The minorities in Pakistan continue to live in constant dread of being attacked or molested. In fact, a newspaper wag in the Karachi Press Club suggested that as so many amendments have been made to the 1973 Constitution, which has now become a moth-eaten document, there is a need to amend paragraph six of the Preamble to the 1973 Constitution as successive governments appear to have been totally incapable of implementing the relevant clause. In case some of you haven’t seen the passage, it reads as follows: “Wherein adequate protection should be made for the minorities freely to profess and practice their religions and their cultures”. Without being accused of quibbling with words, the declaration used is “should” not “will”. Does this mean that protection will be left to the pleasure and caprice of the government in power? The only time such a clause was wilfully implemented in Pakistan was during the period 1947 to 1970. There was, of course, the episode of the Qadiani riots in Punjab. But the historical fact is that the Ahmadis were not officially declared non-Muslims until they were excommunicated by the parliament led by Mr ZA Bhutto, which was formed after the eastern wing was wrenched out of the combine.
In his column in The Express Tribune, Yaqoob Khan Bangash did a bit of tongue-in-cheek sermonising when he asked all minorities to leave Pakistan. Even if this was financially possible, where the hell would these people go? The days of Ayub Khan when Pakistanis could travel freely to all parts of the globe at four rupees to the dollar are long forgotten. Nobody wants Pakistanis anywhere, anymore, except in parts of the Gulf where foreigners have no legal rights, and the Far East, provided they bring plenty of cash. They are isolated at immigration counters at Western airports, on suspicion of being potential terrorists. Mind you, Pakistani Hindus and Christians have a much better chance of getting a US visa than somebody with a strictly identifiable Muslim name. So those who can make it, get the hell out of here. Those who can’t should pray that the next Lucomo who misgoverns the country should keep the promises he makes to the masses.
Published in The Express Tribune, March 17th, 2013.
COMMENTS (40)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Iqbal: Rest agreed, there is a flaw in your understanding of Islam. Islam never disallows exit from faith, and the option for converting away is always available. It is the Mullahs who have fed it in the minds of Muslims that Islam orders to kill the apostate. Islam is so attractive in its true form and Mullahs have maligned its image all over the world.
Some say that the minorities in Pakistan are treated as slaves as second grade citizens ruled by their masters(first grade citizens),minorities have no human rights who's loyalty is always questioned and they are seen in suspicious way,they are seen as to be traitors and often falsely implicated under draconian and discriminatory laws such "Blasphemy law".
@Arzoo: There are a number of typos, hundreds and thousands not billions. The name 'Hindu' was given by the Iranians to natives and this was based on the living style and their social behaviour. They were modern homo sapiens who wandered from the Arabian pennsula along with others to Asia about 130,000 to 90,000 years ago. The great Asoka after having completed his killings around converted to Budhism, people who later converted to Islam started before the intrusion of Arabs, turks and moghuls and during the period when arabs were tradding in India and later settled down.
Rex Minor
In the current state, Pakistan is neither for minorities nor for majorities; Pakistan is a paradise for the barbarians who kill with impunity and politicians who loot and rob with impunity. Pakistan is the only country in the world where the blood transfusion takes place from the sick and the poor to the healthy and the rich.
@Kamran: @Ahmadi Momin:
What we are facing today is the result of successive weak governments bound with equally weak coalition partners. These governments are devoid of the essential human quality of compassion in which situations mushroom when political expediencies acquire preeminence. What Pakistan is facing today is, "The absence of education and the presence of mullahs." With saner elements in society and physical rectitude, this will Inshallah disappear. A far as our society is concerned, "Different ethnic groups are essential for all societies." Salams
Arzoo, Thank you for some Monday morning humour. I did not know that Mahmud of Ghazni, Mohammad Ghori and Mughals like Babur were Sufi saints who were visiting India to spread the messsage of Love and Harmony. Temples as far away as Madhya Pradesh & Orissa bear marks of this love and harmony preached by centuries of sufism on their mute stone sculptures. Perhaps you should visit them sometime to further enrich your knowledge of history. Also, the population of the Planet is approx. 6 Billion today. I also have no know-how on the 'Billions' of Buddhists who inhabit it. Where do they live?
