Behind the scenes footage showing Dunya News anchors Mubashir Lucman and Meher Bokhari talking to Malik Riaz during their show surfaced on YouTube under the title "Malik Riaz Planted Interview with Mehar Bokhari and Mubashir Lukman on dunya tv" on Thursday. The show aired on the TV channel on Wednesday.
The footage shows conversations between Lucman, Bokhari and Riaz focused on the kind of questions they will be asking. Both anchors are also instructed against interrupting Riaz during the interview.
Bokhari is heard saying a question is planted towards the end of the video.
“Say what you want… what question should we ask. It will appear as though it is planted… it is, but it shouldn’t appear it is.”
The video begins with general conversation and is followed by Riaz questioning the anchors on why they are not asking why he is part of “deals”.
Lucman is then seen on the phone asking if the interview is going fine and defending himself by saying Riaz is being given a chance.
Who is he speaking to? Abdul Qadir Gilani, he says.
The anchor tells “Gilani” that he wants to clear his name from taking money and he wants to talk about Hamid Mir’s allegations, but Riaz isn’t letting him take his name. “No, no,” says the business tycoon in response to that.
Riaz then asks “Gilani” to pray for him.
In between Lucman’s smoke break, Bokhari turns to Riaz to discuss what they will ask next. A brief discussion and a “khul kay poochain”, Meher says that they will discuss journalists at the end of the show, so as to “clear her name” at least.
Lucman tells Riaz, “Today I will ask you to give me in front of everyone. Give me a villa like you gave Hamid”. “No, no,” is Riaz’s response once again, followed by a “why not” from Lucman.
Yet another break later, both anchors and Riaz are once again seen talking about what the next discussion will be.
Riaz once again mentions that he wants them to ask why he is in every deal, and is told by Bokhari that she is not interested in asking that question, but is in return told that he wants to go back to it. “So go back,” says Lucman.
Riaz is seen occasionally choosing topics of his choice, focusing on the chief justice as well. He is also visibly upset during one part of the video, where he says that most of his questions are left and the work isn’t done.
Smoke breaks, thumbs up from both anchors, a high five and questions of how the show is going so far are also seen during the video.
Little arguments between both anchors are also regularly seen during the video, mostly on order of asking questions and the time each has to take.
Lucman also tells Riaz that he will ask a “conspiracy theory” question that he wanted to become the prime minister.
He tells Riaz that he will not answer the question before 10, as this will make people wait for it otherwise they won’t come back to the show.
In another interesting revelation, Riaz states that he does not eat roti, chawal or meetha, and will eat an egg or chicken. Lucman asks Bokhari to get barbecue instead.
Riaz is not to be interrupted
The second part of the video has strict instructions coming in for both Lucman and Bokhari that Riaz is not to be interrupted.
Both anchors give their assurance that they will not be interrupting the businessman now. Lucman also tells someone off camera that they should not be pressurising them for a break, and says that they will go over time if they have to.
Lucman then asks Riaz to give him a “dhamaka”, and is promised that he will get one on the next show.
Bokhari also delivers a message from Maryam Nawaz that a car had been offered to them but they had declined it after saying thank you.
During this talk, a muffled off screen voice says something and Riaz tells the female to stay quiet.
The second part also sees both anchors getting into a little tiff over camera time. Bokhari calls Lucman childish, who takes his mic off and leaves.
Riaz appears desperate when Lucman walks off, asking him to come back, saying it will be unfair for him.
An angry Lucman returns and tells Riaz that he will say live on air that he was pressurised into doing the show by him and Mian Amir.
Riaz continues trying to reconcile between the two during all of this.
He then begs both anchors and says that the program will be spoilt and that his life is at stake. Lucman then tells Riaz that he will say that he had gone to meet the man who also had documents to show against Dr Arsalan Iftikhar.
A video close to 26 minutes will now just add to the only dangerously brewing storm that has a member of the judiciary linked to it.
COMMENTS (98)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
It is not the messenger but the saboteur. Unable to compete this was a cheap way of shaking a channel and the two outspoken journalists. Both are the darling of the audience. I dont agree with them most of the time but does not mean to put muck on them this way. Shame on NewsOne. It was framing. It was unethical it was off the record. When Zulfiqar Ali Bhuttos profanity went on air accidentally did he not say cut it, off the record. Off the record cannot become part of the record.
