It was June 4, 2012. Our exams were finally over and we had nothing to do apart from hatching bird-brained schemes to kill time.
After much thinking, if that’s the correct term here, we decided to spend a night with a prostitute. Before you get the wrong impression, we did not want to indulge our carnal desires. All we wanted was to talk to her and try to get her side of the story.
In our 21 years on this earth, we had done a lot of crazy and potentially dangerous things. Some of them were also incredibly stupid. But this latest ‘adventure’ really takes the cake.
I never thought it would be this easy though. It barely took us 15 minutes to find a dalaal’s (pimp) number from one of the shops in Lahore’s Heera Mandi, opposite the resplendent Badshahi Mosque. We eagerly called up the number and were instructed to drive to a specific street in Model Colony and blink our car’s headlights thrice, so that they could identify us. It all seemed right out of an adventure novel to me, but a part of me was petrified. I wondered what my dad would do to me if I got caught.
Suddenly, three cars approached and stopped close by. One of the passengers came over to us and told us ‘to have a look at the girls’. “Do you have a place or should we take you to ours?” he inquired. I nervously blurted out that my friend will be looking at the girls and we will take her to our place. I pinched Taimur, who by now was frozen in fear, and pushed him out of the car. He got out, quickly peeked into the three cars and pointed towards one of the girls.
She calmly walked over and sat in our car as the man approached us again. “Sir ji bachi achi hai, khubsoorat hai, rang bhi saaf hai aur umar ki choti hai, iska Rs5,000 munasib hai,” he said to us.
We quietly agreed, more so because we were at a loss to say much. After all, who wants to haggle with a pimp in the middle of a dark alley? Certainly not us. Seating her in the backseat, we drove towards Taimur’s apartment.
I was suddenly ashamed. Should I be doing this? I convinced myself that it was just an adventure but throughout the drive to Taimur’s apartment, I was not able to gather up the courage to turn around and look at her.
It was only when we reached our destination that I finally saw the girl. She had big brown eyes and her hair was speckled with golden highlights. She looked just like any other girl that we saw around our university campus.
Taimur’s apartment was empty as his parents were out of town. We led her to the drawing room and sat down. After some small talk, she told us that her name was Rubina.
“Aap log yahin karogey ya bedroom mein?” she asked us. Right down to business, I thought, slightly taken aback. We explained to her that all we wanted was to know about her life. At first she was a little uncertain of our intentions, or perhaps thought we had some kind of a strange fetish, but we eventually managed to convince her that that was really all we wanted from her.
We began by taking a picture of her but she stopped us with a flutter of her eyelids. I explained to her that we needed her photograph to accompany a newspaper article we intended to write about her. “Actually, my family members read the newspaper and I don’t want them to know what I do,” she told me, hesitantly. We then asked her if we should change her name also so that she doesn’t get into trouble but she explained, as if to a child, that Rubina was not her real name.
She then warmed up to us, almost as if she had been waiting for someone to bother to ask her about herself. “I am 19 years old and I started working as a prostitute when I was 17. I was raped by my own uncle at the age of 17 and then he sold me to Shamim aunty two years ago,” she said.
Shamim aunty is the “madam”. She rents houses in different areas of the city and keeps her girls there. She is also the one who makes contacts, finds “customers” and then delivers the girls to them.
“She charges for girls based on their looks. Beautiful girls can get up to Rs20,000 per night, while average looking girls can get up to Rs2,000. Sometimes, rich customers give us extra money but the bad ones hurt us physically,” she said, as she showed us cigarette burns on her shoulder. I asked her if I could take pictures of them, but she refused.
But in their world where money seems to rule, there are some things that are more sacred. “Shamim aunty is very nice and takes care of us. We live like a family and we care for each other, sharing our happiness and sadness,” Rubina told us.
Since her family is unaware of her “profession”, we ask her what she has told them. “My family thinks I work at a bank and sometimes when I am out at nights, like today, I tell my mother that I am staying at my uncle’s house,” she said.
This is the same uncle, her tormentor, she told us. “He is married but he’s a really bad man. He beats his wife and even me if I refuse to go to customers. He works with Shamim aunty,” she said. “He always takes a cut from the money I earn. Shamim aunty fights with him for taking my money, but he doesn’t listen to anyone.”
Almost naïvely, we asked her why she doesn’t just run away or inform the police about all this. In a moment of courage, we even offered our help by reporting her uncle to the police. “I wish I could,” she replied wistfully, “but my father has cancer and I have six siblings to look after. My mother is a maid and she can only make 2,000 to 3,000 rupees per month. I do this because I have to feed them, I don’t have another choice.”
As we digested this information, she added as an afterthought: “It’s not like the police would help me either. Some of them are customers and all of them take a commission [from the brothels].”
