Unchanged order

In a village near Chakwal in Punjab, a couple was murdered for marrying of their own free will.

Editorial August 26, 2012

We may as well be living in a different time and age. It seems that life has not moved forward at all. We continue to carry out acts so gory it is hard to believe that human beings in this day and age would be capable of even considering them.

The latest such incident has taken place in a village near Chakwal in Punjab, where a couple was murdered for marrying of their own free will. In our country, many such stories have been heard of before. In this case, Almas Khan, an employee of Mazhar Hussain, eloped with his employer’s daughter Shamim Akhter and fled to Khan’s native Nowshera. Clearly, differences in class, perceived ‘status’ and Khan’s situation as a servant in the house left them convinced they would never get the consent of Shamim’s parents to marry. A kidnapping case was lodged against Khan. However, before anything came of it, the couple was lured back to Chakwal on Eidul Fitr on the pretext that they had been forgiven and then murdered. Sole responsibility for this act has been claimed by Shamim’s brother.

Courts have, of course, given repeated rulings permitting adults free choice in marriage. A landmark judgment in this respect came in the 1990s from the Supreme Court. But more than a decade on, people remain unwilling to accept such rulings. Further complications stem from the Qisas and Diyat laws, which allow the heirs of a victim to accept blood money rather than seek punishment for murder. This factor explains why, in the case of women killed for ‘honour’, their brothers so often take the blame, permitting fathers to accept a ‘payment’ to compensate for physical hurt. The money never actually changes hands, allowing the perpetrators of the crime to, in fact, go scot free. As human rights groups have pointed out, this flaw needs to be plugged. But we also need a change in social attitudes so that such incidents do not occur and the kind of tragedy that was witnessed in Chakwal can be averted.

Published in The Express Tribune, August 27th, 2012.


Reza Mahmud | 9 years ago | Reply

Prevalence of law and order is the only solution. A fear of accountability is need to be ensured! I rest my case.

V. C. Bhutani | 9 years ago | Reply

It is hopeless to think that anyone will give a damn about what I am about to submit for the consideration of my brethren on the other side of the Radcliffe Line. Events of this kind have been happening with disconcerting frequency in Pakistan in recent times. No one batted an eyelid. At the outset, I make bold to say that the entire Pakistan society needs to hang its heads in shame at these events. Ideas of 'honour', with which I am familiar in India - Haryana, you know! - that's no cause for extenuation. Pakistan's laws need to be updated and brought in line with modern laws and ideas. Will that happen? Of course, not. Pakistan and Pakistanis will continue to wallow in their fond ideas of honour.

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ


Most Read