@Syed Shah:
Shooting the messenger Shah Sb?
A casual informal talk in good humor should not have been used to put muck on these great daring journalists. Sad that competing but failed media guys third raters are trying to capitalize on. Both are good journalists and nothing should stick of competing channels. News One must be charged for mal practices. They pay money to small technicians to make a video like this and then put it on air. Shame on News One. I will not accuse these two great anchors of any wrong doing.
Is any in Pakistan to whom we say he is honest, gentle and at least honest with his profession. There is monopoly in every where how the Pakistan will improve.
We need strong Danda with justice to settle every things.
You tube is removing the video`s claiming Copy Right issues. The scum bags have just started the clearing operations by removing everything from social media. I think people should start downloading it and uploading time and again on facebook, youtube and and other websites..
This is tip of the iceberg, the roots of some so-called anchors are extremely deep in mess.. thier links to security establishment would be worth watching, if ever they come up
Well all i can say is from a bollywood underworld movie " SAB DHANDHA HAI PER GANDA HAI YEH " lolz ... we all support CJ way to go
The one who released the video is the truest patriotic paki. May Allah bless him. The whole nation eyes are now open with this one video about this evil people!
Watching the video made my blood boil. The media's have made us fools. Laanat.
Majority of media manipulate the news. They dont report rather they bend the facts
Never really liked or trusted Mubashar Lucman. Everyone who is anyone in Pakistan seems to have their fingers in the pie.
Shame on them, Every day they talk about about truth and sincerity .........and dont see himself..........
After watching the clips now i dont have any more trust on any political show or anchor, but its not fair,we can't deny the efforts of those who are really working for "truth".and Talat hussain among of those.Now this is a time Pakistani should awake and differtshiate b/w right and wrong.if we want Pakistan back.
just wanted to say thanks to whoever leaked this , might ve cost him or her their job but was worth it . we need more people like you.
@Alladin: Actually there is please watch 3rd part :)
Money, Money, Money ,,,,,,,, greed of money , the root of all evils. The same happens in other countries also and same logic (every 1 wants more money).
Ever since the media got its independence people attached with it used their status to blackmail government functionaries or to court politicians for monetary gains and other ulterior motives. What is transpiring in this media gate is shameful for any honest professional. The malaise is widespread and afflicting all whether a reporter of a local newspaper in a small town or the more renowned anchors of big media houses. Now is the time to put stringent checks on wayward behaviour of journalists. All segments of society should be held accountable for their mischiefs.
Now it is quite clear, Never ever trust anyone
This is the outcome of what we call FREE MEDIA. Every thing and every one in media is for sale, you just need to know the price.
Its better to stop watching channel like DUNYA .These media men are the Black mailers of the highest order.Living a lavish life style...hardly anyone,who is unbiased..media and the nation rise and fall together.Its better to watch some light programs...like bulbulay,cartoons,music and religious programs..
The things are going in the right direction.............ie INQALAB.
@Alladin: You must be deaf if you didn't hear Luqman taking Abdul Qadir's name ! Infact,he hands the phone to that despicable Malik Riaz and says ,TWICE, Abdul Qadir ....Abdul Qadir Gillani ! And Malik Riaz calls him by his pet name " BUNNY JI ". Boy ,you really couldn't hear that !!!!! UNBELIEVABLE .....
Good job by a insider to help Pakistan separate truth from smoke and lies. I salute the one who risked his job in Dunya news to help Nation see the truth in latest attack on Judicial system to make it a pocket watch like it was before 2007.
Also, Malik Riaz and Gelani company are fully exposed now and need to pack up as they will not be able to buy justice for them on their terms.
Will ET do similar article about Javed Ch or any other Express Anchor's video gets caught?
I guess not.
"Sadly in Pakistan today any thing can be bought from people to institutions, everything everyone has a price tag you just have to able to afford it"
Isnt it a case of conspiracy against the judiciary, the CJ and his son? Luqman, Bukhari, MR & Co. The real video evidence is out there now. I hope the CJ takes a suo moto on this now and has this corrupt black mailer media system rolled up.