Arzoo, Thank you for some Monday morning humour. I did not know that Mahmud of Ghazni, Mohammad Ghori and Mughals like Babur were Sufi saints who were visiting India to spread the messsage of Love and Harmony. Temples as far away as Madhya Pradesh & Orissa bear marks of this love and harmony preached by centuries of sufism on their mute stone sculptures. Perhaps you should visit them sometime to further enrich your knowledge of history. Also, the population of the Planet is approx. 6 Billion today. I also have no know-how on the 'Billions' of Buddhists who inhabit it. Where do they live?
Why criticise the behaviour of the masses who were simply following the Blesphamy law which the pppp Govt. is responsible for! O'k those who committed arson and disturbance could be tried in a court of law. But who is the great man who legislated the revised version of the Blesphamy law. How can one commt esphemy in a country of majority muslim population.
The country needs written rules of rights and responsibilites for ctizens in Pakistan. Is this avilable to all citizens in the contry? How should a citizen know if his behaviour is improper. The guy who escaped to Germany should get hold of a copy of the BGB end send it to the chief Justice of the supreme court. I though Pakistan was a democracy..
Rex Minor
@Gp65: I do not see "all the US and UK people lining up" for Indian Citizenship either. A nation of rapists have no room to be sanctimonious and lecture others on these matters:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-india-21812849
@TEJAVARDHANA: "@BlackJack: Hello, In India everybody is safe including Muslims. Dont tell lies. Come to Gujarat and ask Muslims only, they will tell they are most safe in Gujarat. Do not spread rumours." @BlackJack is an Indian and a very well informed one. Please read the post again. HE is not the one talking about the Gujarat riots. He is making fun of waqar.
@iqbal I am skeptical of all religions. This is for purely intellectual reasons. To varying degrees all religions are challenged by science. If you do the reading the same arguments used by the philosophers against Christianity are also applicable to Islam. If you meet Christians from Middle East you find they just as reactionary as the Muslims. I am sure, if they were the majority the Middle East Christians would be persecuting the Muslims.
I posted this on another forum too ...
Article from our Pakistani newspaper Daily times from March 16th http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=20133\16\story16-3-2013pg3_5
"COMMENT : Democracy and Indian Muslims — Tufail Ahmad" , Google it if you want.
Many people will not believe what is written in that article because the author Tufail Ahmad is of Indian Origin. Just like Fareed Zakaria.
Similarly Pakistanis refuse to believe any of the mainstream news on India. We just want to believe and tag on to the fringe news - the rapes, the Sati, infanticide etc .... to fulfill our fears that India has not progressed ... that it is still like us .. that we have not been left behind in the club which now comprises of Somalia, Yemen and Afghanistan type countries. We do not want to laud the efforts of our arch rival to break from the social ills and other issues to move forward and join the western club. We want it to stay back in the cess pool that we are in.
Such thinking will not help us. We are slipping, they are moving on ahead and out of our hemisphere ...
@waqar:
I ran Away From Gujrat, India this week. I am now living in Turkey peacefully.
The Turks gave you a visa only because you were from India. Be grateful to India for that.
The Turks take Pakistanis and dump them in no man's land.
http://tribune.com.pk/story/505557/stranded-in-saudi-700-innocent-pakistanis-duped-by-turkish-company/
@fahad: Take a walk Fahad. Don't live in a make believe world. Usually no one likes change and this is true for religion as well. Anyone who is powerful creates supporters and this is how invasions lead to conversions. In Goa for example, and other areas say Diu and Daman, there were conversions to Christianity because of the Portuguese. Why did people not choose Islam there? And in Mysore and Hyderabad, why did people become Muslims? It was because of the rulers. There is otherwise nothing value adding in Islam,
There should be a new transfer of population agreement between India and Pakistan. All non-muslim minorities of Pakistan (except Ahmeddiya) are welcome to India. Any Indian muslim wishing to migrate to the other side, should have the opportunity to do so.
