The head of the Indian Air Force, Air Marshal N A K Browne, has warned that if there were any more ceasefire violations by Pakistan along the Line of Control, New Delhi may have to “look at some other options.”
The warning was issued following a meeting with the Indian defence minister and chiefs of the Indian Army and Navy.
Air Marshal Browne, who is currently the head of the Chiefs of Defence Staff Committee, termed the violations along the heavily militarised LoC and the 2003 ceasefire agreement by Pakistan as “totally unacceptable.”
“We are watching the situation carefully, if the violations continue, perhaps we may have to think of some other options for compliance,” he said, but declined to elaborate on the options. “Options are options … If violations continue we might have to look at the whole issue again,” Air Marshal Browne reiterated.
On the other hand, Indian External Affairs Minister Salman Khurshid said in an interview to NDTV news channel that the government was not “going to be pressurised by wild calls for revenge and reaction.”
“We will do what is in the best interest of the country and peace, keeping in mind that there is a lot at stake.” He added that heightened border tensions demanded very responsible, sensible and moderate behavior.
Union Minister of State for Information and Broadcasting, Manish Tewari said the killing and mutilation of the two Indian soldiers on January 8 was in violation of the “rules of engagement.”
“The government is doing everything at the strategic level to express its anger. We have said clearly that the incident is inhuman. The incident is in complete violation of the Geneva convention and rules of engagement,” Tewari said at a press conference.
There was a lull in the escalating tensions on Saturday as no firing occurred along the LoC, a spokesperson for the Indian Army said. “There was no ceasefire violation along the Indo-Pak border this morning,” Colonel R K Palta said.
However, the opposition Bharatiya Janata Party’s former president, Rajnath Singh said the government should recall its High Commissioner to Pakistan and scale down the level of diplomatic ties. He added that the recent incident indicated Pakistan was not keen to improve relations.
Congress leader Ambika Soni said the killing of the two soldiers was a hindrance to confidence building measures between the nuclear-armed neighbours.
In the Poonch district of Azad Jammu and Kashmir, citizens appealed to both the governments to restore peace and respect the 2003 ceasefire agreement. In a written appeal, prominent residents of the town said: “For the people of Poonch region, as others living close to the LoC, the ceasefire [agreement of November 2003] brought peace, security and created an atmosphere for development in the border areas.”
Commentators and defence analysts said that India needed to exercise restraint, but could not be expected to do so indefinitely.
In a signed column, Col (Retd) Jaibans Singh agreed both the rivals needed to exercise restraint, “but we also need to lay down a threshold which says - this far and no more. If the whole matter culminates with some meetings and a few well guarded words, mostly spoken by our ministry of external affairs, then no message would have been sent to the Pakistani Army and such intransigence will keep happening.”
Published in The Express Tribune, January 13th, 2013.
COMMENTS (11)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Rakesh:Time shall tell who is stronger and who is weaker and if suppose we are weak as you said then come on and take over the whole Kashmir because our weakness has to be the golden opportunity for you and also you have to take the full advantage of our weaknesses?Who is stopping/refraining you from doing so and what are you waiting for and why are wasting the time on the useless and non-result-oriented peace talks and negotiations with Pakistan?And as far as you stance is concerned "talking about your heroes the talibans and jehadies (Mujahideen) these coward’s have strategy to fight in mountains and valleys where it is difficult for regular army to fight. they cant fight head on like men(still they are not winning" then would you like to explain that why approximately 600,000 Indian are deployed in Kashmir to control these coward Mujahideen and why Indian government is wasting billions of Rs. on 600,000 troops in Kashmir whereas only few thousands are good enough if the Mujahideen are coward and as far as Taliban are concerned than why US has tired now and announcing the dates of withdrawal from Afghanistan?
@Clear Black Bag: don't be so over confident on the false propaganda that your ruling class has developed in your country since its creation. your country has lost all the wars it waged against India, which was conveyed to your people as victory's. in 1965 India was ill prepared for war, you had superior air power and the US was on your side still Pakistan was defeated which clearly demonstrated who got more will power to win.. talking about your heroes the talibans and jehadies (Mujahideen) these coward's have strategy to fight in mountains and valleys where it is difficult for regular army to fight. they cant fight head on like men(still they are not winning :-) ). and considering your present conditions it is worst than 65's and 71's. so don't invite India like this, if your proposal is accepted by Indian military, probably Pakistan wont survive. you better get your facts write and think logically.
