SHC stays sheep culling till September 27
Ordering suspension of sheep culling till September 27, the SHC Karachi division bench directed authorities to adopt all-out measures for ensuring health and welfare of the animals as well the designated people handling the herd at the farm.
The bench passed this order after partly hearing the arguments advanced by government officers and independent veterinary, pathology and microbiology experts on a petition filed by sheep importer Tariq Mehmood Butt.
Earlier on September 22, the SHC had directed a team of veterinary and microbiology experts to conduct ‘provisional’ tests of the sheep to determine whether the animals were suffering from anthrax or not.
On Monday, Professor Muhammad Rafique Khanani, who headed the testing team, submitted two separate reports dated September 22 and 23 regarding his visit to the farm in pursuance of the court’s order.
Professor Khanani, the Head of Pathology Department at Dow University of Health Sciences, submitted that 19 samples were obtained from 10 suspected sheep from the herd, as examining the entire herd was not possible.
He said that the culling of sheep was stopped as no sheep was found with symptoms of anthrax despite examination including obtaining the temperature of the animals. Moreover, all the samples were found negative for anthrax after the lab tests, he added.
He informed the court that so far 8,000 suspected sheep had been culled by the government authorities and their carcasses were burnt without obtaining samples to determine whether the animals suffered from anthrax or not and the positive results only occur after the infected animal’s death.
Secretary Sindh Livestock and Fisheries Department Syed Abid Ali Shah along with Director Sindh Poultry Vaccination Center Dr Nazir Ahmed Kalhoro contended that anthrax was a highly contagious disease, however, the laboratories in the country lacked equipment to diagnose it.
SHC division bench expressed its displeasure on conduct of Sindh Livestock and Fisheries Department officers for failing to place on record the documents showing as to why the Bahrain authorities refused the shipment of sheep that were accepted by Pakistan.
The bench observed: “This is a very delicate matter. There are two important questions before us; as to under what circumstances and on what basis the subject consignment (of sheep) was refused by the Bahrian and under what terms and conditions the petitioner procured the subject consignment. Both the questions have not yet been answered.”
The court took on record the reports submitted by the expert team and directed the petitioner to provide copies of the same to federal and provincial law officers, who will file comments before the next date of hearing.
Adjourning the hearing till September 27, the SHC bench ordered that culling as stopped on September 22 shall remain suspended till the next date. Till then, all concerned authorities shall take preventive measures to prevent outbreak of any new infection/disease and spread of any present disease/infection, the court maintained.
On the request of petitioner’s counsel Adnan Memon, the court directed the Secretary and Director of Livestock and Fisheries Department to have the present sheep counted carefully in a scientific manner in the presence of the petitioner or his representatives and the proper record shall be kept safe.
The bench also directed the respondents to file their comments along with reports from the laboratories as ordered earlier.
COMMENTS (5)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
1725612926-0/Tribune-Pic-(8)1725612926-0-165x106.webp "article")
They were being contaminated with scabby mouth condition, however these are currently being examined for anthrax? One more epidemic within the producing. I do think the evidence of health and fitness of those sheep can appear from the barbecue bash to get organized at Australian Superior Commission along with the importer, all HC team as well as vets, who examined these sheep feeding on the meat on the sheep. If there are plenty of no displays, the sheep are unwell however, if all of these have fun with the meat, I assume then we need to declare the sheep wholesome.read more details anthrax
I think the proof of health of these sheep can come from a barbecue party to be arranged at Australian High Commission with the importer, all HC staff and the vets, who examined these sheep eating the meat of the sheep. If there are many no shows, the sheep are sick but if all of them enjoy the meat, I guess then we should declare the sheep healthy.
They were infected with scabby mouth disease, yet they are being tested for anthrax? Another epidemic in the making.
Since day one, I suspect that this is organized propaganda against importer by a few politically backed media groups. Ethnic fights are being fought on organized forums. You can see how efficient govt authorities were in culling the 'diseased' sheep.
Is it possible that the sheep importer might have overlooked to a grease a few palms? What a pitiable result for the 8,000 sheep,which may have been destroyed for no justifiable reason at all.