Manufacturers of automobiles and their parts on Wednesday lost their last hope when the cabinet approved a negative list for trade with India which will be phased out by the end of this year, believing this will massively hurt the country’s auto industry.
After months of deliberations with different industries and inter-ministerial dialogue, the government finally gave the go-ahead to the negative list containing 1,209 items, replacing the positive list, in an attempt to boost trade between the two countries.
The government had been facing strong resistance from different sectors which believed that the negative list should be phased out gradually over a number of years so that it would not hurt the domestic manufacturing industry. Among top advocates of the go-slow policy was the automobile industry.
Pakistan Association of Automotive Parts and Accessories Manufacturers (Paapam) Chairman Syed Nabeel Hashmi told The Express Tribune that the government’s decision to phase out the negative list in just a few months was going to badly hurt the automobile industry.
“We had asked the government to give at least four to five years to the domestic industry before phasing out the negative trade list with India,” he said.
“This is all drama. Despite our reservations, the government has taken this decision which will cost us a lot,” Hashmi said. “The government had decided long ago what it had to do and this is what we are seeing now.”
Hashmi said Pakistan’s auto part manufacturers exported to different parts of the world, but they could not ship their products to India because of non-tariff barriers. “The government is not supporting us in our issues,” he said.
“As far as I think, this decision will lead to an increase in import of Indian products in Pakistan. And eventually all our auto manufacturing units will shift abroad because of unhealthy manufacturing environment in the country,” he said.
Some analysts believe that the phasing out of the negative list is aimed at paving the way for the South Asia Free Trade Agreement (Safta), which the two countries want to implement quickly.
Atlas Honda, the biggest motorcycle manufacturer in Pakistan, has also expressed fear over the cabinet move.
General Manager Corporate Affairs Razi-ur-Rahman said it would significantly increase import of Indian motorcycles in the country because of a significant reduction in duties.
At present, Pakistan imports completely built units (CBUs), or finished motorcycles, from China at 65 per cent duty. The cabinet decision will bring the duty to just 20 per cent in 2012 and then 0-5 per cent in 2013 in trade with India, which will make it very easy to import motorcycles.
Pakistani manufacturers believe that India with the help of non-tariff barriers tries to block their exports. However, Delhi insists that it does not discriminate against Pakistan’s export products at any level. Despite these differences, both the governments have vowed to remove all misconceptions and significantly boost bilateral trade in coming years.
This huge loss to the auto industry, however, is a clear win-win situation for the consumers, who will get cheap products – motorcycles and cars.
For instance, the duty reduction from 65 per cent to 20 per cent will significantly reduce motorcycle prices in the retail market. On the other hand, carmakers will be able to import cheap Indian auto parts that they otherwise import from Thailand at higher prices.
Published in The Express Tribune, March 1st, 2012.
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
We had asked the government to give at least four to five years to the domestic industry before phasing out the negative trade list with India,” he said. Can someone explain to me what these guys have been doing so far and what do they want to do in next four years?
Time for the strong to survive and weak manufacturers to perish ....let there be trade with out Goverment interferance ....Hindu Muslim Sikh or Issaee all are welome in the arena of Global trade ...
What reservation they are talking about!!! ...Manufacturing low grade cars with over price tags...GIVE ME A BREAK Well this move will definitely bring a competitive atmosphere between automotive industry and that's the way forward and i whole heartily support this move. And for God Sake come out of this India Pakistan Dilemma and get over with it , we both Nation had already enough of it , just sweep the grudges against your interests. If European countries can open channel and trade after two world wars why can't we . They fought for almost two decades but for their own national interest they forgot everything, This is the high time we have to accept it and i m not ashamed in praising India at this point , that they have progressed immensely in last couple of years and we are like almost a decade behind in terms of economy and progression, but still hopes are their and Inshalalh as a Proud and Brave Nation we will progress again ...
@Pakistani: yes now you will get a better quality in every product...our auto parts are used by all major automobile companies....
The local auto manufacturers are not producing quality stuff but they are just dictating govt. We don’t need Mehran in 615K. We want quality and healthy competition.
Now quality will be the difference in every products.