"@Sandip:In 1971, you faced a deadly insurgency in just one province. Today, there is one in every 4 of your provinces. US is unlikely to foot any bill on your behalf, unlike in 1971. Investments in Pakistan is anyway very low due to security situation, your dollar reserves are nothing to speak of. An army needs fuel to fight. Do you have any idea how much fuel you have in reserves? The international community is already wary of a terrorist infested Pakistan. So using military options to force them to act on your behalf is unlikely to work either. All in all, things appear to be stacked against you pretty high. Think coolly before you speak and more so before you act." Suppose you are saying true and right then why don't you test your war's and troops' abilities and war's resources India does have against Pakistan now and why don't you take the full advantage of Pakistan's weak military and economic conditions?And your these words show and prove that you are still living in the past and considering Pakistan like 1965's and 1971's conditions.Come in the battlefield and see who is superior and who does have more power and resources to win the battle and what are you waiting for and why are you missing this golden opportunity to take over the whole Kashmir? Never live in the dreams and never forget it that India's approximately 600,000 troops couldn't defeat the freedom fighters (Mujahideen) of Kashmir then how shall you defeat Pakistan armed forces with limited resources as you said in your comment.And always remember that war is always fought with courage,belief and faith not with the bulk quantity of the weapons and Taliban are the live example before you that they are struggling against the superpower US' and NATO's troops with limited resources and war's related equipments,weapons and accessories with true belief,faith and courage from last 10 years in Afghanistan and as a consequence of this war US is announcing troops' withdrawal's dates and facing sever economic crises in USA itself....
@John B: "ET your news is old, PAK and India are having flag meeting with an afternoon tea to discuss the welfare."
I think the Air chief's statement started with 'we are monitoring the situation' - so it was never a threat of immediate action. Rather it was a warning to not develop the type of false compacence that prompted Kargill. Nuclear umbrella does not mean that Pakistan can do anything and India will not retaliate.
OFcourse India has never started a war and never will.
In that sense the Air Chief's gave a statement of intent which is not outdated by any means.
@Clear Black Bag: In 1971, you faced a deadly insurgency in just one province. Today, there is one in every 4 of your provinces. US is unlikely to foot any bill on your behalf, unlike in 1971. Investments in Pakistan is anyway very low due to security situation, your dollar reserves are nothing to speak of. An army needs fuel to fight. Do you have any idea how much fuel you have in reserves? The international community is already wary of a terrorist infested Pakistan. So using military options to force them to act on your behalf is unlikely to work either. All in all, things appear to be stacked against you pretty high. Think coolly before you speak and more so before you act.
@I-umaid: That's what you did in Kargil. Kept on waiting while IAF used "other options" to clear the intruders. Good keep on waiting.............
Clear black bag Taliban needs serious help.
ET your news is old, PAK and India are having flag meeting with an afternoon tea to discuss the welfare.
new bottle news??
How India reacts today will determine how things work out for its soldiers in the LoC.
India should also push the bar up, so that even militants sneaking in will be a violation of sovereignty and a violation of ceasefire.
This should not continue anymore.
Pakistan is stuck in a costly, murderous anti-insurgency operations in the tribal areas, we can afford to escalate and be rest assured, mere escalation will hurt Pakistan, as it would have to move its troops from the tribal lands to the borders, thereby helping the TTP. If not us, TTP will do the work for us..
Pakistan is stuck in a catch-22 situation. Its too proud to admit it.
"NEW DELHI:The head of the Indian Air Force, Air Marshal N A K Browne, has warned that if there were any more ceasefire violations by Pakistan along the Line of Control, New Delhi may have to “look at some other options.” You are most welcome and we also are mentally ready to response/reply you in the same way you are going to adopt and moreover now Kashmir issue must be resolved thru any means and manifestation because there have been 65 years wasted on the useless and non-result-oriented peace talks and negotiations between Pakistan and India and never forget it that now Pakistan armed forces' current conditions and abilities are not like 1965's and 1971's and are most especially importantly are much stronger than 1971.And also never forget this harsh reality that those who always live in the past and discuss on the past's gone issues and matters always commit the biggest ever committed mistakes intentionally and one thing more,id est,both countries are nuclear states and both countries do have mass destruction and nuclear weapons and missiles and the destruction shall be more than expectations.So never live in the past and stop stargazing and daydreaming of defeating Pakistan and live within your limits Indians because present Pakistan is never like the past Pakistan and Pakistan is never only like a cricket team but is now a full-fledged country...