Being a female helps tremendously as powerful circles in Pakistan believe that women are most effective in conveying messages to the world. A genuinely pretty face is not a prerequisite as long as the female has a man-attracting-magnetic personality, can speak English well, and falls in the category of a ‘liberal scum’ (most likely she will never be a true liberal). Although domestically numerous versions of females are now available, some of them original and other clones, to communicate the views of the ‘state within the state’, there is always the need for the superior version: the white-skinned female who can naturally speak with an accent and easily make inroads in the western system. A well-dressed woman with airs is certainly a huge advantage.
An appreciation of norms of research and inquiry is certainly not a prerequisite either in the country of origin or in Pakistan. The right instinct as a salesperson, who could sell anything from dishwashing liquid or a used car to a used idea, is essential. However, certain conditions can make the sales pitch extremely impressive. For instance, a couple of generals, senior bureaucrats and politicians in the pocket with whom you can demonstrate familiarity on a first-name basis works really well. It will be naturally assumed that these people have unloaded all national secrets on to your hard drive. Some of this may not be a fallacy as those in position of power feel extremely elated talking to a gora sahib or a mem sahib. They would love to boast about their power and knowledge which is nice since you can write a book after several such conversations. These people, who will willingly become your hosts during visits to Pakistan, will not even bother with what you have written about them and how they have been quoted as long as they are named in an international publication. This, of course, will increase your market at home where you will immediately be invited to talk shows on which Pakistan and the South Asian region are being discussed and taken seriously. Given the concern for security of their nationals in Pakistan, some western countries have started using its (Pakistan’s) non-gora nationals as well. However, the dark-complexioned ones have to work doubly hard for making clients in their countries of residence by first showing off deep contacts in their countries of origin. Of course, dropping names helps a lot as well. But for both, the coloured and white ‘rent-an-expert’ type, it helps to recount certain very private kinds of information. These details, then, help others in foreign capitals assume that the information you have as an expert on the whereabouts of bombs and booby traps is correct.
But the vital personal information requires that you first get close enough to the bigwigs in Pakistan for which a recommended recipe is initial investment in making contacts in the right circles. You will be lucky if you are a female and go through an established introducer in the country of origin. But once past the initial handshake it will be worthwhile to make initial contact successful which you can do by faking a genuine interest in the people, culture and country — and convincing your Pakistani clients of your access to the right circles in important western capitals.
As you get a chance to expand your circle you must remember to say the right things at the right time. For instance, words like ‘feudalism’, ‘clientist’ and so on are a sign of you knowing it all. Also, public claims regarding the state not being a failed one, will bring assured gains. Before long, you will become an author of a few books and an acclaimed expert.
Who says selling the soul to the devil doesn’t have benefits?
Published in The Express Tribune, March 1st, 2012.
COMMENTS (39)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Dr. Saheba! You could have done more better by deconstructing her instead of this. And one shouldn't be scared of annoying others.
Let's see which way this battle goes. Looking forward to a big debate between you and whosoever you mean. Let it be a declared one. Think aloud.
Genetic engineering or plain old evolution. You sound like someone who was left if not high certainly dry? Then, who are you calling colored? woman!
Sounds like someone is so angry, they can't make an argument!
naked truth and already knew.
naked truth.
Miss Siddiqa! Very well written criticism. Dot you think it is the problem of every developing country? problem is not Pakistan specific. Indeed we have to induct more Professionalism in our dealings and have to stay stick to our professional secrecy codes. This article, i should say is not a litany on any issue, it is a critical evaluation of behaviour of Pakistani professionals.. NOT AN AYESHA SIDDIQA TYPE ARTICLE..
A superb piece that sufficiently hints at those selling the country along the corridors of power. Unfortunately, only those in the know would know who Ayesha Siddiqa is referring too. Too bad, it could not be more explicit but there is a time for everything.
You had your turn Ms Ayesha!
You already tried to bring out weaknesses & negatives of Armed Forces;
Then, you were heard, Now let them be heard.
No jealousy, please.
Maria Sultan......................
Seems like the author is quite upset
And she's advising the chairman nab, because her research and analytical skills are very fine. If she can research and expose the whole inner dynamics of the military economy, means she can debunk other cases of corruption as well. Stop hating the people who show us our true faces.
