A caricature of JUI-F leader Maulana Fazlur Rehman, drawn by fine arts students in an exhibition at the Nishtar Hall in Peshawar, was pulled off the wall and removed from display. It showed the leader stepping out from a lamp and this was apparently offensive to some political leaders. At least, one other caricature was removed for similar reasons. The young artists involved, including the girls, who projected the Maulana the way they saw him have expressed disappointment and said they are upset by the removal of their canvases. The action taken hardly goes to encourage artistic expression. Indeed, curbing expression amounts to a form of unacceptable censorship of opinion and goes against the basic grain of human rights as protected in our land.
More seriously, it exhibits a diminishing sense of tolerance. A nation that is not able to laugh at its flaws cannot be expected to progress. Satirical shows which have depicted figures ranging from the Queen of England to prime ministers have been popular television hits in many nations. The fact that we cannot accept a drawing of a political figure shows the kind of intolerance that is breeding in our country. Somehow, we need to rediscover this lost sense of humour and use it to our advantage in these difficult times. Caricatures, cartoons and drawings can often say more than words. They create awareness of the realities and highlight the perception of the people. Those concerned should draw on the positives instead of curbing the right to expression.
Published in The Express Tribune, May 18th, 2012.
COMMENTS (10)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@John B:
The other cartoon was about a Prophet so please don't mix a cartoon of a politician with that of a Prophet.
we have a similar situation in our country. a cartoon made in 1949 on jawahrlal nehru and b r ambedkar on the slow process of constitution making has raised the heckles of all politicians of all parties here. and mind you both nehru and ambedkar had no objection to them being cartooned.
politicians globally seem to be good only at fanning differences, corruption, crimes and ruining the economy.
Guys,try to understand,the pic was ordered to be removed by a Govt Officer who was incharge of the Hall.The theme of the exhib was "Tolerance and Peace" and having picture of an open taliban supporter who's own beliefs go tootally against what the exhibition was all about "Tolerance and Peace" was to say the least,a wrong idea! The city of Peshawar has suffered the taliban wrath more than any other city has,and the students also need to have a vision and why paint this extremist??..We need to condemn the taliban and all their supoporters amongst us,through our art,music,literature and acts,if we want to do away with them that is !
yes...get rid of the mullahs and the rightists....they are the main problem of pakistan. remove them and pakistan progresses.
When western media depicts cartoons, we find them despicable. When students air caricatures on our leaders, we find these offensive. More often it is the corrupt religious right that finds offense. But they don't find personal corruption as offensive. Should we not get rid of the religious right all together?? Where have the Pakistani Left, the Socialists and the Communists disappeared. They should mount the ramparts against these Mad Mullahs and free the soul. We want freedom of thought and the freedom to express it!!!!
Where was this sense of humor when THE OTHER Catoon was published.?
It's shocking to not that act by the authorities. He's a politician and he should face the criticism like others.
It's a shameful act to remove that cartoon. If he's a politician then he has to accept this criticisim and humour. He's not a prophet or God that we can't make fun of him.
Sad, but not happening for the first time. We take offense at anything and everything.