@Arzoo: A bit of non sequitur eh? No one has criticized Islam here. All that is being discussed here is sectarian violence in Pakistan. So are all the US andUK people lining up for Pakistani citizenship then?
As an Indian I am NOT OK with communal riots and tit for tat killing and it is due to this attitude of the people that over the years communal riots have gone down greatly and interfaith harmony has increased. It is not because riots present a bad image of the country that they are reprehensible but because lives of absolutely innocent people get ruined and they are Indians.
Pakistan was also for the minorities... its history now
@BlackJack: Hello, In India everybody is safe including Muslims. Dont tell lies. Come to Gujarat and ask Muslims only, they will tell they are most safe in Gujarat. Do not spread rumours.
@Arzoo:
But who said that UK and US were against their Muslim minorities. It only proves that Christians are large-hearted enough to allow their minorities to prosper.
To prove the critics wrong you will have to prove that minorities are prospering in Pakistan or for that matter in any Muslim majority country.
Go for it, Tiger.
@Mr Iqbal In north america i dont see muslims are poor and i dont where u got the figure from and in whole muslim world is not bad either compare to poor non muslims of many afro and latin america. thanks.
@Arzoo: I think you are missing the point. You should compare apples with apples. I have seen this article before. The problem we have is that Islam does not allow muslims to convert to other faiths. Some time ago I wanted to convert to christianity but my relatives did not allow because it is forbidden. There are a lot of instances in the West where people who have converted to Islam have expressed regret but cannot convert back.
@Iqbal: Good try. Seems like a lot of Indian trolls on this site spewing their hatred. But nature has a strange way of rectifying hatred. A record number of people are converting to Islam because of this hate propaganda. The example I am quoting pertains to Britain, it is the same thing in the good Ole US of A. Take a look for yourself:
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/the-islamification-of-britain-record-numbers-embrace-muslim-faith-2175178.html
@Parvez: I apologise for some of the silly responses we are having in respect of this very good aricle.
I suspect waqar was educated in a madrassa where hated towards minorities is taught: http://dawn.com/2011/11/09/pakistan-schools-teach-hindu-hatred/#idc-cover
@waqar: your attempt at countering @Ahmed Shah was pathetic...............made people laugh more than anything else.
Is Pakistan for the Pakistani people? No it is not. How can one tell? We all can see that the Pakistani people have abandoned Pakistan to the crooks, criminals, thieves and murderers. It that true or not? If the people did not abandon this country for the crooks, criminals, thieves and muderers why then will we be seeing the crooks, criminals, thieves and murderers ruling over this country. The people everyhwere in the world are their own worst enemies. They do what they should not do and do not do what they need to do. So what do they need to do? Very simple. People should from today make a resolution not to make the mistake they have been making all these times i.e. leaving their coountry to the undesirables. They must start taking interest in those matters that concern them. To achieve this it is just common sense that people, organise themselves to become strong enough to be able to deter all the undesirables from coming anywhere near the corridors of power. Just too many friends of the people i.e. thinkers, philosophers writers etc. have come and gone and advised people to do exactly that i.e organise themselves into one party. A party of the people, by the people, for the people. Where should people go to start their organisation? Charity begines at home. They should start organising themselves from the localities where they live. Once they all start coming together then most likely they will not need any advice or suggestion from anyone as coming together to do good work for all, upholding justice at all the times will put them on the path to wisdom as this parctice in itself is wisdom and the best favour they will ever do to themselves. To bring people of oher localities in contact with each other they will need to elect someone from their each localities. Elect and keep him/her under their control. Can one expect people to start doing the biggest favour to themselves. This will be a chnge for the better. Better for all, except for the crooks, criminals, thieves and murderers. So let us ask this question. Can we do it? Yes we can. Weherever there is will, thereis way.
@gp65: couldn't stop having a rolling laugh 'coz of your witty response !
