‘Besides govt, 10% NGOs are also wrong’

Published: November 21, 2012
CM adviser speaks at workshop to reflect upon the management of 2012’s floods. PHOTO: AFP/FILE

CM adviser speaks at workshop to reflect upon the management of 2012’s floods. PHOTO: AFP/FILE

KARACHI: If there were problems in the government systems, the relief systems of the international NGOs were also not up to the mark, said Sindh chief minister’s relief adviser Haleem Adil Shaikh.

He was speaking at a workshop, titled ‘Issues during Flood Emergency’, organised by the Participatory Development Initiatives (PDI) and the Oxfam Novib. Commenting on the participants’ view of the government’s relief and rehabilitation systems, Shaikh said that, “if things are 90 percent wrong in the government, then 10 percent wrong things also happen in the NGOs”.

The participants were discussing the relief work carried out by the Sindh and Balochistan governments after the rains in 2012, when Jacobabad district in Sindh, and Naseerabad and Jafarabad districts in Balochistan were flooded.

Shaikh said that the relief distribution system by the government was inefficient and corrupt, adding that it must be changed by involving local community-based organisations, notables and social welfare department in the relief distribution. A majority of international NGOs are only interested in collecting data instead of supporting the affected communities, he said.

Pakistan Muslim League-Functional MPA Nusrat Sehar Abbasi said that the government had completely failed to provide timely relief to the flood affected communities during the 2012 floods. Not only were the funds released late but there was rampant corruption in the relief funds, she claimed. Relief was only provided to potential voters, she added.

There may even be duplicity in the government as the relief department and the Provincial Disaster Management Authority are working as parallel departments, without any coordination with each other, she said.


Pakistan Peoples Party MPA Ayesha Khoso replied that the PPP government tried its best to support the flood affected communities, however, there were certainly some flaws. She said that there is a need to make the local government effective to improve disaster risk management, as well as, disaster relief mechanisms.

During his presentation former Sindh irrigation secretary Idrees Rajput disclosed that a lack of drainage system in Jacobabad was a major cause of flooding in the area. The Water and Power Development Authority (Wapda) is preparing a master plan to prevent the 2012 affected areas from floods in the future, he said.

Nevertheless, Rajput feared that this master plan may face the same fate as the plan to remove engorgements from the natural waterways, which was prepared last year, but could not be implemented.

Due to global climate changes, there is a strong need to redesign the irrigation infrastructure because Sindh is located on the lower basin, he added.

The participants were worried that more than two months have passed and some villages are still inundated. The affected residents from Balochistan blamed both their government and the humanitarian relief agencies for failing to provide adequate relief facilitates. They complained that they were living at the mercy of God.

Published in The Express Tribune, November 21st, 2012.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (1)

  • Jim
    Nov 21, 2012 - 3:01PM

    Criticism and restrictive discourses aside, the larger and better funded an NGO becomes, the more people they are able to reach. No organisation can reach every one in need of aid and support–and the majority of governments certainly aren’t willing to step in. NGOs fill a much needed role in society and the success of many countries, whether developed and or still developing, is directly related to the work of NGOs. the aid and assitance of NGO in Thailand as an example may be flawed and flabby, but poverty and disease is still prevalent, so why attack those who are capable and willing to help?


More in Sindh