Fact: an illiterate village family weds its daughter when she reaches puberty. Therefore, the average village woman is married at not later than 15 years, the groom being a couple of years older. (Though things have changed, this was the norm until about 30 years ago). The couple parents their first child before they reach their 20th birthdays.
By the time they are 30, they are grandparents. Consequently, if anyone claims to be 130 years old, they have to show us a line extending through at least seven or eight generations. But these false claimants can only show a couple of great-grandchildren. What’s more, they also have an eldest child only in their 60s. That is, these century-and-a-half-year-old persons married and produced children when they were in their 90s!
Here’s how it occurs.
Back in 1988, PTV aired the interview of an octogenarian who said he was 144 years old. Proof of longevity: he said he knew so much about Ranjit Singh’s time. Indeed, he did narrate a few details of the Maharaja’s death and funeral to the utter astonishment of the ignorant interviewer. Note that the Maharaja died in 1839 and by his own reckoning the man was not born until 1844! But our electronic media persons are hardly notable for their erudition and gumption.
Similarly, in 1997, up in Hunza where the moronic British invented the myth of longevity which was gobbled hook, line and stinker (no pun) by simple people, a man said his grandmother had died at age 150. His father –– who I also met –– was, incidentally, only in his early 50s. It was confirmed that he was the eldest child of his supposedly 150-year-old mother. Proof of longevity: grandma remembered everything about the time of Mir Safdar Ali (ousted by the Brits in the 1890s).
Aside: a 1990s research by IUCN shows that until very recently, Hunza and Gojal women were married not later than their 15th year of age. This has only changed now because of the education programme of the Aga Khan Foundation.
I was researching Alexander the Macedonian in those days and sometimes felt I personally knew the man. I asked if that meant I was 2,200 years old. This was the only time in my life that I saw an angry Hunza man.
Even more recently, in the village Allahabad (Rahim Yar Khan), a local journalist took me to meet a 125-year-old man. This chap had interviewed the oldie and published it in an Urdu paper. I asked the man (another octogenarian) his age and he said ‘Paintali!’ (45).
I thought the old man was off his rocker and asked again. ‘Ik so paintali!’ he said the second time. Now, in July 2007, when he was interviewed by my journalist friend he was 125. In November the same year when I met him he was 145! That, then, is how we attain longevity. Incidentally, his eldest son (another angry man when I did my sums for them) was about 60.
Two things here. For one, illiterate people have little concept of time and space. I have known in my time of people who count two years from one winter (or summer) to the next. Secondly, they believe they ate pure and good. I ask you, what great and healthful diet can a poor man maintain?
The 145-year-old man had owned only an acre of land and barely made a living off it. The food in his youth was sparse: millet bread, some buttermilk and occasionally, some veggies. He had ten children and had worn himself out by the time he was 50 –– which, in his reckoning, was a 100 years.
If these fogies want a man of good sense to believe, then they have to produce certificates. Other than that, it is all balderdash.
Published in The Express Tribune, March 24th, 2012.
COMMENTS (10)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
I think I may not be wrong in disagreeing with Salman Rashid as the perception developed by the authors in the past about longevity in Hunza was not a myth but a fact however it may not stand valid today due to food adulteration, inactivity, polution and so many other reasons. People in the past used to have organic food and strong physical activity with healthy habits like 'early to bed and early to rise' and no worries and tensions of modern day life which surely were the reasons of their logevity. I have a living example to quote of my maternal grand father who has crossed the century of his life and still is in good health.
Hunza Longevity isn't totally a myth , some research support this clam ,on visiting Hunza you can easily find one person between 90s-100 in each family. or just attain a social gathering , in Hunza a special decorum is observed for group in their 80s and 90s!
The Hunza longevity myth has gone on for too long. The people who wrote up that sort of stuff clearly had neither commonsense nor the ability to spot patent illogicalities! Thanks for an excellent piece!
@Parvez
A good one.Can be a subject of psycho analysis of aspiration and self worth of rich and poor.
Poor people who are 60 claim to be 130 while rich people who are 80 claim to be 50, both for the same reason. An interesting and amusing read.
@Arifq: "Myth buster"!----he has got a lot of 'myths' here to bust and that might help us become a bit better informed and a little more realistic about ourselves. Salman Sahib, please help us the ignorant folks a vast majourity here in this sea of 180 millions.
Salman Rashid, educator, philosopher, archeaologists and now myth buster. I always read and enjoy your writings, many thanks.
Dear Salman
there was a news item 30 years back which claimed a Pakistani man being 150 years old. Later on it was checked and found that he was just 75 yeras old. Confusion between saka era and christian calender, which I guess are having a time gap of 75 years was given the reason.
Many of the dates recorded in pre-partion pakistan are from saka era. They get confused by Christian calender used right now. Guess that could be an explanation.
Nice little snippet of Pakistani culture. I myself have come across several domestic servants claiming to have grandmothers who should by all means have been recognised by the Guinness Book of World Records--had their claim actually been true. Although I think that the tone of the article suggested that these false claimants were all lying whereas all this could be chalked down to simple senility, reverence for the elderly in our culture and the lack of records in rural societies--many don't even know when they were born.
Wow, apparently they could make quite a name for themselves and their way of life through the guiness book or world records. There would be no short of funding into the research of lifestyles resulting in living that long.