Those who prepared the plan simply were not thinking that when you are going to target the top judge, you must know that it would not be a cut and dry affair. Were they too simpleton to think that allegations against the son would force the hand of the chief justice and nobody else would be involved. The plan was to put the highest on the back foot, but it's the media that has bared its greedy soul. There is still time to back off and leave the top judge alone!
Mubashar Luqman is a greedy man not a jurnalist. Malik Riaz ka" BAQAOO" mall ................ Shame,shame,shame Mubashar,Mehar & Malik Riaz.
No trust any more in Anchor persons. All programme already are pre decided in Pkaistan.
PTI guys should now believe in laptops transparency :) this had to happen.
Wow I had so much respect for ML ..... Who you trust in Pakistan. One time I met him and I said " I am so proud of you Mubashir " ... So here goes down my respect for him.
@Nadir: Why is it quite necessary to drag in or charge the army for everything? FOR GOD SAKE .
Wellll i use to like u ....but after seeing wht u did iz shameless....n nw ur covering it but i dunt belive on this n it ws....planted shameee on u
http://www.valuewalk.com/2012/06/a-leaked-tv-show-video-leave-questions-on-pakistans-media-credibility/ - also covered in INTL media.
Meher Bukhari should act as a host, rather than a stock broker. If you are inviting a person to talk than let him/her talk.
I wonder how much money had been paid to the person who leaked this video online!
The true picture of our media can be seen in this video. Hats-off to Talat Hussain for predicting all this, these stunts will add to the media's black holes.
that's going to make his case a whole lot weak..
It honestly was not that bad. I have seen a few other behind the scenes video's from other talk shows and this is what they were like. Malik Riaz is friends with most media persons and I am not surprised.
Although I am shocked by how immature and un-professional Lucman was.
Real Face of OUR Talk shows
It couldnt have been scripted better if a writer wrote this show! Its one of the most entertaining things I have seen! If you know a little of background it becomes riveting viewing! Funny, sad, raises moral and ethical issues and shows media satirising itself! AN oscar winner indeed!
Yes yes, Malik Riaz indeed has them in his bag! These media goons are not to b ever trusted again.
I am surprized at people who are defending this video. Never ever a private business tycoon got 2 hours of prime time interview..The calls from gillani's son, and every thing else..Yet still we have people who are defending these two journalists? I mean realy we all pakistanis deserve to be here..we deserve much worse than this actually.
Removed from front page. Why?
@Bilal:
Yes may be, but this video speaks truth itself.
“Journalism is printing what someone else does not want printed. Everything else is public relations.” - George Orwell
ET why this news is taken off from front page? As usual my comments not being publish :)
Now getting reports that @MubasherLucman has been suspended for ‘off-air’ comments: Source.Mubashir Luqman has been Fired from Duniya TV After Malik Riaz Interview Leaked http://najamsethiaapaskibaat.wordpress.com/2012/06/14/mubashir-luqman-has-been-fired-from-duniya-tv-after-malik-riaz-interview-leaked/
i think that it is the normal practice that each and every detail is decided before hand or you can say planted before hand. he is a business tycoon and a big man so he got extra special treatment. nothing else. why this video got out or leaked out or something that's the question i want to ask.
Problem is with us 'common people'. Why do we expect so much and consider these anchors 'Patriots'. They are simply doing their job and selling their 'words' just like actors do their best to make their drama a hit. Its a fake glamorous world of media full of disguise. We must not expect too much from either military or judiciary or politicians or businessmen or media men as 'Villains' and 'Corrupt' exist everywhere. Even if we perform a clean up operation, 1% germs would still be left as you see in 'Safeguard' soap ad. :P
Why video has been removed? is ET getting threats from big media persons or ET was just getting clicks for his news page. Also link has been removed from home page of ET. Shame.
@Hafiz: And what is good about these two anchors?? Yes they lie very well and are as corrupt as the people they preach against
Now come to know why Musharraf wanted to regulate the media.
