The chivalrous perpetrators of this horrid crime must be so proud of shooting an old and defenceless woman whose only crime was that she looked after those at the bottom of the Pakistani pile; and their orphans and their sick; the poor of the poor of Youhanabad. And who also ran an adult literacy centre to improve the lot of those left by the wayside by an increasingly bigoted and unfeeling state. More than anything else, the braves must feel elated that they have killed another kafir and have further purified the Land of the Pure.
For all the good work that she did, Sister Bargeeta must be in heaven by the grace of the Almighty: this is just to beg her and her loved one’s forgiveness for the pain she went through in the days after her shooting as she struggled to hold on to her beautiful life, and to send my heartfelt condolences to all those left uncared for and alone in this increasingly ugly and vicious and cruel country. There is not much more anyone can say about a horror such as Sister Bargeeta’s cold-hearted and sickening murder, except to remind ourselves that this wanton killing is another nail in the coffin of a civilised Pakistan.
As if to say the great men of Lahore who killed an innocent, and may I say it again, defenceless woman are not the only gallants around, their brothers-in-arms in Karachi killed five women dispensing anti-polio vaccine days after Sister’s sad death; those in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa, one in Peshawar (a 14-year-old volunteer), and a woman supervising the anti-polio campaign in Charsadda — and for good measure her driver, too. By the by, the World Health Organisation has stopped polio immunisation in Pakistan forthwith. We should not be surprised if Pakistanis are now not welcome in other countries for fear that any of us might be carrying the polio virus.
Amid all of this mayhem, Twitter is humming with rumours that extensions in service will be given to some powerful players including in the army and judiciary; a government of ‘technocrats’ (who have failed this country repeatedly, kindly note) will be engineered in; and elections will be postponed for a year. Does this not dovetail neatly with the recent ‘revelations’ of the NAB Chairman, Admiral (retd) Fasih Bokhari?
Whatever in the world has got into the man? On December 13, he says there is ‘corruption’ of Rs7 billion every day in the country; exactly one day later and abracadabra, that figure becomes Rs12 billion a day. Neither was this the end of it: two days after this shemozzle, we are worst confounded when a NAB ‘spokesman’ tells us that 65 per cent of this corruption is done in Punjab. I ask you!
What magic wand did Bokhari wave, what dream did he dream, that all was revealed unto him? Or did he read Harry Potter and intone ‘Specialis Revelio’ which causes something to reveal its innermost secrets? He must tell us the magic with the help of which he got his figures and also explain why they changed so drastically upwards inside of 24 hours?
The admiral not only sounds ‘at sea’ (pun intended), he looks it, too. Did some ‘movers and shakers’ in his organisation feed him these figures or was he merely spouting someone else’s without giving a single thought to how silly he would look when people turned these outlandish sums over in their heads? The admiral must immediately clarify the details of his accusations. For if he does not make a full accounting, people would be justified in thinking that this is all part of above ‘conspiracy’.
Let’s look at this another way. As an editorial or two, and several op-eds in various newspapers (which I am sure have been ‘put-up’ to the admiral by my friend Shaukat Qadir) have suggested, not only are the figures mind-boggling, the ‘timing’ of the ‘revelation’ is most curious, too. Add to that the fact that only the federal and Punjab governments have been named by the admiral and you get the drift of what I am saying. I mean, the elections are mere months away, so is this an insidious, nay brazen, attempt to favour a particular party (wink, wink)? The admiral trying to fill ‘spymaster’ Pasha’s ill-fitting shoes, eh what?
Seriously, how possibly can Bokhari conflate electricity theft and crooks not paying income taxes, to corruption committed by governments? I am not saying all the people in government are angels, but Rs12 billion a bloody day? Fifty billion dollars a year? Poppycock!
A word or two about the infamous tattoo(s) found on the Peshawar airport terrorist(s): so what if one or all of them had tattoos? They could have been hardened criminals on the run from one of Russia’s gulags; they could have once been gang members. What is the problem here? Who has ever accused the TTP of being angelic?
Finally, it is rather rich of the shadowy ‘security official’ to accuse the civilian governments of not taking ownership of the War on Terror when the army arrogates to itself all decision-making on this matter. As we well know, it only turns to parliament when caught in a tight spot such as Osama bin Laden’s discovery and killing in Kakul.