Ayesha is a wonderful writer. This is a piece of satire and needs to be taken like satire, which bears the concealed truth present in the prevalent trends. Westerners are making money by posing as experts over the situation in our country by armchair theorizing. People come and spend a week here and then write books and then tell us about our own country. I mean what do you guys know other than making a few sweeping overgeneralizations about us. We know ourselves better.
Something burning! And why in the world you are advising the chairman NAB!
Another petty and spiteful article by Ayesha Siddiqa. Keep it up.
Is it Carey Schofield?
This is so funny! There are many names that come to mind like Anatol Leiven - the Pak fauj's new discovered love - the gori - Carey Schofield, Christine Fair, Raymond Moore, Stephen Cohen, Kim Barker. The local list is even longer.
Ouch, a hard hitting article about some Pakistani TV anchors perhaps. I was astounded at the ignorance of the interviewer in the following video - the level of strangeness to some of her questions and assertions was at an all time high:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uKZ18gQVSgo
@amadha: I think she is referring the one who has wrotten "Pakistan: a hard country " who is form kings college. can any one remind me his name?????
"Being a female helps tremendously as powerful circles in Pakistan believe that women are most effective in conveying messages to the world. A genuinely pretty face is not a prerequisite as long as the female has a man-attracting-magnetic personality, can speak English well, and falls in the category of a ‘liberal scum’ (most likely she will never be a true liberal). "
Are you referring to Sherry Rehman and Hina Khar? No matter who you are annoyed with, this article is not upto your usual high standards and is quite disappointing. It is clear that you are taking potshots at someone - just not sure who has earned your wrath and why.
Christine Fair is it ?
Very well written. But at the same time I felt it was too critical.
The author is right. When us common Pakistanis have to suffer the likes of Catriona Luke, I can only agree with what the author is stating
Although the lady seem furious at some Goree woman but this is the reality of our society what she presented
I always enjoy Ms. Siddiqa's articles that show mirror to our society. It is so real and could be analyzed who has the charm to be a success, only natural condition being 'white'.
Hi Ayesha, It would have been best to have some (remote) form of "perspective" and "direction" in your column so that the user could somehow relate your writing with something concrete.. I love reading your columns and I understand that sometimes not "all" could be revealed and subtlety and discretion is to be used, but I am really lost in trying to decipher a clear message - over and above that gora-sahib does well in this land of kala-people :) What else..? Any examples ? Any names ? Regards Geronimo
A bit disappointed by this piece. Not everyone is out there to sell their soul. Dr. Siddiqa you can do better!!
Another great Op Ed nicely written by A. S. I think Mansoor Ijaz and Hina come to mind right away. I am not very familiar with the "local gems" though.
she is basically referring to Christina Fair
There is another way to be an expert and glorified. All you need is to be a woman and go to India for few visits. Bash Pakistan publicly in India and get a chance to meet Bal Takuray... On your return you will be witness your glory
Begum Sahib,
Although there is a grain of truth in your thesis, such cynicism is not becoming of you. I always throught you stood on a higher pedestal and far from the "maddening crowd".
I could turn this around and say if she is white she has an agenda and must perforce be treated with suspicion; if she is of the local wheat-complexioned variety, and no matter how alluring, she could not possibly know more than you do because only YOU know the "ground realities".
That's good to hear.
If you do not sell your soul to the devil "they" make a devil out of you.If someone does not agree with this,he can give it a try
lolzz...it seems the author is angry at some lady who has become more famous than the author! I would love to find out the name of this new 'mysterious expert' though ;)
Hmm, why the author is so upset? Can't she name names of the rented experts so that the readers can also be informed.
Agree with the most part that much of the information on PAK is given to the world by half baked cookies and overnight experts, but in the end what they inform is not wholly untrue-partial picture but nevertheless true.
If Hamid Gul can get into international forum, so can real domestic experts. There are people who listen to the author's kind in international forum, as well. Several articles in NY times, WSJ, New Yorker, Newsweek have quoted authors view also.
When Musharaff wrote his self styled autobiography, people in the west expected that it would give an honest picture and make a case for Pakistan. Instead, it was self boasting and full of errors and gave the impression that all Pakistan leaders are megalomaniac in the end.