Chief Justice (LHC) Umar Ata Bandial was hearing a petition filed by a Lahore-based advocate against Asif for holding dual nationalities – Canadian and Pakistani.
The petitioner had presented relevant record before the court and the hearings were held for the last three months.
Rana Asif’s membership had been suspended on August 3 on the petition of Faisal Ilyas Sadiq.
Sadiq’s counsel, Saiful Malook, had pleaded that the court should suspend the membership of Asif as he is a Canadian national.
Article 63(1) C bars any person who is a dual nationality holder from representation in any legislature of the country, he said.
Asif’s counsel was quick to rebut that Asif was a Canadian citizen but not a Canadian national and therefore under the said article of the constitution could not be disqualified.
Malook had said that the MPA had an overseas identity card which could only be issued if Asif was a foreign country’s passport holder. He had also produced a copy of the card before the court.
The minority issue
Asif’s religious affiliations had also challenged in the court.
Malook had alleged that Asif had pretended to be a Christian to be elected to a minority seat. Malook had pointed out that in the overseas identity card Asif had declared himself as a Muslim.
He further said that all his children were also Muslims, according to the records at Nadra. Only his wife was registered as a Christian, he had said.
Asif’s counsel had told the court that his client was a Christian. He had said that his client had been mistakenly identified on the overseas identity card as a Muslim.
COMMENTS (10)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Why do these politicians hold dual nationalities?? This is because its an exit strategy! As soon as they lose power they runaway!!
@asim: My reply was based on facts and still insist that you can not call a person criminal unless convicted. Zardari is still not convicted. You have quoted examples of CIA. You should not forget that we are living in a society of law lessness. During British period bueroctaic promotions were with held if a person was REPUTED TO BE CORRUPT. Contrary to our nation perceptions western societies punish Extra Marital relations but Islamic societies only verbally treat them bad. Arslan Ifitkhar is facing cases which based on proofs provided by Malik Riaz Seem to be 100% true and people ar still calling CJ as angel. Nawaz Sharif was convicted and Shahbaz Sharif is Chief Minister because of a stay order, As one friend has mentioned that Imran Khan case of Sita white convicts Imran Khan legally, Zardari and Benazir have been convicted in Swiss Court of Money laundering. How many people of public life can you name as following high moral standards? Just observe the behaviour of a upper Class person breaking the traffic laws which is a good example of moral standards. We pakistanis talk of very high standards but factually each one of them observe very very low standards. I have yet to see ONE BEARDED PERSON who has not got involved in activities not allowed by Islam.
@Haroon Choudhry: Zardari is still facing corruption cases active .....SC is puruing these don't forget. The nations loose confidence is leadership by such acts. Recently US CIA chief resigned showing high moral standards and courage. General Martin Dempsey termed "Worse, they can be detrimental to the execution of our mission to defend the American people". Similarly elevation of convicted and criminals has the potential to erode public confidence in nations leadership and in judicial system as well.
@ asim
What do you say about morally corrupt Imran Khan who committed adultery with Sita White? He has been convicted by a district court in USA.... Does he fulfill the conditions laid down under article 63 of the Constitution of Islamic Republic of Pakistan?? Certainly not !! The election commission should take notice of violation of the Constitution. What a joke that he preaches "insaf" !
The consitition has other articles like convicted and criminals can not hold executive public offices. Why not implemented? The courts are playing politics.
a) President continues to hold office even serving 10 years in jail b) Governor sindh continues for the last 12 years despite murder charges. c) PLM(N) continues to rule chating democratic slogans, Nawaz in politics for the last 30 years d) NAB chairman a retired person for the last 10 years apponited to lead accountability has corruption charges against him
What a joke! Pathetic!
........and he has been sitting as a law maker all this time ??? Something very basic is very wrong here.
Congratulations. The first wicket of dual nationality has fallen.
The other dual national players will also be out in due course of time.
To become a legislator, one has to be a full Pakistani and not tthe half.
Hilarious that foreigners are ruling us, just like Imperialism.