@waqar: "I ran Away From Gujrat, India this week. I am now living in Turkey peacefully. We were all very scared that there might be another Mass Killing Event Against Muslims. "
The last communal riot (not mass killing by the way) that happened in India was over 11 years back. Dozens of people guilty present in the last riots have been convicted by the courts. No communal riots in the last 11 years and you ran away to Turkey NOW? Sightly delayed response times - eh? Also why did you not run away to the country that was created for the safety of Muslims? Oops - they stopped accepting Muslims after 1949...
Oh and you gave yourself away by how you spelt Gujrat. In India we spell it as Gujarat, not the way it is spelt in Gujrat, Punjab. So really where did you run away from?
Mr Iqbal
Please study Islam thoroughly , and then decide if you want to be a muslim or not. Our ancestors were never converted by any force, they converted because they saw what true islam means and how the sufis practiced it. it was their way of living with invited others to convert.
It is law of Sharia and islam also to protect the country men belonging to other relegions also untill they attack you. if they seek your protection you have to provide them.
What is happining is not Islam in any way ! I hope someone can educate these fools that blankly follow wrong leaders. and trials should be done against these leaders for their fake theories.
@waqar: I ran Away From Gujrat, India this week. I am now living in Turkey peacefully. Buy a map, since Gujrat is not in India, you may not have actually reached Turkey yet.
I ran Away From Gujrat, India this week. I am now living in Turkey peacefully. We were all very scared that there might be another Mass Killing Event Against Muslims. Last time it Happened nothing was left. Thousands were killed. There were cases of rapes etc. Back home people are living dangerously and Muslims are deprived of basic rights.
In Christian countries people ask themselves "What would Jesus do?" when pondering difficult problems. If you want to know where minorities in Pakistan should move to, perhaps you should ask yourself "Where would Jinnah have emigrated to?".
Yes, minorities most definitley should leave Pakistan.
The heading misleads you.
You are talking about Constitution and Laws and stuff. Yes, good, but that can, rather will not happen.
The Feudal Elites who created Pakistan, their Political Party's name was "Muslims" League. The capital of Pakistan is "Islam"abad, not Seculrabad.
Pakistan DOES NOT belong to the Minorities. You are the majority community member, your intentions are good, but not everyone feels the same.
Take Ideology, HIstorical Events, Symbols of the state, Constitution and Law, nothing is there to suggest minorities of Pakistan are actually part of Pakistan.
@ Ahmed Shah
hopefully you are not creating a Pakistan in Germany.
@Ahmed Shah: Good for you. Just stay away from Rostock and Hoyerswerda where racist incidents against foreigners are common. And count your blessings that you are not in Mexico and some other countries where life is more dangerous than in Pakistan. And that includes some parts of urban U.S.A.
I totally agree with Mr Mooraj's view. His final paragraph has a chilling observation about we muslims being seen as potential terrorists. I will go further, we are also behind in education and health. In UK there has been many research into Pakistani muslims and other people from the sub continent. This probably sums it up: http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2002/feb/20/race.immigrationpolicy I live in UK and I know we are subject to a lot of suspicions due to our militancy and hatred towards minorities. I have at times applied for jobs with short names suggesting that I am a hindu but after I go for an interview and after they discover my real name and place of birth I am politely rejected. I think we are doomed in the West. Even Mr Musharaf has a point when he said of us (muslims): "Today we are the poorest, the most illiterate, the most backward, the most unhealthy, the most un-enlightened, the most deprived, and the weakest of all the human race" I totally agree with him. Remember, our ancestors were either hindus or buddhists who were converted by force some hundred years ago. That would not happen today unless you live in Pakistan.
I think the word "minority" is a misnomer. Every group is otherwise a "minority" based on certain of their distinctive beliefs.The current "majority" based in Pakistan is currently/actually a "minority" in India.
I would have preferred the title "Pakistan for ALL Pakistanis".
65 years have passed and it is time for the people to realise that religion is the business of individual people and not the business of the state. One cannot be a muslim pre-1974 and suddenly becomes a non-Muslim post-1974.
Only Mullahs and the people they misead can digest such irrationality.
I ran away from Karachi last week to Germany due to the security crisis. We were all scared if someone will shoot us. I am writing this comment from Germany where it is very peaceful. Back home people were very dangerous.