She felt, however, that there may be a way out once her younger siblings begin to earn. “All I want is my little brothers to grow up soon and become doctors or engineers, and I pray for them daily. What really kills me is that whenever I go home, my father puts his hand on my head and says he’s proud of me,” she said, as she broke down.
I am still not completely sure if she told us the truth or simply gave us a printable story. But what I do know is that under different circumstances, she could have been my classmate or even my friend. Instead, she’s forced to sell her body to provide for her family by fulfilling the desires of men. And, as a man, I hang my head in shame at my inability to help her improve her lot in life.
* Name has been changed to protect identities
Published in The Express Tribune, Sunday Magazine, September 30th, 2012.
Like Express Tribune Magazine on Facebook and follow at @ETribuneMag
COMMENTS (42)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
A good piece of writing...... well deserved to be rewarded by 4k !!!!
Nabeel...i love this piece...:)
Something very true !!
A ususal story. A slap on the face of human right activists
Bold step. Author must have to courage to write so openly,good piece of writing !!
This is something very true and unfortunate happening in our country too...this stuff is absolutely true...i look forward to read more from author...!! :)
@Sami Saayer: Stereotypes are stereotypes for a reason.
What does the author wants to show? This is one of the thousand stories that haunt our society. Why don`t these wealthy burguer class take any practical step. I question would any of these guys marry such poor girls , so that they could ameliorate the filthy conditions? Be practical take steps........
worth reading !! :)
@THE: Take it easy. On basis of just one experiment, can you generalize rest of the workers in prostitution? Why would a prostitute admit that she is doing so in pursuit of quick cash? All will weep of their misery but never tell the truth. If you have even one bit of respect for your body in you, you wont let anyone use it. You will die resisting but will never give in, no matter what the circumstances are. If i tell you that my horse lays eggs, will you believe me or your brains? People cry their lungs out to call for legal cover to 'poor' prostitutes. Amsterdam legalized, made a whole district and the situation got so much out of control that they have started to shut down sex shops and replace them with bookstores.
Id rather not comment on the article itself but gotta say, nice cover photo mate:)
@Eagid : Probbaly Sunny Leone in the lead.
But on a more serious note, human trafficking and prostituion is a major problem in south Asia. I read an article in tribune that 1 million girls are trafficked alone in Pakistan (outflow+infolw) and quite a few of them land up in UAE and other Arab countries.
The ground reality is mostly worst then what's written here! If you don't believe it then do an experiment like the above no your own. The fact of the matter is that when the law enforcement agencies are involved in this business then there is no stopping it besides the fact that this cannot be stopped by force either. The only way we can stop this as a society is to eliminate the middle man, whoever that maybe, in most cases its the Aunty and Uncle.
"I was raped by my own uncle at the age of 17 and then he sold me to Shamim aunty two years ago,” “Actually, my family members read the newspaper and I don’t want them to know what I do,” she told me, hesitantly. Am I missing something here?
Fact or Fiction this article maybe but reality is pretty close!!!!!
Yes, this is something in our society. I have heard of the same things. I hope to read more of your stuff !! keep writing!!
Come on everyone, unfortunately this is something happening in our society...bold style...I love the way everything has been so honestly described...:)
Do not let Mahesh Bhatt read this, or else by next year, there would be a bollywood flick on this story!!
This should be in the Poetic License section! The author must think we are all really stupid...
A good piece of writing, about the girl, yes it happens in our society. girls have to sell her body to feed her youngsters but there is also another angle of the same picture, Girls want to have " a lot" of money and come to this business and then stay here as it is easy to earn money while enjoying at the same time. MONEY MATTERS
Bit of a wishy washy, mambo jambo, gobletegook of a fictional storyline that lacks punch and weight ! I also question the very innocent and elementary motivation that the writer wants us to believe in. Perhaps try interviewing a few of them a few times ;) and I am sure you might come up with something half original :)
dont think its a real story, sorry. pretty much fiction covering all the stereotypes.
Wow, definitely leaves an impression. Wonderfully written! And those who have their doubts, are you really naive enough to believe such situations never occur or that they're not THAT ugly, or do you just wish they weren't true...? Perhaps every story is not so bleak, but too many are. @author: you certainly have a way with words; I hope to read something else by you. Cheers.
One word : Perfect !!
Nabeel, this is something new, i really love the way you used your words to put more details in your story :)
In love with the boldness of writer's style..perfect expressions
writer tried to finish it in haste. I doubt true part of the story is missing.
good work nabeel, proud ov u
..................oooooh to be nineteen again, vaah!!
It is heart-wrenching to hear about such things happening in so-called "Islamic republic of Pakistan".. One wonders is the police sleeping? Then u get the answer they are themselves involved,why would they give a damn about it.
The worst part is, if she does come forward, first of all her family would be the first to denounce and disown her and then society will shun her. We, as a society, don't believe in forgiveness and redemption, especially for women... :/