After dancing rituals became the centre of controversy in Kohistan, the performers’ community of Banr seems to be taking a share of the spotlight. The community, which depends solely on singing and dancing for a living, has been banned by the police from performing the cultural activities in the district.
Ironically, the news comes as efforts are underway by the Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa (K-P) government to give Banr the status of a “cultural industry”.
The ban has upset the locals who would perform in houses and hujras to entertain people, said Javed Iqbal, a local singer. “We get Rs200 to Rs400 for a single music and dance performance, which is our sole source of income. If these things are stopped we will have no other option but to beg or commit suicide,” he lamented.
Another artist, Gul Wadood, who lay sick in his bed, was perturbed over the matter. “The police have besieged us in our homes,” he said. Wadood added that as a single concert earns for up to 10 families, banning such performances will render his community homeless.
The artist said that under the government of the last ruler of Swat, locals had the freedom to perform their crafts. He said that a high court legalised the activities in 1977 by giving a verdict in their favour. “However, the Taliban came and not only banned the practice but also punished those involved in it; and now the police are doing the same,” he added.
“We had guests over when the police raided our place. They disgraced our families and took us to the police station where they beat us and warned of dire consequences if we continue performing music and dance, said a wounded Mushtaq. “They tell us to sell tomato in the Grain Square instead,” he added.
The community members claim that the police have threatened to shave their women’s heads if they violate the ban. “This is exactly what the Taliban did during their regime,” added another artist, requesting anonymity.
“We are starving and have nothing to eat; if the government wants to ban our profession, it should provide us an alternate means of earning livelihood,” said Dilawar. “Unfortunately, the police are only harassing the poor community and letting the rich get away,” he added.
A performing artist, holding her medical reports and medicines, said she has to buy medicines worth Rs300 and pay Rs6,000 house rent every month. “How should I make ends meet with a ban on our profession?” she questioned. She said the government should present a solution before banning us from singing and dancing.
With similar woes, an old Rahat said that as four of her sons have died of a “mysterious” disease, her daughter supported the family through singing. She appealed to the prime minister, K-P chief minister and the Supreme Court to allow them to practice their profession.
Svastu Arts and Cultural Association Chairman Usman Ulas Yar said, “instead of banishing cultural activities, the police should improve their performance. Music and dance is part of the Pakhtun culture and peace can never prevail without them,” he said.
When contacted, Deputy Superintendant of Police Mingora Amjad Ali Khan said that they have implemented restrictions on logical grounds over cultural activities which lead towards criminal lines. Then he got furious and hung up.
Published In The Express Tribune, June 7th, 2012.
COMMENTS (13)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@China: Music and dance comes under cultural sector and there is complete freedom for cultural activities. and the profession enjoys complete freedom under Pakistani constitution. if you are so much interested then challenge the musicians in court
@ Jamal: The issue we are talking about is not constitution and law, we are talking about that it is forbidden in Islam but now that you have triggered the constitution and law, so let me tell you my friend that it is clearly written in the constitution that The Constitution of Islamic Republic of Pakistan that 1.Islam is declared as the state religion of Pakistan. 2. All existing laws shall be brought in conformity with the injunctions of Islam as laid down in the Qur'an and Sunnah and no law shall be enacted which is repugnant to such injunctions. 3. Steps shall be taken to enable the Muslims of Pakistan, individually or collectively, to order their lives in accordance with the fundamental principles and basic concepts of Islam. 4. Pakistan is a democratic State based on Islamic principles.
@ Nazir Hussain: Its not whether i mind or not, the thing is these things are against Islam, prohibited in Islam. A Muslim is the one when he says kalma then HE SURRENDERS HIMSELF TO THE WILL OF ALLAH, so why do people do things against the will of Allah. Talking about poor people earning there bread, there are many other ways to earn there bread rather then dancing and singing. if poor people are selling drugs and are involved in smuggling earning there bread than do you think it is right that they should continue doing it and the police should allow them doing it and tell them " oh please continue with your drugs and smuggling cause you are poor and earning your bread"? My friend there are many people who were poor and they struggled, worked hard on the right path and they are well off now, they did not sing or dance.
@China: You do not mind if Allama Iqbal wrote poems and Noorjehan sings them, but when poor people sing for earning their daily bread, Islam will not accept this. These double standards are in our blood. Even Saudi Arabia where Islam born never do such nasty things.
No, The thing is, these activities are prohibited in Islam, so that's why he banned such activities, so who ever is supporting this kind of activity, then i dare them, why don't you and your family start this business? You wont do it because it is against Islamic law and values. one should respect religion rather than going in the against Islam. Stop using Taliban, Taliban, come on we all know they are long gone and they did not represent Islam truly, they were violent, they were criminals using the name of Islam, these are facts my friend.
Policegardi.....
What else can be expected from Us? Dear Fazal, We are living among in such a suffocated society, where everything is in the hands of mulla and military.
This is a centiries old profession in the region, the idea of banning cultural practices in the name of religion or morality came with Taliban in the area and is a fairly new phenomenon. Police needs to protect the traditional cultural practitioners rather rhan harrassing and beating them, they are not involved in any illegal practice. These police officers need to be reprimanded for harrassing people.
Dont blame the police. I have met the people from this region. Most of them are ultra Orthodox and they force the police and then police have to act. It is a general mindset like that and it would take years to change. Dont blame Taliban or Police. When some extremist group have a local backing then they act otherwise they dont. So if Society there will change then extremism will die out automatically.
This is called police extremism
Actually the DSP belongs to Charbagh which remained a stronghold of Taliban so the DSP has the same impacts on his mind. the SHO of the Banr police station is Talib himself. the KP government and Federal government must take strict action against the police as they are going towards religious extremism
Taliban, religious superstitious backward tribal mentality and intolerance has infiltrated most Pakistani minds and institutions, unfortunately.