I am not a movie fan and know little about films, but the gripe of most reviewers is that this film features Arabic being spoken on the streets of Pakistan in the year 2011. One reviewer even ridiculed the scene of a camel train somewhere in Abbottabad. This poor reviewer may actually never have left his TV lounge where he writes his reviews because we have camels aplenty in this country.
I have no idea what director Kathryn Bigelow and her team had in mind when they put Arabic in the mouths of men who should actually have been speaking Hindko, but I fear this film may well turn out to be prophetic: that one day, we will totally succumb to Arab imperialism and actually make their language the official language of Pakistan. That we will then be seen running around with bed sheets for clothes with our heads bound with fan belts.
This is no unfounded fear, mind. The change has begun. In Punjab, it is creeping in. And it is coming by car. Or, at least, by car registration plates. Ever since the incumbent chief minister banned the official registration plates that came encrypted with every detail of the car and the owner, we have once again reverted to plates of all patterns and colours.
The new one, very likely paid for by the Saudis as they pay for most seminaries in this sorry land, is now in Urdu lettering. The red band on top is marked ‘Al-Bakistan’. Mind, it is not ‘Al-Pakistan’ but BAKISTAN. At the bottom, another red band reads ‘Al-Bunjab’. In between are the alphabets and numerals of the registration number in Urdu. By the way, that was how Ibn Battuta pronounced the name of this province.
While ‘Bakistan’ and ‘Bunjab’ have been sold, for some curious reason, alphabets like ‘p’ or the palatal ‘d’ continue to be written in Urdu as they should be. That is, they retain their sounds. I suspect the sluggish Arab mind behind this sneaky move to colonise us in terms of language did not realise this snag. But, sooner than we know, this will be changed with ‘p’ on the registration plate replaced with ‘b’. And if that throws everything out of kilter at the registration office, so be it.
Now, as this assault on language continues (and grows, as all evil must), we will soon have some idiot wanting to banish the hard and aspirated sounds that make Punjabi (and Urdu) the languages that they are. True, Lahoris from the inner city who simply cannot pronounce the palatal ‘r’, and with some difficulty, the palatal ‘d’, and for this handicap are made fun of by the rest of us, will be delighted. They may even claim that having embraced the one and only true religion, they knew the way the language would ultimately change and had adjusted their language accordingly centuries ago.
But why Bakistan? If ‘Falisteen’ (as it is pronounced in Arabic) can become Palestine in European languages, why can Pakistan not be ‘Fakistan’?
Every time I see a car with the ‘Al-Bakistan’ and ‘Al-Bunjab’ plates, I want to stop the louts to ask them why they should corrupt the name of their land. But the ugly, thuggish characters driving these cars make me desist. Because as things stand in ‘Fakistan’, it is impossible to attempt to talk sense to anyone, least of all to a yahoo.
In Karachi, they shoot you before you have delivered the first admonishing word. In ‘Bunjab’, they first abuse you and then ask if you are the mama (maternal uncle) of ‘Bakistan’. Since everyone except you is known either to some politician with a bogus degree or some thug of a police thanedar, you decide discretion and cowardice really are the best part of valour and withdraw.
‘Bakistan’ zindabad.
Published in The Express Tribune, March 2nd, 2013.
COMMENTS (33)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Under light tone is the feeling of insult and injury of a man who is proud of his ancestry. There is honour in that,surely!
i think mr rashid to get bhavan india protection after pakistan become bakistan...
Ahhh....Pakistan in submission of the Arab world. Poor Pakistan, willing to erase its rich past, dating back to Indus civilization.
0:30 the director introduced Arabic to imply that the terrorists were from Arab lands and the director wants to imply that the scenario of terrorism played out in the arabic speaking neighborhood crowd of PAK. Many in PAK fail to take notice this subtle face saving grace of Urdu speaking normal pakistanis generously showed by the director. But after reading this article, may be she had a good perception of PAK !
Camel runs in sind,punjab,chistan,india rajhestan, and any desert country not in Hindhco speaking area the reason its not a deserts,..
@FU I checked the Punjab MTMIS website (which seems to be regularly updated) and they are issuing the same, normal, license plates. I couldn't find one instance of the sort of plates he's talking about, anywhere. Anybody else seen 'em ?. . . http://mtmis.punjab.gov.pk/images/services.jpg
@Adnan Khan: Dude, the number plate was posted on 07-OCT-2011. Author is talking about 2012/2013.
Unlike OBL, Hassan ibn Sabah only targeted killed generals and princes that ordered the persecution of the Nizari Ismailis. He did not go around getting innocent people killed.