Let me say in the end that most of the chickens hatched by the Deep State are home and roosting nicely, thank you very much. If COAS Kayani and DG ISI Islam do not even now live up to their reputations of being 28 and 52 on Forbes’ list of the world’s most powerful people and root out the evil of terrorism from this poor country, we, and they, are done for.
Published in The Express Tribune, December 21st, 2012.
COMMENTS (37)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Paki2thecore:
Stage left; enter the apologist.
Seriously, what are you talking about? The Connecticut shooting? PLEASE get a grip and stop willfully casting your eyes away from your own demon by pointing to another. The Connecticut shooting was an absolute travesty, and so are the MANY travesties that visit our hapless country on a daily basis. However, I, as a Pakistani, am more concerned about what happens in my own country, to be very honest. When we (as a state) are able to provide security to our own people--Ahmadis, Shias, Hindus, students, volunteers, social workers, doctors, farmers etc--we can THEN worry about "taunting" others. Until then, we must fix our OWN house.
Lone incidents? With due respect: you are delusional. Men, women, children, social workers, teachers, students, doctors, politicians--PEOPLE, PAKISTANI citizens--are killed everyday by the Taliban. Sister Birgitta joins a very very VERY long list of innocent people who have become a target of the Taliban. Please stop apologizing for them, and accept what they have done is barbaric and have done so NOT just to malign the image of Pakistan (as abu-uzh has pointed out above, we do a marvelous job of that ourselves) but to spread fear in all our hearts. Moreover, please stop pointing your finger outwards towards the US, and rather, look inwards.
@Paki2thecore:
You have observed , Sir , that "these terrorists have a mission to distort the image of Pakistan" Do we really need anyone special to destroy our image in the world , when we ourselves are working so hard to accomplish this task ? Only a couple of days a man was beaten and burnt alive on the premises of a police station in the presence of police , a few days ealier a woman was stripped naked and paraded in the streets on the orders of the respectable elders of a panchayat, burying women alive was justified in our august national forums as a respected customary practice, recently we attacked a graveyard and desecrated over a hundred graves ----these and such others are almost daily happenings in our beloved country . Do we need , Sir , any terrorists to destroy our image ? And why to worry only about the image ? Why not worry about our ugly realities ?
Great Article Mr. Shafi, albeit quite heart rending. Being an Indian who has never met a Pakistani, I hardly understand Pakistan. In spite of many internal conflicts India is much different from Pakistan. But reading the headlines one can feel that Pakistan is increasing tormented by a Frankenstein monster. Who is Dr. Frankenstein is immaterial today. But the reality is there is a monster in your midst. May God give you strength and wisdom to overcome it.
@Mind Control.
Rightly said like a true Shaheen... we are proud of you..
A well written article.A nation with zero tolerance, all brave bigots want to go paradise by killings innocent and defenseless people. Actually, we are now known by terrorism, radicalism. Whatever comes in our mind, they try to impose by any means.
For all the good work that she did, Sister Bargeeta must be in heaven by the grace of the Almighty
Beg your pardon.
Kaffirs are not admitted in Jannah.
Not even Mother Teresa.
A very good write up which was enjoyable as always. However, my suggestion to KS and ET is that since a number of issues are discussed, it should be published as a weekly column with a single title eg 'Straight talk, From horses mouth, Take it or leave it or Bull's eye etc'. India's most famous writer Khushwant Singh used to write very popular weekly column 'With malice towards one and all' in a popular Indian daily and even though I am not comparing them for their professional skills but incidentally initials of both are same ie KS. The mantara which the military is following is that whenever in a fix, fire from the civilian govt's shoulder and let them take the brick bats. As far as figuring in the Forbes most powerful persons is concerned they surely are powerful, running the country through remote control but without any accountability. Nevertheless, they proved themselves to be powerless as well as incompetent in front of a jihadi outfit whether deliberately or otherwise is difficult to state.
People in Pakistan have to start taking responsibility of what is going on in the country. Instead of blaming "them & they" we should start cleaning up our house ourselves. The government, the judiciary, bureaucracy, police, city officials do not comprise of aliens but Pakistanis. They are men & women who grew up in this country and live here. Every one that I see is trying to make a quick buck, lie, steal and cheat and then hide behind the beard or the veil to show piety. But they are really fast to point out the faults of the "system". We have to understand that "we are the system" and the people in power are just a cross section of the common citizen.
zSir, you are just hitting your head with wall by telling us that we should stob being an abnormal country. Punjab constitutes 60% of Pakistan and they always buy their establishment's endless lies started from 1965 War loss to 1999 Kargil misadvadure and 2 May 2011 debacle. I think East Pakistan was quite fortunate to get out of this penorid federation controlled by Punjab through their military establishment. Other three smaller provinces should take leaf out of former East Pakistan's book and opt for peaceful divorce from Punjab and let Punjab enjoy their weird Generals' srategic theory .
