Clash of institutions

The stand-off between the Supreme Court and the government could threaten our system of checks and balances.


Editorial July 05, 2012

The stand-off between the Supreme Court and the government could threaten our system of checks and balances. Shaken by the corruption allegations against Chief Justice Iftikhar Chaudhry’s son Arsalan Chuadhry and finally finding itself in the crossfire after years of popularity, the Supreme Court has essentially declared itself beyond the purview of financial accountability. Some would say that by claiming that the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) cannot probe the conduct of judges, including whether they were given additional plots of land, the Supreme Court has elevated itself above those that it judges.

Having been stung by Yousaf Raza Gilani’s disqualification by the Supreme Court and with his replacement, Raja Pervaiz Ashraf facing the same threat, the PPP is on course to pass a law exempting government officials from charges of contempt of court. The PPP may be using standard legislative powers to protect itself but the end result is likely to be as hurtful for the separation of powers and can lead to a further clash between institutions. Even if the Supreme Court, in the judgment of the government, had overreached by charging Mr Gilani with contempt, to pass a law based on that would be a folly. Recall that in 1997, the Nawaz Sharif government wanted to pass an almost identical law to reign in the Supreme Court, when Sajjad Ali Shah was chief justice. Sharif’s supporters then went on to raid the Supreme Court, an act that certainly qualifies as contempt and should have been severely punished. The PPP, blinded by its own narrow interests, seems not to have realised that.

The fact is that every institution needs to be kept in check by other independent government institutions. The PPP has already submitted itself to the mercy of the Supreme Court in the case of Mr Gilani. One can only hope that further confrontation between the executive and judiciary does not take place.

Published in The Express Tribune, July 6th, 2012.

COMMENTS (6)

Abdullah | 11 years ago | Reply

Curse of democracy and secularism where rule of the people, by the people for the people give absolute legislative power to the parliament who is supreme. They legislate wrong right and right wrong. Then this stupid game of balance of power get played out from which public never benefit.

what is needed is that our establishment seriously consider the ruling system given by Islam - the Khilafah. the sovereignty belong to Allah swt and authority belongs to people to elect those who implement Allah's deen on earth.

Javaid R. Shami | 11 years ago | Reply

But who will keep the judiciary under control and prevent it from over-reaching?

VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