Bedsheets for clothes and fan-belts for heads? Oh so its allright to wear Western clothes then? I don't see Mr. Salman in Pakistani Shalwar-Kameez or the wider South-Asian loincloth.
Bedsheets for clothes and fan-belts on heads...??? hahaha!! Pakistani 'designers' - take note!!
Its like asking as if you like Shawarma or McDonalds!
You should ask what a Pakistani who has spent all his life here wants ! Why focus on Arabinsation or Americanisation . People heed either to Usa or Arab countries to make future just because they dont get any opportunities here due to definitely lack of government interest in providing opportunities and employment and the result is they totally become a part of this americanisation or Arabinisation process.
I love Pakistan and i would be much happier if we retain Our identity . And by our identity i just mean simple 'Pakistani identity' which is a beautiful amalgamation of sweetness of Sindhis, bravery of Pakhtuns, hospitality of Punjabis, Sincerity of Baluchis and zeal of Kashmiris, and not to forget the loyalties of long forgotten northern areas.
However if i have to choose between devil and deep sea then let it be the deep sea the deep rooted Arab sagar instead of Drone Devil.
Hasan bin Sabah was evil? Dude, he was an Assasins. The Assassins were a whole organization. They didn't hurt innocents. You have no right to judge them.
This is the 2012 Punjab car license plate. There is no "B"akistan here. . . http://www.pbase.com/bmcmorrow/image/138866476
"That we will then be seen running around with bed sheets for clothes with our heads bound with fan belts." I think with this you have officially become my all time favorite writer now. Have great respect for you and would love to meet you one day. You are a true offspring of Mother Saptasindhu.
I think the author has extrapolated a highly dramatic and therefore improbable scenario. Seeing few Arabic name plates in lands of millions and projecting it on the entire nation is statistical slight of hand. Days of Arabization are so 80s and 90s. Youth in Pakistan is going through a very strong identity shake up and therefore, will most likely survive all imperialisms and come out with an identity of its own. To put things in perspective, how Pakistan has survived last 5-10 years despite all the troubles is nothing short of impressive and for that alone, I am proud of my country.
Sir, you are one of the few people who understand that civilization doesn't exist without its culture.
Salman's observations are epic as well as scholarly and my request to him is to educate readers about migratory birds of Sindh in coming columns.
great article as always.
I went to a party in London sometime in the 70s where some Arabs were present. I remember feeling utterly nauseated at how we fawned over the Arabs in the most degrading and servile manner.
And, its not hard to impose a language on a society. Its happened in Pakistan before with Urdu.
So, much so that case is being made that number plates should be in Urdu, not Arabic! Urdu is an Indian language. Only 8% of the people spoke it at the time of Partition.
Arabic is Allah's language, Urdu is tied to Hindi, Indian influence will never cease with Urdu as the main language. There is every reason that these two reason will result in fading of Urdu and promotion of Arabic.
I think Arabization of Pakistan and adopting Arabic language as the 'mother tongue' of Pakistan is a good idea. Arabic can be mother tongue and Chinese can be father tongue. Then you would have wiped away last traces of a Hindu past and rid yourself of Hindu imperialism.
@Razi:
Obviously you only see good looking "mushtanday/ ghunday" types. Just wait till you rub someone the wrong way and you will realize your mistake.
This country is finished.
God bless your soul, dear Sir. . I am in awe of your articles, but I rarely comment on your articles.... . This time, I am speechless... ...This is all I can muster.
Razi I agree with your observation. I respect his difference of opinion but he is really arrogant and contemptuous when it comes to arguing with people who do not agree with his opinion. This article is as disgusting as his previous ones.
Salman Rashid speaks rubbish as gets carried away by flow of his thoughts and literally becomes abusive. Bet me Arabic is never going to dominate and it has never dominated in history. Salman sahib muster your courage and speak about Urdu imperialism that has humiliated so much that Punjabis that they feel ashamed to speak their language. I am not mentioning how they mock at non Urdu speakers speaking Urdu. the very seed of seperation was sown by Urdu not Arabic. they even try to change Bangali script into Urdu. Old people like Salman Rashid should stop giving sermon to young generation. You just hide your blunders and presume that we follow the path of your fictional articles .
You are getting too close to no go area.
It was fun reading though. NFP and gang could learn from you.
I enjoyed the Film Zero Dark Thirsty. It was a hollywood film and not a documentry. It is not important that it told all the truth.It did not tell any lies. The rest of the article is a riddle. We will carry on speaking Urdu, thank you. Not many speack Arabic.
Salman Sahib, reading your piece is always a delight, many thanks. "Fakistan"