We shoot defenseless women don’t we — By Kamran Shafi
Of course you do, cause they can't shoot back...
@Sterry: I hope you don't mean us on your Eastern border. Just for your information, we bestowed our highest civilian honour "Bharat Ratna" twice on Mother Theresa! Actually Indians & Pakistanis are similar in many ways & should do introspection to get out of such mindset so that even TTP changes its ways & stop killing innocents. Shafisahab, another gem from your 'mightier-than-the-sword/AK47' pen. Carry on the good work you are doing & take care of your safety.
This land once rich of genuine heros in every fields has turned into a barren land where only hypocrites are born.These power hungry bigots know only one thing;people of this country are most vulnerable to rumers,whispers and lies,fool them in the name of corruption,religion. nationalism ideaologies.One such ridiculous story is 12 bilion corruption in one day.What is the size economy of this country no one will ask. Excellant article kudos to writer.
I have only qts who is "we". Thats the problem with Mr. Shafi, he blames everything on "we" does we include him? Stop accusing the collective we, I understand Mr. Shafi has some personal issues against "establishment" (read pakistan as whole) and age seems to be catching up. Take a rest baba ji and stop saying "we". May be its only 'You".
The murder of this good woman is indeed the last nail in Pakistan's coffin. From now on let it be shunned by all humanity. May a Pakistani never be allowed to travel beyond its borders. Next time a catastrophe hits Pakistan, pray to your murderous faith to bring deliverance because the rest of the world is sick to its teeth with your idiocy. Stay away, breed polio, and kill each other in the name of your god.
Bravo sir! I detect a hint of an adrenaline rush too. But well written.
Fantastic article! We surely are very ungrateful & thankless people & bite the feeding hands.
The failure is of the much touted democracy. This 'democracy" has FAILED to deliver at any level and now after 5 years of this PPP, MQM, ANP & PMLN government this country is now a failed state! Maybe the author should write about this and should stop blaming our army!
@Lala Gee
Is Pakistan army free from corruption?
@Lala Gee:
I think I have a pretty good idea of the level of corruption in government after having spent 25 years in it although whether it is worse now or not I cannot tell because numbers are just thrown around every day with no basis. No one tells us HOW the number has been arrived at. That is all I am saying: " tell us how you came to this estimate".
As for quoting me on the List Price, that was just one example of an exaggerated claim. That does not mean there is no corruption in PIA.
Mother Teresa served the poor in India, we gave her the Nation's highest honour. Compare that to Sister Birgitta who served the poor in Pakistan for 35 years.
The moral of the story is "If you feed snakes, someday you will get bitten"
Another bold and fair Op Ed by KS. Thanks ET for that. Each and every elected govt has been overthrown by the generals using the excuse of corruption. Yet there were never any true accountability and the politicians who cooperated were rewarded and those who did not were sent out or hanged or killed. The NAB chairman is a top army-man and it is not surprising that he is talking like a low IQ person. The army cannot use the treason card (as the US and donors would not allow) against the govt so they are left with only one tried and tested option of corruption. Only extremist fanatics can kill unarmed social and medical women workers. I am so disgusted, outraged and ashamed that I have no words to condemn it.
@meekal a ahmed:
"But NO ONE pays List Price! Both Boeing and Airbus discount their prices to woo customers. And their competition can be pretty fierce."
It seems that you have no idea about the level of corruption in governmental departments. Not only they would ask the bidders to raise their quotations, even much higher than the list prices, but also ask them to deliver scrape, or discarded non-functional stuff, and pay them more commissions while earning better profits. Many contractors told me this personally, and I know this from my own personal experience as well. In my assessment, hardly more than 50% to 60% of money is actually spent on any governmental projects, and the rest goes as bribes and commissions. And this estimate is only for the projects that actually exist, not for the paper projects where 100% goes to personal pockets.