This is not something new. Those who were shocked by looking at it, i must say, are the fools because this what happens in every talk show. A detailed off-record conversation are being done between anchors and guest before every talk show in which anchors are informed what to ask and what not. In short these so-called live shows are followed with a proper script. :)
What is the credibility of the MD,EXECUTIVE of the DUNIYANEWS. These channles are playing with the whole nations and must be shut down.
Is it the only TV show that has been "planted" by any channel? Is it ban on discussing during the break as how should the program move further by the participants? Who made an ordinary mortal a demigod and imposed on the poor nation whose issues are different from the hifi litigation going on in the Superior Court? Have a mercy on poor people of Pakistan.
Did someone hear this or this is just imagination of Mr Popalzai? I watched this clip several times but could not hear anyone of three mentioning Qadir Gilani's name
Everything is planned. It's meant to be.
Both of these anchors should be fired; shame on them
Wait!! Govt, Establishment, Judiciary and now Media. Whats going on. Any institution left for corruption?
Even if the video is meaningful, the Malik Riaz's three questions and his accusation that the Chief Justice knew about Arsalan Iftikhar's activities for a long time and did not do anything, are still valid. Barrister Aitzaz Ahsan has also confirmed that he had informed the Chief Justice a few months ago, but he took the suo moto action only after the news had broken on the media. Unfortunately, Malik Riaz 's shady dealings and reckless undertakings are not helping Arsalan Iftikhar or the Chief Justice. I pray the Chief Justice come out clean on merit.
Hats off to one who release this video. Great job.
True example of 'Yellow' journalism.
M. R@fique Zakaria Karachi
suo-moto action ??
I believe any person who is very successful in the field of media is a part of such activity.to me personaly lier and journalist mean the same
Seriously?
You guys never knew what happens behind the camera? It's the regular and common happenings behind the live shows. Every of the shows you watch are scripted and planted just like you watched this above. Each question and the answers are discussed behind the camera.
The loud arguments you watch in the live talk show are also scripted and directed very much like a TV serial.
If you are surprised watching these scenes then I am even surprised to see you guys wondering like this.
PML-N on one hand produced evidences against riaz.. but i think in the show riaz bought them back by giving a statement of their (PML-N) choice """a car was offered to Hamza and he rejected""
It is war between media groups, Express and Geo Tvs are on one side rest all are on the other. Luqman and Mehar are very good anchors indeed..
After watching this video, I can only say that Mr. Riaz is not a businesman but stupidman.
Good to see this unmasking and truth unfolding.
Shame, shame, shame. I will never be able to defend myself as a journalist after this episode :(
All those who take people for their joy ride must be exposed. Our elite including media believes that people are stupid and so it can get away with anything. These clips are abridged summary of dirty nexus between corrupt PPP govt, media and Malik Riaz phenomenon. Shame on all of them and its good for people of Pakistan; they could get better insight of pervasive hypocrisy shamelessly practised by the predatory elite.
Pakistan media has become a joke it seems. Highly unprofessional of Duniya TV.
Always the questions are known to the guest, before an interview.
So now Media corruption is appearing. My God why in Pakistan Electronic media is so corrupt. I stick to Print media now further. I feel most of Tv show in Pakistan is planted and alreday decided what to asked?
I wonder which country we are living in. there are more like mubashir and meher in the media industry, and all of these anchors start their performances from 7:00 pm evening till 12:00 am midnight. almost on all T.V channels depicting their loyalty to their paymasters.
And the Army is in business with this guy? DHA Islamabad is being developed by Malik Riaz, parts of DHA are marketed as Bahria Town and people have the audacity to call him a role model, and all the decisions the Army takes remain beyond accountability. Pathetic
A "DUNDA" is needed for such Journalists also
Is this News ? huhhhhhh Every TV show is pre-planned either in favour or against judiciary
that's sums up the myth of free journalisim. wonder how else is not sellable in this open market?
so? all media is corrupt including ET
Lemme guess ..... there will be another denial and a claim that this video has been dubed like Amir Liaqat.
shut up call for every one who s against CJ.U cant hide truth shame on lucman and so many others who daily gave us lecture
And the Pandora box opens
Popcorn anyone.........