As tensions flared again on Tuesday over the newly-convened commission on new provinces, the government threatened to steamroller ahead with its plans with or without the main opposition Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) while claiming that it had enough consensual support for fulfilling its objectives.
The government scoffed at the PML-N’s move to boycott Tuesday’s maiden meeting of the commission, insisting that the party’s absence made no difference.
“There will be no deadlock even if the PML-N does not participate in the process and if the Punjab Assembly does not nominate its members (for the commission on the creation of new provinces),” Religious Affairs Minister Khursheed Shah, who is also the Pakistan Peoples Party’s (PPP’s) chief whip in the NA, told the media after the session.
Shah dismissed the notion that the opposition had virtually gone unrepresented as a consequence of the PML-N boycott. As proof, Shah cited the name of Senator Ghafoor Haideri of the Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam-Fazl (JUI-F) as being the eyes and ears of the opposition at the inaugural meeting.
The minister, however, pointed out that if there were any misgivings, on the part of the opposition, the PML-N could vote against the commission’s proposals when they come up before the National Assembly in the form of a report.
Additionally, Shah pointed out that the commission’s members had been tasked with convincing the PML-N to participate in the process.
When asked whether the commission would manage to finish the task of carving out provinces, Shah said: “The next assembly will do the job if it is not done now.”
The minister rejected outright the PML-N’s objections on the composition of the commission. “If the commission is renamed following objections of the PML-N, then every single standing committee will meet the same fate.”
Brushing aside PML-N’s allegations that the government had not consulted the opposition over the commission, he said that the leaders of the opposition in the National Assembly and Senate were formally asked for nominations. While Senator Ishaq Dar nominated one member, no response was received from Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan – only after which the speaker nominated opposition members herself. “Rejection of nominations (for the commission) is like disgracing Parliament,” Shah added.
Earlier, nine out of 12 nominated members of the commission attended the session, since all three members from the PML-N – including Senator Rafiq Rajwana, Tehmina Daultana and Saud Majeed – remained conspicuously absent.
During the meeting, Senator Farhatullah Babar, who belongs to Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa, was made chairman of the commission. PPP’s Jamshed Dasti had proposed Babar as chairman and was seconded by other members.
Babar said that the commission had taken two key decisions during the first session. First, the commission will request members of the PML-N to participate in the proceedings. Second, the commission will meet again today (Wednesday) for framing and adopting draft rules to increase efficiency.
Babar made it clear that the commission was mandated with compiling a report on the creation of new provinces in Punjab only, since no other province had made such a request. “This proposal (the passage of two resolutions) has come from Punjab itself; therefore, the work of the commission is limited to this province alone,” he added.
When asked why the commission’s members did not only consist of representatives from Punjab in this case, Babar said, “When you talk about creating a new province, it requires amending the Constitution. And the amendment of the Constitution cannot be handed over to any one province or political party.”
The commission was constituted by the National Assembly speaker on the directions of President Asif Ali Zardari to act upon resolutions passed by the lower house of parliament and the Punjab Assembly calling for a new ‘Janoobi Punjab’ (South Punjab) province and the revival of Bahawalpur’s status as a province.
Published in The Express Tribune, August 29th, 2012.
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
All these are delaying tactics of PML-N. It was never willing to cede the rights of Southern Punjab and therefore coming up with lame excuses. Saraiki Province is the demand of People suffering since inception of Pakistan. Punjab Government never bothered to launch a single development project in Southern Punjab for the welfare of the people. The plight of people in Southern Punjab makes one believe that these areas were treated as step mothers. Rather than mulling over the rationale demand of the people PML-N is riding on anti-PPP move. Mian Nawaz Sharif has also formed a party committee related to the demand for new provinces. While this may be a political gimmick for the mainstream political parties, the truth is that the idea of more provinces in Pakistan is indeed a good one.
@nomi: There is no such thing as a northern punjabi or southern punjabi these terms have been coined after 2008. Law and order is a nation wide problem but it is most likely better in Lahore, Rawalpindi or Multan than Quetta, Karachi or Peshawar. Brush up on your history the nawabs of Punjab are a thing of the Past. Punjab is a much more egalitarian province together with KP than the Provinces in the South. The exception being Pirs and Sardars who are trying to buy time by creating a nonsensical notion of Southern Punjabi. By all means create new provinces throughout the land but spare these fantasies about a shared northern or southern punjabi identity!
@nomi: If provinces are required, a "uniform criteria" has to be identified and then applied all over pakistan for the creation of provinces. This applies even to KPK, Balochistan and Sindh. If punjab division is required, we very well need a province for Karachi, one for Hyderabad, one for Hazara and ofcourse apply the "uniform criteria" all over pakistan.
Now ANP and MQM have members on commission while they have not a single councillor in punjab. It is just hateful agenda of people who are responsible for the mess in Sindh, NWFP.
I hope Punjabis at least once take stand for themselves and leave this pakistani nationalism mantra.
I would request you to come back from mars as you are having problems in seeing the whats happening in Punjab.
Feudalism in northern punjab was always there. Characters like Nawab of Kalabagh are a plenty.
Northern Punjab has a horrible law and order situation. Chaudhries of Gujrat left Punjab in a better state.
There is no work at the grass root level. No local government and Mians love to keep power in Lahore. Going outside lahore, one might be deluded into believing that one is in an african country.
And now South Punjab, it is not even considered seriously as northern punjabis consider GT road cities a complete Pakistan.
The problem is economic justice and whoever identifies it, is labelled a traitor. Northern Punjabi arrogance has turned this simple problem in a fiery ethnic issue.
So the die is cast - take the only stable and developing province and try to make it instable and backward. This is all a political ploy to weaken the Punjab. Central and Northern Punjab have been developing and growing well despite no support from the federal government. For the most part, there is no feudalism in either North or Central Punjab whereas the southern part of the province there is some degree of it - similar to Sind and Baluchistan. By creating a feudal south Punjab, all it seems is that the nation will get a backward province instead of letting the region develop along with the rest of the Punjab. And by the way, I do not live in the Punjab but I admire how it has remained relatively stable despite the turmoil in the rest of the nation