Regarding the author's point about the timing, postponing elections for 1 year, and extensions for certain people, I think he is right, but he is wrong in his assessment who would be the beneficiary due to his own personal prejudices. You need to recall who appointed the Admiral and his past behavior, who negotiated NRO, and who would really benefit from and who be at disadvantage from the elections delay. If not obvious to you, only PPP would benefit from the delay, and PML(N) and PTI would be at disadvantage. It should give you enough clues who is behind all this.
@Paki2thecore: I inadvertently pressed "Recommended". KS is one of the few sane voices left in this country. May God bless him.
@Falcon:
Very well said. Perhaps the Admiral referred to the number of corruption cases in Punjab as its population is 60% of Pakistan, otherwise 70% of the financial transactions take place in Karachi and Islamabad.
With due apologies to the writer this article speaks of the narrow mindedness of the writer.
Lone incidents should never be used to unnecessarily belittle a people who have come thus far, despite all odds being against them.
I wonder why Kamran failed to see the lone assassin of the primary school in Connecticut, and did not target entire USA whereas he targeted entire Pakistan due to this particular event.
I'm not saying what the Jaahil terrorists did was right. But we also must not forget that these terrorists have a mission to distort the image of Pakistan, and the writer is doing nothing different.
May I ask the writer why he did not taunt the second most powerful man on the Forbes list after the Connecticut massacre? Plus, the Connecticut incident wasn't the first time ever in the history of US, whereas the killing of a missionary old woman in Pakistan was probably the first ever incident of its kind.
@ Haris Chaudhry: You might be barbaric in drawing a twisted conclusion from a twisted write up about a twisted incident. Don't blame the nation for your own lack of judgement.
@Author
Did Kayani not promise to defend the ideological frontiers of Pakistan when he took over as COAS.
May be he is doing a good job of it.
Someone shoots someone somehow this is existential problem of Pakistan.
The fault lies with state because it don't provide any law and order. Instead of mincing words in talk shows and news papers why there is no pressure on state to fix law and order.
Thanks for writing about Sister Birgitta. I was feeling ashamed at the indifference of civil society and government. The honourable lady served this nation for 40 years and no body uttered a word on her tragic murder. Same is the case with killing of polio workers...the teenage volunteers have been killed dastardly and there is no vigil, protest, no procession to condemn the savages. Sad...extremely sad state of affairs.
Mickey,
The first part of your article makes my heart ache.
In regards to corruption, all so-called estimates of corruption are open to critical scrutiny. I have no idea how they are calculated and we are not told that. The devil is in the details, as they say.
That does not mean that corruption does not exisit. But if you insist on putting a number on it, you had better have a solid case.
In a recent report on corruption in PIA, they took the LIST PRICE and multiplied it by the number of aircraft and said "Lo, there is corruption"!
But NO ONE pays List Price!
Both Boeing and Airbus discount their prices to woo customers. And their competition can be pretty fierce.
we are a barbaric nation.. period !
The army in its infinite wisdom is still pushing the 'technocracy' option. They must know better than their paymasters (i.e. we the People) what is good for the country.
Agree with the rest. But the explanation to discredit figures of corruption are more of a conspiracy theory than anything else. I am afraid this is a new habit being picked up by liberal enthusiasts of Pakistan where everything to them seems like conspiracy of establishment. They must understand that this hurts their credibility in the long run, because as obvious, some times their claims are as exaggerated as are those of people on the far right. Lastly, for your question about 65% of corruption originating from Punjab, last time I checked, Punjab was more than 60% of Pakistan, so why is that figure such a surprise?
Well spoken and reasoned. The sad part of these recent killings is that, in some circles, the conspiracy theories will probably flourish that these women were Blackwater agents and such! As for Pakistanis not being welcome in other countries, might that be the reason so many of the Elites are dual nationals, free to travel on their REAL passports if the end comes!
Tattoo issues extraordinarily cheap even for Pakistanis.
Pakistanis having lived with Pakistanis, do not know how low they have stooped to.
Pakistanis need to become outsiders to see how pathetic they look to the outside world and no matter how much lies they shout the only ones who end up believing it are Pakistanis.
I think it is clear that the culprits behind the killing of women and innocents are just anti state criminals on the payroll of foreign agencies. Their game is to sow unrest and cause confusion. Fortunately most people in Pakistan understand that a lot of this criminality is sponsored from beyond Pakistan's borders.
Excellent......excellent and more than excellent, if that is possible. Our security establishment cuts a very sorry figure today.