.
Inflation measured by the Consumer Price Index, the most closely watched barometer, clocked in at 5.8% in April over a year ago, according to the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics. This is the lowest level since April 2004 when CPI inflation stood at 5.99%.
The declining rate of inflation has provided room for a reduction in interest rate in the next monetary policy. According to sources in the State Bank of Pakistan, in the last monetary policy the policy-setting committee discussed the possibility of cutting the discount rate, but the idea was dropped for the time being and until the new government takes over.
Since May 2012, when the last government introduced some changes in the calculation methodology, the pace of increase in prices of essential commodities has been slowing down. In May last year, inflation was recorded at 12.3%.
Experts are calling for a review of the methodology, considering the results contrary to ground realities. According to the State Bank of Pakistan, from July 2012 to April 19 this fiscal year, the federal government has borrowed Rs827 billion for budget financing from commercial banks and the central bank. This is in addition to Rs360 billion that were raised through the National Savings Schemes.
Defending the figures, Chief Statistician of Pakistan Asif Bajwa said high domestic borrowing did not have any impact on inflation as it was substituting negative net foreign assets. He said the high base impact was another reason behind the slow increase in prices of essential commodities.
However, experts attribute the reduction to changes pertaining to data collection for house rent and gas prices, which have almost 25% weight in the CPI basket. Previously, the PBS calculated the change in house rent, which carries 21.82% weight in the CPI basket, by taking the average rent for 24 months.
Now, the house rent is calculated on the basis of monthly rental survey, which is termed distortive and far from reflecting real change. The house rent increased 7.7% in April over a year ago.
Similarly, the government has reduced gas slabs from four to three, leading to a decrease of 46% in prices every month since the change took place. In April again, gas prices dropped 46.1% over a year ago, according to the PBS. Gas prices have a 1.58% weight in the CPI basket.
Core inflation, excluding volatile fuel and food prices, eased to 8.7% in April over a year ago. Experts give more importance to core inflation as an indicator that is not affected by seasonal price shocks due to exclusion of food and energy items. But they do not accept the figures, saying the trend goes against economic theories.
Average inflation in first 10 months (July-April) of the current fiscal year remained at 7.75% over the same period of previous fiscal year, according to the PBS.
For the current year, which is going to end in June, the average inflation target has been revised downward to 9% from the earlier 9.5%.
Published in The Express Tribune, May 3rd, 2013.
Like Business on Facebook to stay informed and join in the conversation.
COMMENTS (6)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
I second some of the earlier comments that there is a need to dig dipper for writing such articles. Two points are worth noting. One is related to average number, which conceals distributional contents. Another is the inflationary bias: individuals try to judge inflation based on their own consumption basket, while inflation number is based on a standard basket. PBS may step in to create awareness on these issues.
However, experts attribute the reduction to changes pertaining to data collection for house rent and gas prices, which have almost 25% weight in the CPI basket.
I completely disagree with this statement. Inflation would have followed the same trend even without cut in gas prices. The decline in inflation does not seems surprising when we consider the following factors. i) one of the major reason behind inflation in last 2-3 years was the raise in energy prices, which has been stable during the current fiscal year. 2) for different reasons, the economy is working below its productive capacity and lending to private sector credit has reduced significantly. So, in this case, even if the government is borrowing it will not raise the overall prices. 3) real wages are declining 4) real imports are recording negative growth 5) because of decline in cotton prices during the current fiscal year, agriculture sector has not provided any stimulus in the economy to boost aggregate demand.
Lastly, isn't this unfair that we consider PBS right when inflation was 25% and distrust when the inflation comes to 6%. Please stop publishing these conspiracies theories.
Is this another revenge of democracy and coalition govt to Pakistan?
Just a month ago, ET business desk was seeing green shoots in Pakistan's economy. In fact, they said the next PM would inherit a booming economy.
Please, hire someone who is familiar with basic Econ 101. Your business desk has embarrassed you for far too long.
Coherence in the structure of the article and clarity when reporting numerical figures IS KEY to such articles.
Please improve ETs standards when it comes to financial news. Heck i'll give you a free workshop if that's what it takes. Heh.
Yes, it is "core" inflation that calls for a response. The "headline" rate is typically more volatile because it includes short-term "disturbances".
Furthermore, what is your standard? Pakistan has never been a high-inflation country. If you take a fifty year average, and exclude the extreme points, positive and negative, inflation would be about 6-6.5% -- a remarkable record for a developing country.
I personally think the SBP should target inflation -- as others do.
But that is a long story.